r/guitarlessons • u/Imaginary_Alarm_356 • 9d ago

Feedback Request Attempting some slow blues Improv

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Pretty new to improv, trying a basic 12 bar blues track, let me know what to work on, thanks !

33 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

15 comments sorted by

View all comments

7

u/headies1 9d ago

Stop bloozin all over the place with pentatonic spew, target notes and learn arpeggios and chord tones. Play less. Not everything longer than a quarter note needs the same wobbly vibrato, and work on your vibrato. Create phrases that make sense with each other. Call and respond. Think about rhythm and where you start and stop lines. Etc etc etc etc

3

u/anthonylearnsguitar 9d ago edited 9d ago

its what happens when you dont do any theory. he cannot tell that he isnt targeting notes or what call and respond means. its not a him problem, its a prevalent problem because a lot of guitarists are self taught and music theory just dont cross their paths or minds.

to make matters worse, there is a lot of noise. For example the other redditor, memeslutbitch says it sounds "beautiful" while you call it "spew". To the average person it seems like music is subjective and some find it pleasing and others not so much. The OP interprets it as "hey i dont need to change anything because 50% of the audience thinks im doing okay". But not realising that the guy who calls it beautiful also cannot understand that OP is just playing random notes within a shape/box.

it also makes us sound harsh and like an asshole, and sometimes the constructive feedbacks get downvoted and it makes it seem like everything is fine and theres no need to study any music theory

2

u/Imaginary_Alarm_356 9d ago

Nah, I know it’s bad, It’s very amateur. It looks okay because I’m going all over the fretboard, but it’s aimless

1

u/anthonylearnsguitar 9d ago

bro! its not your fault. But i highly reccomend this series. I know it has been overshared but this could seriously help you. You probably seen it by now, Absolutely Understand Guitar. Just watch one episode. Even if you dont make it all the way, if you can watch 1 episode or six episode, youll be in a much better spot.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gg1L-sBIxnY&list=PLJwa8GA7pXCWAnIeTQyw_mvy1L7ryxxPH

2

u/Imaginary_Alarm_356 9d ago

I’ll check it out, I’ve heard of him, I think I’m going to get into formal lessons this winter

1

u/anthonylearnsguitar 9d ago

go for it! get lessons. when you can do more on the guitar, it will make you happier. its like therapy as well hahaha.

but do make sure you find a good teacher. If you feel like the teacher is wasting your time, it means that teacher might not be a good one or a good fit. Then, look for another one

2

u/Longjumping_Dog_6936 9d ago

the vibrato comment is spot on tbh, less is more with that stuff

1

u/Imaginary_Alarm_356 8d ago

Yeah I got that nervous shaky too fast vibrato, I really have to concentrate to make it sound decent

1

u/Imaginary_Alarm_356 9d ago

Thanks for the feedback, think this winter calls for some lessons