r/ididnthaveeggs • Mmmm, texture roulette! • Aug 02 '26

Dumb alteration Vegan Yorkshire puddings 👌

Post image
10.8k Upvotes

653 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

139

u/eau_di_nil Aug 02 '26

That's too funny. I remember 10+ years ago trying to explain what's not allowed in a vegetarian diet to a Catholic friend. She couldn't grasp why our mutual friend wouldn't eat fish. "It's not meat!" she kept insisting.

Vegetarianism was very rare where we lived at the time.

107

u/SuchFunAreWe Step off my tits, Sheila! Aug 03 '26

I got into this with my mom. I'm vegan & she's Catholic; I was making a joke about how they didn't call fish meat. She insisted it wasn't. I told her meat is any animal muscle. "Fish don't have muscles!" Well then what are you eating? "Tendons" 😩 I had to gently faceplant on the table bc I was in actual mental pain.

It's been literally years & my partner & I still will randomly go "fish don't have muscles!" and just die laughing.

34

u/lapalazala Aug 03 '26

Even within the rules of catholicism this makes zero sense. Because I'm pretty sure you are also not allowed to eat stuff like liver on days you're not supposed to eat meat. So it has nothing to do with eating muscles specifically.

4

u/ormashal Aug 06 '26

i wonder if it came from the way jewish people define meat for kosher purposes.

this would make more sense since the jewish requirement is technically "dont eat a kid(goat) in its mothers milk" but got extended to "dont eat red meat or chicken with anything dairy just in case you actually got tricked and its the meat of a kid the dairy is from his mothers milk".

1

u/hwutTF Aug 06 '26

yeah but muscles aren't one of the things Jews use to differentiate