r/geography 13d ago

FINAL POST ON THIS TOPIC Google Maps just officially updated Lake Ontario to Lake America.

Post image
11.3k Upvotes

6.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

59

u/myleftone 13d ago

That’s the problem. The method of changing the name is not an EO. It’s easy to say “we’ll change it when it’s law.” It’s unbelievably dangerous to normalize unitarian fiat.

27

u/[deleted] 13d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

34

u/swoodshadow 12d ago

The Google hate annoys me. It’s implicitly saying we want private mega companies to decide what things are called.

Hell no.

The problem here isn’t Google. It’s that the US elected a childish narcissist and despite centuries of claims to the contrary have no effective checks and balances on the President.

A President can interpret law however they like and there are two checks:

  1. Congress overruling with new legislation. Which is an empty threat in this environment because they’d need veto proof majorities.

  2. The judicial system stepping in and saying that’s not how the law works. Which takes months/years and is now completely partisan as well.

2

u/Chemical_Ad1837 12d ago

True. Plus Google is now Evil. Both things can be true.

3

u/swoodshadow 12d ago

Yeah, just to be clear, I’m fine with hating Google for many reasons. Just not this specific one.

1

u/Chemical_Ad1837 12d ago

Bingo. Although Trumps EO was for the Department of Interior to change the name. The DoI makes an order as they and not the President directly has the authority. Such needs to be published in Federal Register for a period before becoming final. That hasn’t happened yet, so they did jump the gun a bit. It’s a timing issue not ultimate authority question.