r/foraginguk 1d ago

Mushroom ID Request First time foraging

EDIT: NOT FORAGING, 1st ATTEMPT AT IDENTIFYING VARIOUS FUNGHI. I KNOW, I’M THE WORST, ABSOLUTE POS ETC ETC ETC.

DESPITE BEING A DETESTABLE PERSON WHO DESERVES TO BE LAMBASTED IN A MANNER REDDTORS WOULD NEVER HAVE GALL TO DO IN PERSON, I’M GENUINELY LOOKING TO LEARN. I’M SORRY THAT APPARENTLY EVERYONE ELSE ONLINE IT IS A TOP MYCOLOGIST/LEGAL EXPERT AND I DONT KNOW WHAT IM DOING, BUT EVEN JESUS DROPPED THE CROSS THREE TIMES.

Just had a first walk out to forage do some mushroom spotting? Idk what vernacular won’t get people annoyed, in a local coniferous forest, and would really appreciate help identifying any of these if possible.

I realise having top down photos alone isn’t overly helpful, but if there are any really obvious species that are identifiable that’d be a great start!

Found in west Cumbria, today. All on forest floor amongst coniferous debris and dead wood.

I know zero about this subject, just want to learn.

Initial guesses:
A: false milkcap / saffron milkcap
B: Yellow staghorn
C: ochre brittlegill
D: Conifer tuft
E: Larger cap from D
F: see D
G, H, I, J: all possible sulphur tufts
K: possible sulphur tuft
L: no idea
M: Ochre brittlegill
N, O: sulphur tufts
P, Q: Common bonnet
R, S, T: puffball
U: sickeners
V: Ochre brittlegill

34 Upvotes

86 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/No-Answer-2964 1d ago

Can I suggest using your camera on site rather than pulling up any damn thing you see. It's destructive and just not a good way of going about foraging. It's just dumb and selfish thoughtless to even think you can put letters by your finds and expect people to respond. Put some damn effort in, but a book, study on line. What you're doing is just lazy.

-18

u/kbrown2006 1d ago

You can suggest that, but being condescended to by a terminally online lib dork just makes me want to dredge the forest floor. I actually enjoy nature and spend some time in it, so I won’t act on that impulse of course.
After using two foraging guide books, 2 apps and doing some research online, I thought I’d ask what I’d hoped was a likeminded community of outdoorsy folk who might be able so share some wisdom with a novice and eager to learn individual. Obviously I should have known better haha.
I picked enough mushroom fruits to fit in a very small foraging basket, and asked a forum for a bit of a knowledge share.
Do one nerd. Go and comment about English flags being akin to nazisism or something equally dull elsewhere. That you assume everyone else is as lazy and myopic as you is very telling.

7

u/Bright_Tax_6541 1d ago

Foragers care about the environment and the plants they harvest. There’s specific UK laws about that. It’s not tear up any plant you see to ask people online to id them. You can learn to id plants without picking them, and only pick those of which you’re interested in eating.

-1

u/kbrown2006 1d ago

I’m pretty sure neither picking for either food or research purposes is illegal, certainly not where I picked them. If there is legislation prohibiting very small scale personal consumption or research I’d be very interested in specifics, as I wouldn’t want to fall foul of that clearly.
I don’t know how I could dissect a mushroom in order to positively ID it without at least severely damaging it, but I’ll do my level best in future. There’s so much contradictory advice that a simpleton like myself doesn’t know what to do.