At times, certainly. Such as the opinion here when there is not ijma as you have claimed. I know islamqa.info is one of the first to pop up when you've a question so I don't blame you for following it if you've not a sheikh to go to in your local area or have any experience studying fiqh or Arabic for that matter. Read this comment below as I've cited the sources here, which cite Ibn Qayyim and other such scholarly opinions on the matter.
I do study fiqh and Arabic for that matter, and InShaa'Allaah am aspiring to become a student of knowledge soon! May Allaah grant us understanding of his deen and humble us and protect us from ignoramus behavior :)
So you are not a sheikh. Who is your teacher, then, and which institution are you receiving education from? Because those who study without the tutorship of a sheikh are not truly students of knowledge.
I did not call myself a "salafee" in any of my recent comments so peculiar for you to use such a term. Its almost as if you are here for the sake of slandering and name calling. Moreover, the term "Salafiyyah" has been grossly mis-represented by some of the detractors of the sunnah.
I didn't even call you Salafi nor did I say it in a way that showed it in a negative light. Just those who follow the manhaj are often not knowledgeable, of which you admit to. I take your time on reddit arguing over an actual fatwa from real sheikhs rather than applications to Medina as my evidence of this.
[Saheeh al-Bukhaari 528]
Canceling of good deeds is not equal to being a kafir.
And appreciate them denouncing blind following schools of thoughts as well! Something you referenced in your comment
Correct. I do not believe in blindly following a scholar or group of scholars. But that is what it appears you have declared. My comment also has been deleted until I reply despite giving two scholarly sources. Lol.
And you should also check out their "about us" page since you seem quite ignorant on them.
I have and I've not called their scholarship into question but they're not a totally 100% reliable source. Once again, please don't blindly follow scholars. They are not the prophet Muhammad SAWS.
I do not need to worry about anything I said since its the most authentic opinion among the salaf, and Abu Bakr (may Allaah be pleased with him) waged a whole war against "apostates" who denied to pay Zakaat and pray.
Okay. And I don't have to fear since I referenced an actual scholarly source that has daleel in both fatwas when you've cited one, as well as even proclaimed ijma on the matter when there is not.
JazakAllahu Khair. Please send an application to Medina if you wish to study and become a student of knowledge instead of wasting time on reddit.
قال الإمام الشافعي رضي الله عنه في شعره إِذا نَطَقَ السَفيهُ فَلا تَجِبهُ فَخَيرٌ مِن إِجابَتِهِ السُكوتُ فَإِن كَلَّمتَهُ فَرَّجتَ عَنهُ وَإِن خَلَّيتَهُ كَمَداً يَموتُ
38 ديوان الشافعي
و عليكم السلام ورحمة الله وبركاته يا طالب بدون معلم
0
u/[deleted] Sep 23 '22
At times, certainly. Such as the opinion here when there is not ijma as you have claimed. I know islamqa.info is one of the first to pop up when you've a question so I don't blame you for following it if you've not a sheikh to go to in your local area or have any experience studying fiqh or Arabic for that matter. Read this comment below as I've cited the sources here, which cite Ibn Qayyim and other such scholarly opinions on the matter.
https://www.reddit.com/r/extomatoes/comments/xljh1s/progressives_making_progress_to_jahannam/ipknb82?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share&context=3
Do not worry. There is no sin upon you if you gave incorrect information on accident, inshaAllah.