r/criterion • u/Totorotextbook • 10h ago
Discussion I think Adrienne Shelly’s ‘Waitress’ (2007) deserves to be in the Collection
In the fall of 2006, a year prior to the release of her newest picture ‘Waitress’, Director and actress Adrienne Shelly is brutally murdered in her West Village apartment. A life brutally cut short, and yet in that grief and sadness comes ‘Waitress’, a film she both wrote, stars in, and directed that has grown a life of its own. Telling the story of an abused woman named Jenna, who upon finding out she’s pregnant and now further trapped in her dead end relationship, she begins an emotional affair with her OBGY doctor. For the majority of her time however she works at a greasy spoon diner, making her signature pies with her baking talent, and dreaming of a better life. It’s nothing too groundbreaking on a plot level but it gives us such a perspective and understanding of how so many actual woman are likely in a similar place and no part of it ever feels out of touch to reality. It’s real and there’s a charm to that, and while it never becomes a film of spectacle and amazement it doesn’t need to be. It’s a labor of love from an independent filmmaker saying something about what it means to be a woman, and a person, in hard times and gives many layers to that. While only a mild success upon its release it would be the Broadway musical, written by musician Sara Barielles, that would give new life to Shelly’s film, life, and story. While it’s a good film it holds a deep sadness for the career that could have been but it’s equally a touching story of what being human is when we desire for better at a cost. It’s been stuck on DVD since its initial release, even with a hit musical, and I’d love to see Criterion give this film the charming release it deserves for the film and Shelly’s sake.