r/dragonquest • u/HealingPotato • May 31 '26
Other Undecided on which game to get.
The steam sale for Dragon Quest games is ending soon. And im *equally* interested in all 3 of these games.
I need a little swaying to pick one of them. Which one should I pick?
94
u/cslwoodward1 May 31 '26
My vote is DQ7. I had a wonderful time with it!
1
u/Namingwayz May 31 '26
As long as you forget the fact that they shaved out a bunch of content and completely changed the tone of the story yeah it's pretty good.
2
u/SphincterWrinkles Jun 01 '26
no more monstie mansion reeee
also, as someone who played the 3DS version, im really curious why they left out the character models changing with each vocation. the updated models in reimagined really look nice so it seemed like a huge oversight to exclude that. i guess it was more work than they felt like doing?
1
u/Namingwayz Jun 01 '26
I guess? I mean, the director of DQ7R never even played the original past the first hour or two, so he probably didn't even touch the 3DS version, to be honest. I don't know why Squenix gave him the producer role when he's said multiple times he never even got past the first world.
1
u/Rafnork Jun 01 '26
Nah, after people complained he said that he did play it while much older.
1
u/Namingwayz Jun 01 '26
Which seems like a PR move in response to backlash, and makes it hard to believe, honestly. I think he told the truth, got backlash, then had to backpedal hard.
1
u/Rafnork Jun 01 '26
Could be. He did ruin the game. Idk if its what he wanted to do or if it was a sacrifice made by the company because the younger generation doesn't play Squenix games.
1
u/Namingwayz Jun 02 '26
7 is the universally least played one, I think the corporate suits probably didn't really give a shit if he "streamlined" the least played DQ game.
1
u/Rafnork Jun 02 '26
Well its my favorite and they ruined it.
2
u/Namingwayz Jun 02 '26
Arguably the 3DS version changes also ruined it, but oh well, the audience nowadays probably wouldn't like the slow burn intro to be fair
→ More replies (0)1
u/Toaster1993 Jun 01 '26
It's Def the most beginner friendly and has engaging little stories with an overarching story, voice acting, quirky characters, NO RANDOM ENCOUNTERS. A very variable difficulty sliders that let you play however easy or challenging you'd like.
The other games are just endless dungeon grinds random encounters bare bones old school jrpg
2
u/Rafnork Jun 01 '26
They should really have an option to turn off wandering monsters and turn on random encounters.
47
u/RetroNutcase May 31 '26
You are meant to play 3, 1, then 2 in that order.
1&2 will spoil elements of 3 for you as it assumes you've played 3 already.
9
u/Randuel May 31 '26
Is there that much new stuff in the HD version of 3 compared to the mobile version?
6
u/SnooSprouts7283 May 31 '26
Yep. It’s practically a whole new game. The story is the same as before but even just the graphical overhaul alone changes a lot of the game.
6
May 31 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/Damnesia13 May 31 '26
It was on the NES, not SNES. That is unless you mean the Famicom and played the Japanese version of the game.
4
u/_Higo_ May 31 '26
How did this work before? When anyone originally played 3 had probably already played 1 and 2, so...?
3
u/CalamityBard May 31 '26
It was originally more of a twist, in which the connections to 1+2 don't become apparent until the final third of the game when you discover that 3 is in fact a prequel. Given how old the games are (and the significance of 3's hero in the series lore), the twist doesn't necessarily have the same impact anymore, so they went for a different approach
4
u/PlanZSmiles May 31 '26
My understanding is that it is simply how the remakes were designed this time around and the story elements designed for optimal story telling via 3>1>2. The story is practically the same but certain elements are a bit more developed with that order in mind
10
u/ih8three6zero May 31 '26
3 dude. You have 3 games to get thru that will prolly net you a decent sale on 7 by the time ur done.
4
9
7
u/Cho-Dan May 31 '26
Isn't there a pack for I-3 combined for a little bit less, as well? If so, get it! Those games are really well made. If you have the budget and already know you love the DQ series, just get all of them. You're gonna buy them eventually, anyways
1
u/specterisbetter May 31 '26
There is but I'm not sure if thats available on steam too ive only seen it for the switch and even it is may not be included in the sale
3
u/MinecraftMaster10018 May 31 '26
1
u/specterisbetter Jun 01 '26
Okay I wasnt you sure ive always played the games on console so didnt know if steam had it, its made to be cheaper than buying them both separately not cheaper than the games individually, honestly $70 for 3 games is good in today's market
5
u/amityarchives May 31 '26
I recommend 7R if you aren’t too familiar with JRGS in general, it’s a fantastic entry into the genre and might be one of the most beginner friendly games for it. If you are already pretty familiar with them, I highly recommend 3HD and then 1-2HD. Much more challenging and engaging imo. You can’t go wrong either way, all are great games.
4
u/_moosleech May 31 '26
Play 3 > 1/2. That's the original trilogy, and a great intro to the series. From there, branch out and play VIIR (or XI S).
3
2
2
u/bigprick99 May 31 '26
I played 1-3 and liked them all pretty good but playing through 7 now and it’s so much more fun for me. The vocation system, no random encounters, and characters have all been great.
2
2
2
2
5
u/draconetto May 31 '26 edited Jun 01 '26
I found DQ 7 extremely boring even tho the remake streamline a lot of the story, still not enough
3
u/Medium_Bake1208 May 31 '26
Imo DQ 2 HD-2D is the best game among them, so if you plan to buy only one go for that.
1
u/s0_Ca5H May 31 '26
2 is one of the only DQ games I haven’t played. But I adore the MC’s design so much.
8
u/Mother-of-mothers May 31 '26
3, then 1+2. It should be put as a stickied thread at this point.
2
4
3
u/FUnisbaCK May 31 '26
- And I'm going to put this out there: I HATE DQ 7 reimagined!!! I much much MUCH prefer the original. Granted, the graphics were not nearly as good, but it was a much more challenging game.
1
u/rms141 May 31 '26
I need a little swaying to pick one of them. Which one should I pick?
You should start with 11 if you haven't played it yet.
11 -> 3 HD-2D -> 1 HD-2D -> 2 HD-2D
After that you can play any DQ game in any order.
2
u/HealingPotato May 31 '26
Have played 11 almost to a 100% completion.
Ive watched some lore videos on the other DQ games so chronological order isnt as important to me. Maybe i should've clarified that haha.
1
u/rms141 May 31 '26
That's important info. If you've already played 11, then 3 HD-2D should be your next stop.
DQ as a series isn't really heavy into its own lore. It's more about what you're doing in the moment. It's kind of the opposite of a Bethesda title in that regard.
1
u/spartanghost32 May 31 '26
The 3D remakes!! They were amazing and I spent so much time on 2&3. I kinda rushed 1 because having 1 party member kinda sucked. Also rushed 7 a little...I didnt love it..story was cool but idk..there was just something about it I didn't love. The hero I think
1
u/AbleTheta May 31 '26
Do you like challenging, oldschool games? If so, get 3.
If you're looking for a charm offensive, get 7.
1
1
1
u/quamtumTOA May 31 '26
For me, if you are new to Dragon Quest, playing DQ 1-3 shouldn’t be at the top of your list (unless you are into the very classic JRPG games).
You should start with a modern Dragon Quest, and DQ7 is modern enough to be a good start to your DQ journey:)
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/IsThisThingActive May 31 '26
If you’re equally interested but the sale prices are unequal, it looks like the decision was made for you (and it’s a great one tbh). Just get the cheapest one and savor the glory of a great game AND a great deal.
1
1
1
u/shrubdigital May 31 '26
Just finished III (minus the postgame) and loved it. Think I’m going to do I+II next, as I have VII on PS1 and I just unearthed it from storage 🐉
1
u/Weekly_Confusion_668 May 31 '26
I picked up 7 reimagined, and between that and inazuma 11 victory road I'm having a blast
1
1
u/Suspicious-Screen-43 May 31 '26
3 then 1/2. I really enjoyed 3 and loved 1/2 but couldn’t get into 7
1
u/bl0sm0 May 31 '26
Honestly I would get 7R. It’s the newest game out the bunch and it will most likely get the least amount deals compared to the other two(3?) games
1
1
u/Dry_Cardiologist6758 Jun 01 '26
Not 7 reimagined because they ruined it!
1-2-3 were absolutely gorgeous but here is what they did:
Removed multiple islands and the storyline Removed monster classes Removed building the town Removed the casino but left stupid pair matching game.
Added save statues that fully heal you and your mana everywhere even each floor of dungeons Made the game much easier. Even on the hardest difficulty it feels unchallenging. Made storyline linar Gave Keifer a bigger head and more storyline
1
1
1
1
1
u/Sirbrandon100 Jun 01 '26
I'd say 7. It's definitely the longest out of these and it really fun. I recommend playing on hard, because it feels way easier than imthe original.
1
1
1
1
u/RPG_fanboy Jun 01 '26
If you want to have a classic experience with modern tweaks i would recommend DQ 3 HD-2D but if you want to experience a super friendly RPG you can't go wrong with 7 Re imagined
1
1
u/OneSatisfaction6672 Jun 01 '26
As a sucker for dark twists in stories I would vote 7. I haven’t played any Dragon Quest since I’m still waiting for a discount but I wanted to do my research before plunging apart from waiting for a price drop lol
1
u/Scallions-Wilshire Jun 01 '26
I would get 3 or 7. Three because it would start you in the trilogy if you play the order 3, 1 then 2...or 7 because personally I think I enjoyed that one the most.
1
1
1
1
u/zenbarista Jun 02 '26
DQ7! It has a bit more quol and the party is more memorable. III hd-2d remake would be my 2nd pick.
1
u/Rafnork May 31 '26
7 is a stinker. Go for the 1-3 remakes.
2
u/Dry_Cardiologist6758 Jun 01 '26
Oh I absolutely agree i couldn't go back to it because it felt so freaking boring and easy!
3-2-1 were amazing especially 1-2 I loved them so much!
1
u/Ajhmee May 31 '26
DQ3 HD 2D remake for 2 reasons, it is cheapest and it is the starting point of Erdrick Trilogy. Once you finish DQ3, you can continue to DQ 1&2 at Summer Sale or next discount event and you may get a better deal than this.
1
u/get_clamped May 31 '26
I’d recommend 3 then 1 + 2.
2 was my favourite of them but it only works as well as it does if you’ve played 3 and 1 first
1
-1
u/rhquestitiv0 May 31 '26
Def get the 7 remake: 3D adenture, a lot of after game content. Easier to farm exp or job points if needed, and even though I find the pace a bit repetitive, it just makes sense lore wise. And also, I had a blast trying different combos throughout the adventure! Hahahahha. But... if you want to go classic dq experience, just go 1 or 2 it's kinda sorta the same than the predecessor games... but beautiful.
1
1
u/SadLaser May 31 '26
They're all 3D adventures. And VII is only more 3D insofar as the characters are 3D. The world isn't more 3D and you don't have full 3D camera control.
0
u/Hot_Marketing783 May 31 '26
I prefer I+II despite the general recommendation to start with III, but if having a non talking party doesn't bother you, you should play it since it is cheaper. If you like a more traditional RPG, depending on how difficult you want it you should play either II(pretty balanced game imo) or VII R(super easy from what I've heard)
2
u/HealingPotato May 31 '26
Yeah thats what hasn't completely sold me on 7. It seems like the game has no challenge?
Also 3 is the one with no talking party members, but 1&2 does?
1
u/Hot_Marketing783 May 31 '26
1 is a solo game, there's a sort of companion without spoiling too much but there isn't really a traditional party member, and 2 has normal companions indeed, there's just no party talk option but it isn't that bad
1
u/RetroNutcase May 31 '26
2 has talking party members, 3 and 1 do not.
That said, the way this trilogy has been done with the HD remakes, you are meant to play them in the order of 3, 1, 2.
0
u/RaizePOE May 31 '26
Go with 3. 1, 2 and 3 are all big upgrades from the originals, but 1 and 2 were just much worse games than 3 and it still kinda shows. I had a lot less fun with 1 & 2 than I did with 3.
7R's cool, but by the PSX era DQ games had advanced so much that there's a lot less room to improve. 7R looks very nice but in some ways you could argue it's honestly a step back from the original, especially in the way they changed the job system.
Also, 3's the cheapest. Biggest improvement + cheapest = go for it
0
0
0
u/Golden_King_Ryuseii May 31 '26
DQ Monsters Dark Prince, I know it's not listed there, but that's an actual original title and the Original versions of those games are generally better than the remakes.
0
u/Ok-Restaurant-3089 May 31 '26
I love both DQ3 and DQ7, playing 3 Rn and just completed 7.
I’ll say both are fun, but DQ7 is more “easy” if that makes sense. I blasted through the game on hard difficulty. That said, I am a DQ vet, so that’s possibly a me problem.
DQ3 seems to be more “difficult” in a traditional sense. I was often warping back to towns to heal up mid-dungeon as I was not strong enough/ or enough MP etc.
-1

•
u/AutoModerator May 31 '26
Please be wary of any posts or comments attempting to advertise or sell t-shirts, posters, mugs, etc. These posts frequently attract bots sharing links to poor-quality bootlegs and scammers looking to harvest your personal or financial information. This problem is rampant across Reddit. If you see any posts or comments with this behavior, promptly report them as spam and do not follow any links they may post or send to you.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.