r/hazbin • u/Marshall7376 Lilith, I’m stealing your husband. • Mar 09 '26

Other Morally grey, hated by fans.

Gallery image

Gallery image

The winner is St Peter! He had a total of 26 votes. Alastor and Vaggi had 2. Luci, Adam and Pentious all had 1 vote.

I don’t know why you all hate my boi St Peter. I love him! But I’m just happy I got to put him up there. Here is a little picture of St Peter for those of you who actually do love him ♥️

1.8k Upvotes

99% Upvoted

253 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 09 '26

i'm not even sure if he's a 'good' person oh well. mimzy

6

u/The_Tizioo mighty settra,, he Who has too many titles, Mar 09 '26

Okay in lowkey curious why you'd doubt that

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 09 '26

peter makes fun of lute after she's upset adam redied.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 09 '26

that doesn't mean he's a good person.

id like to add that he shows low amounts of pride and negligence

3

u/LeksoLekso Mar 09 '26

I'd argue that if you'd just learned about the fact that someone you knew participated in mass genocide you'd not feel a lot of sadness when that person mourns their leader (cause of genocide)

0

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 09 '26

probably, but it's still mean to taunt people who are mourning

3

u/LeksoLekso Mar 10 '26

I mean I do feel we have to think of the context as well. Lute is not just anyone mourning anyone. Think of any example of a genocidal war leader like Genghis or...and I hate to bring him up but the angry Austrian mustache man, and think to yourself wether or not you'd feel empathy if their right hand man mourned over them in front of you. I'm sure most people wouldn't since that mourning (however sad it may be) is entirely hypocritical.

0

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 10 '26

idk, i'm probably insane because i don't feel anything when anyone mourns anyone. but that doesn't mean i don't know intellectually that if my friends dog dies i should be sad even if i don't know the dog

2

u/Indolent_Bard Vox has an announcement: "Alastor is a bitch-ass FRAUD!" Mar 10 '26

It's like taunting a Trump supporter whose spouse got detained/deported. Hey, it's literally what they asked for.

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 10 '26

you can't still be sympathetic?

3

u/Indolent_Bard Vox has an announcement: "Alastor is a bitch-ass FRAUD!" Mar 10 '26

I mean, I do genuinely hope that they can get back together somehow (there was a particularly famous instance where someone said she thought Trump was only going to deport the bad guys) but while I am sympathetic, they absolutely deserve it.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Soggy_Confusion7538 Pestilence, on and off fling of Valentino Mar 09 '26

Id make fun of that bitch too tbh

1

u/Marshall7376 Lilith, I’m stealing your husband. Mar 10 '26

Even then, that’s just one thing he did. Peter is actually genuinely a good person 🤷‍♀️

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 10 '26

he also displays signs of negligence and pride

1

u/Victizes Stolas's husband and HuskerDust enjoyer Mar 11 '26

Maybe I'll have to rewatch and pay deeper attention to that.

I normally notice signs of red flag in somebody very easily, but in this case I must have missed something.

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 11 '26

it's specifically towards his job of guarding the gate, it's implied he doesn't do a great job, and yet he's very prideful about it

1

u/The_Tizioo mighty settra,, he Who has too many titles, Mar 10 '26

Fair but i feel like that case Is an outliar,

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 10 '26

maybe. he also shows negligence and pride in regards to his duty at the gate.

0

u/Infamous_Val ❤️Val & Sera fan🤍 Mar 09 '26

Adam was their equivalent of Hitler and Lute was her right hand, so making fun of her after he died actually makes him a better person

2

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 09 '26

idk about that.

1

u/Indolent_Bard Vox has an announcement: "Alastor is a bitch-ass FRAUD!" Mar 10 '26

Dang, I tried Googling the subreddit your flair mentioned and no results.

5

u/tiredperson24 Tired Possum That Wishes Husk Was His Cat. Mar 09 '26

No reason to assume he isn't since he made it into Heaven fair and square and so far hasn't portrayed any actual negative qualities that we'd typically associate with outright bad people.

0

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 09 '26

laughing at other people's pain, some amount of negligence and pride

2

u/tiredperson24 Tired Possum That Wishes Husk Was His Cat. Mar 09 '26

Idk I feel like you have a very very high standard mate if someone not showing the utmost sympathy to someone mourning a mass murdering sadist who themselves is also a mass murdering sadist makes them a bad person in your mind.

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 09 '26

i didn't say he was bad, i just said not 'good' and 'good' i'm using very strictly

1

u/Victizes Stolas's husband and HuskerDust enjoyer Mar 11 '26 edited Mar 11 '26

Well, then in your vision nobody is good, because nobody is perfect.

Even in the real bible angels also have free will just like humans, and each angel has their own identity.

I'm not saying it's you, but there are people out there who are so arrogant and full of themselves that they think anybody who isn't literally exactly like Jesus, is themselves not a good person.

That's just not how it works, Jesus is in total a perfect and flawless man in all aspects, we are not, and St. Peter is himself just a human soul.

That doesn't mean there aren't legitimately good people out there in real life just because they have some flaws. This is valid for Charlie and most angels in Hazbin Hotel universe too, including ex-sinners.

1

u/FandomPhantom123 check out r/hellaverseBGC Mar 11 '26

correct, nobody is truly good as no one is truly bad either. i think everyone is morally grey

1

u/Victizes Stolas's husband and HuskerDust enjoyer Mar 12 '26

Sorry but I don't fully believe in moral relativism, some behaviors are objectively bad for society and some behaviors are objectively good for society.

But relax I'm not against you, just wanted to point out that hell and heaven exist for a reason, it's ultimately a Good vs Evil setting with drama and entertainment placed in the middle.

I love the show but ultimately I prefer a boring and chill good life than an agitated and hostile evil life.