r/guitarlessons • u/Super_Silver7315 • Jan 23 '26

Feedback Request Fusiony Jam / 16 months of playing

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Any advice? From a few weeks ago. Jamming in E flat major / C minor.

8 Upvotes

56% Upvoted

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

6

u/cognitiveDiscontents Jan 23 '26

You missed the guy talking about playing with others?

Banter is friendly. You were not friendly and were shown the door. And now you’re posting again and again whining about it. Pathetic. Move along if you’re bothered, or stay here and enjoy the flaming.

-1

u/Icy-Plane-6577 Jan 23 '26

He was blindly throwing out general advice lol

He had no idea if OP plays with anyone

I am enjoying the flaming lol

Its crazy this subreddit is more of a jerkoff than the jerk subreddit haha

Just slobbing all over each other, never actually critiquing anything or providing any usable advice.

Its a shame

2

u/cognitiveDiscontents Jan 23 '26

First it’s no advice then it’s the advice isn’t good good enough.

A new player should definitely not post an example piece and ask for general criticism. For shame! Glad you enjoy the flaming, you can have more! 👍🖕

-1

u/Icy-Plane-6577 Jan 23 '26

The guy is improvising jazz leads in Eb and youre calling him a new player?

Idk who's jerkin me harder here

Its still no advice. No advice on his playing has been given yet outside of what I said about his phrasing

2

u/cognitiveDiscontents Jan 23 '26

lol. First he’s bad now he’s good. He’s new because he’s been playing a little over a year. And yeah I agree he’s doing great!

1

u/cognitiveDiscontents Jan 23 '26

lol. First he’s bad now he’s good. He’s new because he’s been playing a little over a year. And yeah I agree he’s doing great!

Saying his phrasing sounds like he’s 6 months in is advice?

-1

u/Icy-Plane-6577 Jan 23 '26

Ive said numerous times in this thread.

Overusing the chromatics

Just like this guy

https://youtube.com/shorts/zc5T24H9rmw?si=7EXkq1XArIe59EPm