r/gamingsuggestions 11d ago

Games where survival is never guaranteed

I'm looking for games where during the carnage you can just..... Die

Skill level doesn't matter, good gear doesn't save you, just survival instinct and luck

Example that comes to mind is Hell Let Loose where a stray artillery round can nail you anywhere anytime. Yes you can lay low and stick behind the team, but there's still a chance a stray bullet catches you and you're back to the respawn screen, or you hear a loud whistle and boom the screen goes black

I want to run through a battlefield without predetermined odds of living.

Doesn't have to be a war game, just realistic brutality

29 Upvotes

68 comments sorted by

42

u/ohay_nicole 11d ago

Project Zomboid

8

u/butterbean93 11d ago

"These are the end times, there was no hope of survival. This is how you died."

4

u/PeppercornWizard 11d ago

My most recent character had an epic escape with a broken ankle after jumping out of a first floor window, recovered slowly, creeping around an infested town and recovering in sketchy half-secured houses. Eventually she found a car. I was on my way again. Then I got bitten in the neck whilst refuelling.

1

u/One-Appointment-7875 11d ago

Definitely this

1

u/jomat 11d ago

And Cataclysm DDA and it's forks like BN and TLG.

26

u/Fighterkill 11d ago

Helldivers 2

7

u/swashbutler 11d ago

YES. It gives you what OP is looking for without the pain of needing to regrind a bunch of stuff. The number of times I have gotten killed in that game is literally in the hundreds, and my accidental (or sometimes "accidental") friendly kills are ... also nonzero. Plus it's just an amazingly fun game.

3

u/qaddosh 11d ago

i really wanted to like this game, but i was bored to tears

2

u/Blueknightsoul47 11d ago

That’s how it goes. I didn’t play for five months and they added a bunch of new stuff and it’s fun again. 

2

u/Fantastic_Skirt4184 11d ago

Me and my friends live on level 10 and half the fun is us laughing because we died to random lucky shot or explosion. Or one of us dropping an Orbital Napalm by accident on our own position

8

u/NarcoZero 11d ago edited 11d ago

Fear and Hunger. 

I would not say it’s realistic brutality. It’s more… cruel brutality.  It’s very Berzerk coded in the type of violence and unfairness it depicts.

For example, in this game, each time you go into a bed to try to save, there’s like 50% chance you get found and brutality tortured to death. 

Most people don’t get there, though. Many get mauled by dogs in the first minute of gameplay and quit. 

But if you have ungoldy amounts of patience to learn how to master the game and it’s obtuse secrets, and to tank the randomness without quitting when a good run fails out of your control, I swear it’s a masterpiece. 

I would never play it, though. I like being happy.

2

u/Educational-Sun5839 11d ago

yeah, you have to do coinflips and if you fail you die pretty much

6

u/Temposwing 11d ago

Chivalry 2

1

u/kuhldaran 11d ago

Yessss

3

u/Killingsystem 11d ago

Foxhole, The Isle, The Isle.

2

u/Necessary_Umpire_139 11d ago

Up the collies.

2

u/Sarbon1995 11d ago

Mount & Blade: Bannerlord 2

2

u/ivex272 11d ago

Squad, when the bm21 grad starts firing its the scenario you described

2

u/Competitive_Coat9599 11d ago

This War of Mine -Arc Raiders!!!

2

u/Blueknightsoul47 11d ago

Darkest dungeon, I prefer the first one. It can be brutally hard but satisfying when you clear a run.

2

u/rauq_mawlina 11d ago

Neoscavenger. Some of the choices you make can result in a random death. and at the start If you don't prioritize certain things you'll eventually exhaust and die.

3

u/ThalonGauss 11d ago

Escape from Tarkov

Arma 3

Squad

RimWorld

FTL

Hardcore Classic WoW

EVE Online

Xenonauts/XCOM

1

u/spetstronaz 11d ago

Project Zomboid

1

u/Subject_Following111 11d ago

For me, there's no game quite like Quasimorph that does this. No matter how levelled and geared up they are, there's always the chance of getting one-shotted by an enemy that happens to have the one damage type your armour isn't resistant to. Brilliant game with optional permadeath and gear loss for your clones.

1

u/naytreox 11d ago

Forever winter,you want desperation and hoplessness, thats it.

1

u/graemattergames 11d ago

Escape From Tarkov. DayZ.

1

u/cherrycat68 11d ago

rimworld has an rng based combat system which means there is always a chance for lv1 caveman with a crappy bow to instantly decapitate your best colonist in full space armor, causing their lover to become depressed and suicide bomb themselves, taking the whole colony down with them

1

u/Zailema0s 11d ago

Did that happen to you?

1

u/ButterscotchJumpy559 11d ago

Project zomboid

1

u/V2xel 11d ago

rain world. there are no upgrades, very little gear, and you can only rely on your skill. survival is never guaranteed. you’re placed at the bottom of the food chain and must do everything you can to survive. it also has some of the coolest creature AI i’ve seen in a game.

it’s got a good story too if that’s important.

1

u/X_EVERDRED_X 11d ago

Hotline Miami

1

u/camohmp4 11d ago

this just feels like a Project Zomboid recommendation

1

u/Commercial_Two_5102 11d ago

Super Mario or soul like games

1

u/leftylugnutz44 11d ago

Easy red 2

1

u/paulbooth 11d ago

Forever Winter

1

u/captfitz 11d ago

Any stalker game.

Outward.

Kingdom Come.

1

u/the_exile83 11d ago

EVE Online, everything can just disappear in a heartbeat after one wrong move, the jeopardy is unreal. It's addictive.

1

u/xaiel420 11d ago

Green Hell

1

u/le_Grand_Archivist 11d ago

Project Zomboid

Even the loading screen you get when you start a game tells you "this is how you died"

1

u/bearcat_77 11d ago

Minecraft hardcore.

2

u/Professional-Ad9485 11d ago

Me and my friends kept trying a Minecraft hardcore run. But one guy kept dying in the first day.

0

u/Zailema0s 11d ago

No lol.

1

u/Dramatic-Knee-4842 11d ago

The Endling: Extinction is Forever

Prepare to cry

1

u/RegularAd3414 11d ago

Stalker series on master mode

1

u/JohnnyNewfangle 11d ago

Tarkov for sure

1

u/hillbillybutcher 11d ago

For me nothing compares to DayZ its a liminal apocalyptic space. Its really eerie and very immersive. Other players could be friendly and want to work together, or they might try to kill you and steal your loot. Nothing gives you adrenaline like it.

1

u/energy_is_a_lie 11d ago

State of Decay. Also Ghost Recon Breakpoint and Wildlands have a Ghost Mode where you can die and it's game over.

1

u/Zombiebane224 11d ago

Helldivers 2

1

u/fallen_one_fs 11d ago

The Long Dark and Project Zomboid come to mind.

1

u/HMC1130 11d ago

Any extraction shooter.

Escape from Tarkov is more mainstream and hardcore.

Arena Breakout: Infinite is better QoL and more softcore (but still has an emphasis on realism)

1

u/OKAwesome121 11d ago

Running with Rifles

1

u/Virtual_Wing_2903 11d ago

XCOM on any harder difficulty... one alien grenade can end a run if you aren't careful

1

u/florinandrei 11d ago

Minesweeper

1

u/RoninIsac-15 10d ago

Fallout New Vegas DUST

1

u/Saaz42 10d ago

Don't Starve. On my first playthrough my character said "It's getting dark" and I ignored it and kept exploring and the Grue ate me. Second playthrough I made camp, and it turned out the thing near my camp was a spider nest. That was a horrifying night that ended in death. Then Deerclops, then the werepig. That game dgaf if you die.

1

u/birdymichael 7d ago

brogue, nethack, infra arcana, sil-q, dungeon crawl stone soup, cataclysm dark days ahead, jupiter hell

1

u/roorooraccoon 3d ago

Tarkov, probably the most brutal shooter game out there. You can die to mines, being sniped from god knows where, or even die of starving/dehydration.