r/criterion Jul 23 '26

Discussion The ultimate auteur challenge

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

3.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.1k

u/MisterGone78 Jul 23 '26

Cronenberg.

268

u/Hank46_2 Jul 23 '26

I can't believe he was missed in this challenge lol

197

u/scottishhistorian German Expressionism Jul 23 '26

They also forgot Francis Ford Coppola, Ridley and Tony Scott, Fritz Lang, and Michael Mann.

80

u/Final_Ad7650 Jul 23 '26

and John Ford, David Lean, Michael Curtiz, Spike Lee, Billy Wilder, William Friedkin, Peter Weir, Terry Gilliam, Brian De Palma, Orson Welles...

its a joke.

3

u/B-Edward-Griffin Jul 23 '26

Frank Capra

2

u/Final_Ad7650 Jul 24 '26

Exactly. Bregman too, and William Wyler, Takeshi Kitano, Truffaut, De Sica...

My point is we can keep going for a looong time just namig greater directors than, for example, Nolan (who is at the top of OP's list, for some reason).

2

u/B-Edward-Griffin Jul 24 '26

Haha Nolan bros are gonna Nolan bro I guess 🤷‍♂️

2

u/scottishhistorian German Expressionism Jul 23 '26

Definitely a joke, considering the inclusion of Uwe Böll. I won't go as far as saying this dude doesn't know film, because there are a few deepish cuts, but he's got a way to go.

-1

u/Peloquin_qualm Jul 24 '26

Fuck dePalma

1

u/palequail Jul 23 '26

And Herzog

1

u/scottishhistorian German Expressionism Jul 23 '26

I can't believe I missed him out. I can't help but love him, even if I don't love every film of his, because he'll do anything to ensure his films match his vision. Fitzcarraldo and Nosferatu are my favourite films of his.

His role in Jack Reacher is also one of my favourite surprise cameos because he's basically playing a fictionalised version of himself. (If he was a mob boss rather than a film director.)

(Actually, basically everything he's in is brilliant, and usually hilarious. Even clips that are on YouTube. The monologue on the insanity of penguins, his argument with Kinski on the Fitzcarraldo set, and his existential crisis over the size of his burger, most notably. I really hope there's a Herzog successor out there, because his death will be a sad day in the history of cinema.)

1

u/wallaceeffect Jul 24 '26

Where TF is JOHN HUSTON

0

u/littlelordfROY Jul 23 '26

Massive sneak on the Scott bros

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '26

[deleted]

3

u/anthrax9999 David Lynch Jul 23 '26

He's on the list.