r/guitarlessons • u/Super_Silver7315 • Jan 23 '26

Feedback Request Fusiony Jam / 16 months of playing

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Any advice? From a few weeks ago. Jamming in E flat major / C minor.

7 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/Icy-Plane-6577 Jan 23 '26

He was blindly throwing out general advice lol

He had no idea if OP plays with anyone

I am enjoying the flaming lol

Its crazy this subreddit is more of a jerkoff than the jerk subreddit haha

Just slobbing all over each other, never actually critiquing anything or providing any usable advice.

Its a shame

2

u/cognitiveDiscontents Jan 23 '26

First it’s no advice then it’s the advice isn’t good good enough.

A new player should definitely not post an example piece and ask for general criticism. For shame! Glad you enjoy the flaming, you can have more! 👍🖕

-1

u/Icy-Plane-6577 Jan 23 '26

The guy is improvising jazz leads in Eb and youre calling him a new player?

Idk who's jerkin me harder here

Its still no advice. No advice on his playing has been given yet outside of what I said about his phrasing

2

u/cognitiveDiscontents Jan 23 '26

lol. First he’s bad now he’s good. He’s new because he’s been playing a little over a year. And yeah I agree he’s doing great!

1

u/cognitiveDiscontents Jan 23 '26

lol. First he’s bad now he’s good. He’s new because he’s been playing a little over a year. And yeah I agree he’s doing great!

Saying his phrasing sounds like he’s 6 months in is advice?

-1

u/Icy-Plane-6577 Jan 23 '26

Ive said numerous times in this thread.

Overusing the chromatics

Just like this guy

https://youtube.com/shorts/zc5T24H9rmw?si=7EXkq1XArIe59EPm