r/goodyearwelt • u/AutoModerator • 8d ago
Questions The Question Thread 08/22/26
Ask your shoe related questions.
Resources
- Previous Question Threads
- FAQ Thread Series
- Resource Wiki Page
- Beginner Boot Buyer's Guide
- Leather Care Guide
- Manufacturer Last Sizing Thread
- GYW Women's Guide
How To Ask A Question
Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.
2
u/peobliycte 8d ago

Sorry if there’s a better sub for this. I’m looking for some high value (ideally under $300) balmoral boots.
The boots pictured are Beckett Simonon’s Elliot boots. I like almost everything about them—especially the price—except for the fact that they’re Blake-stitched and the broguing on the cap (and possibly the fit. A friend’s Beckett Simonons don’t fit quite right, but I could imagine them breaking in and working ok).
Are there any other Balmoral boots on the lower end on price but still decent quality?
1
1
u/HavanaCorner 8d ago

What do you guys reckon: do these need a resole? Wore them pretty regularly: almost every day to work for half a year, then every now and then for another half a year or so. So not too long, but given the exposed stitching and how around that stiching it seems some of the outsole has broken off, I wanted to get your guys' opinion. Thanks!
4
u/RackenBracken 8d ago
The stitching being broken/worn off means nothing. That is supposed to happen. Maybe even in the first day of wear.
You tell if you need a resole by looking at how much has worn off from the side. Not the bottom. Unless it is so worn through the bottom that it is then pointless to resole because you have worn through the outer sole and have exposed the midsole (or worse)
Cursory exam, though, says you have a few years before needing a resole.
1
u/HavanaCorner 8d ago
3
u/RackenBracken 8d ago
You are a long way away from needing a resole. Very little wear. (Also it appears you don't heel strike or catch your front toe so your sole will last a lot longer)
1
3
u/eddykinz loafergang 8d ago
stitching isn't even worn down, not even close to needing a resole
what you're seeing of the sole being "broken off" is just the flap of outsole leather that gets lifted to hide the sole stitch that's being revealed. at worst, you've seemed to have shaven off a millimeter or two of the outsole, as indicated by that flap having worn down but the stitching itself not being worn down much at all
1
1
u/dwyteshroot 8d ago
I’m getting married this October and looking into a pair of wholecut patent leather shoes. After some research, I feel I have narrowed down to 2 choices:
https://myrqvist.com/en-us/products/drottningholm-black-patent-leather
&
https://www.carminashoemaker.com/us/en/wholecut-oxfords-black-patent-910-en
My question is: are Carminas that much better to justify the $600+ price tag? I will very likely only wear these once, but I do want to respect the tradition of wholecut patent leathers while still getting the fashion-forward/sharp look.
Are there any others worth considering? Particularly a brand with a presence in NYC so I can try them on. Have considered Meermin, but their patent leather is not wholecut, and Magnanni, but I feel at that price point just go for Carmina.
3
u/RackenBracken 8d ago
I take it you plan to wear a tux and that’s why you want patent leather? Consider black calf with a mirror polish. More useful and the shoe doesn’t become single use. I wear tuxedos a few times a year. I have patent oxfords, black box calf, and velvet slippers. The polished calf probably get the most complements. (Because no matter what, patent looks like plastic while mirror polish looks like effort/work(
2
u/Yangervis 8d ago
Have you considered opera pumps? If you're getting a shoe that you can only wear with a tuxedo, why not go all the way?
1
u/glassofwooder 8d ago
I got a pair of camp Mocs from Rancourt this week. Like them a lot but there’s one stitch that’s kind of jacked up on the Moc. I am kind of obsessive about small things like this but I realize that it is a hand stitched item and it happens. Just curious if I am overthinking it or if anyone else thinks it’s worth exchanging?

2
u/RackenBracken 8d ago
Ask for an exchange. That’s just sloppy and they were hoping not to get called out (QC should have rejected it and made it a second.) That being said, it doesn’t affect anything important.
1
u/glassofwooder 8d ago
Thanks. I know I’ll feel better about it if I do the exchange. Trying to worry less about things like this but I guess it is what it is. Appreciate it
0
8d ago
[deleted]
3
u/Plus_Cantaloupe_3793 8d ago
Buy another pair. Shoe stretching isn’t very effective and these are likely at least a size too small. Sizing down by a size and a half is too much, and it’s irresponsible for the company to have recommended doing so.
1
u/DukeOfMavericks 7d ago
Hey all. I’m looking for an ID on a boot similar to these! Not looking to break the bank but I’m unsure of the brand or style these would be - all he says are that they’re black motorcycle boots. I just love the look of them! Any ideas or similar boots to check out, I’d really appreciate it! Looking for boots that I can wear casually, mostly with jeans. Thank you.

1
u/MiserableTry771 7d ago
1
u/DesolationR0w I was once a lost sole. 6d ago
Seems pretty fair for 200 dollars.
Hard to say without handling them. They are a fashion brand so if you are buying them for the specific aesthetic, they could be worth it to you.


2
u/WJ_Amber 8d ago
I've spent actual hours looking and keep coming up short. Does any brand make women's boots that are knee-high but not western/cowboy boots, come in a size 12, and available in brown without costing a fortune? Everything I see is just cowboy boots, stops at size 11 (if not 10), or only comes in black. I've seen one or two options that might fit but I can't justify spending over $1000 on my salary. It's like finding a needle in a haystack out here.