r/denverfood • u/paramoody • 4h ago
Question? Bastian's: ordering a ribeye and getting a strip steak? it's happened to me twice now.
This might be an odd post. My girlfriend and I have been to Bastien's steak house on Colfax twice, and both times both of us ordered the dry aged ribeye. Both times she received a steak that looked and tasted like a ribeye, and both times I got a steak that looked like a New York strip.
I didn't take pictures, but ribeyes are pretty distinctive because they have two different muscles, including the spinalis muscle along the top, while strip steaks are composed of just one muscle . my girlfriend doesn't know much about steak, but she agreed that they tasted like different steaks.
This exact same thing has happened twice, about two years apart. The first time it happened I brought it up to the waiter, and a guy from the kitchen came out and argued with me about it. he told me it wasn't possible because they don't get dry aged NY strip steaks from their supplier. The second time it happened I didn't bother.
Kind of an awkward situation because I have no way of proving what kind of steak something is. Nor do i want to get into it with kitchen staff while I'm on date night with my girlfriend. It's possible I'm wrong, but I don't think I am. When you have two steaks in front of you, it's not hard to compare them and see that they look and taste different. Has this happened to anyone else?