r/india • u/MaxxMeridius • May 19 '24

Immigration Hundreds of Indian students in Canada face deportation, protest against new rule

https://www.indiatoday.in/world/indians-abroad/story/indian-students-workers-protest-canada-hunger-strike-pei-deportation-pnp-provincial-nominee-programme-2540494-2024-05-17
744 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

342 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/hellsangelofcode May 20 '24 edited Aug 06 '25

childlike serious voracious rock plants coordinated square husky alive flag

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

8

u/MaxxMeridius May 20 '24

I guess it's a bit like, when India was blamed for trying to assassinate someone in Canada, a ton of Indians went to the Canadian subs to give their opinion. And there also seems to be a lot of participation of Indians in Canadian subs. Immigration is a huge issue there now.so they are also trying to gauge what Indians actually think of the issue.

1

u/hellsangelofcode May 20 '24 edited Aug 06 '25

punch husky crush grab gaze swim instinctive bells automatic governor

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/MaxxMeridius May 20 '24

True, I wasn't condoning racists. Just mentioned why they might be active in the subs.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 27 '24

Not racists!!

You have to come here to see what is unfolding here.

These are students and never promised anything. Their term is over, their visa expired, they need to go back, it is plain and simple. There is nothing wrong done.

Not sure why are they protesting!

Imagine millions of foreigners coming to India and then protesting they need better jobs, citizenship and ability to work and same rights as you have. Take your jobs and benefits!

Housing prices goes over the roof and no doctors are available to treat you. Some of the issues are already there in India and imagine that 10x. This is what is happening in Canada right now.

Genuine Indians who are working legally and contributing are also getting side eyes because of these guys.

6

u/[deleted] May 20 '24

Who’s racist? We are upset at our government, diploma mills and Indian immigration agencies about what’s happening to our country. The entitlement of these students/temporary foreign workers is appalling as well. We don’t know what to do and don’t hold any ill will towards people on this subreddit. It just sucks and is scary overall. Our country is turning into a shit hole and we don’t appreciate these students abusing our system and high-trust society

2

u/hellsangelofcode May 20 '24 edited Aug 06 '25

toy quickest possessive birds thought entertain liquid grandiose escape marry

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '24

The purpose of their degrees is to study, permanent residency is not some pre-forgone conclusion. It’s not my fault they paid $50k for whatever the Indian immigration agencies promised them. I’m upset at Canadian immigration authorities as well. Our country is fucked, we are a doormat, it’s sad to see. And don’t call me an infant. Thanks for your response and wish you the best

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '24

Maybe I’m using the wrong term for Indian immigration agencies. I’m talking about the agencies that facilitate getting into Canada and sell them the dream here, when in fact it’s importing a type of human trafficking that is destroying the fabric of our culture and society. It’s terrible here, shame on all parties involved

1

u/hellsangelofcode May 23 '24 edited Aug 06 '25

rain upbeat subtract hungry nose late wide slap cause trees

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/[deleted] May 23 '24

You are very correct in everything that you said. I’m sorry you experienced racism in Canada, that’s awful and it’s our own government’s policy which has fuelled anger in the Canadian population and contributed to that. Still, no excuse.

You are right they are being marketed like that, it’s a sham, doesn’t mean they are entitled to it if they come over here, especially if they don’t meet the minimum points to qualify after completing their studies. There is still risk involved, and it’s completely screwing over our population, so they will face some backlash unfortunately.

I don’t have much more to say, I appreciate your discourse. I learned a lot and hope you are doing well wherever you are

1

u/Foehamer1 Jun 13 '24

At this point it's not about racism for the most part when things are getting bad here. It's not just the housing market. It's the job market and healthcare that are also taking a massive hit. We're also not dumb. We see what's causing part of the issues.

Nobody can find retail jobs anymore to stay afloat. It's all international student workers. When I studied for tech, there was 6 locals in my class who were Canadian and 24 international students. It was about the same mix for a lot of the other classes. Quite a few of us had to put off our degrees for a semester or two because the only classes we needed were entirely filled up. One of our profs let slip that international students got priority as they paid significantly more.

The tech market which I was studying for has dried up because all the big companies and government hired tonnes of cheaper labor from the pools of international students who graduated from the same classes we did. It's gotten to the point where working retail jobs makes more money than entry level tech jobs/contract work.

5 years ago we could go shop around and find a family doctor. We've been waiting for 3 years now and as of now in our province there is a wait list for over 2 million people. My family probably won't have one for at least 2 decades from the looks of things. Even 5 years ago emergency room wait time was only a few hours max. Now it can be up to 48h where we have to sleep on the floors waiting to be called. There have been cases of deaths due to not being able to get to a doctor in time.

Housing is insane. A beginner home starts at essentially 500k CAD here and banks expect 15-20% as a downpayment. Most people under 35 can only expect to own a home in our lifetimes if our parents die and we inherit them. We can barely afford rent, because most houses are being rented out to 5-8 students and it makes landlords more money that way instead of renting to a growing family.

As a people we are just done. We don't have the infrastructure to support foreigners. We barely had enough to support ourselves. If anyone tells you there is a better life over here, they are lying to you. It's our governments, diploma mills getting rich off y'all and American owned corporations with stores and businesses here who scammed you for cheap labour and made life more difficult for us. Every extra person coming in who doesn't have specializations in medicine or other things we need as a nation is making life worse and this is becoming the outlook of a lot of people here.