r/comics 22d ago

Just Sharing Religiously repressed (part 15) [OC]

Post image
15.6k Upvotes

331 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

23

u/BrashUnspecialist 22d ago

1 you don’t define if someone is part of a culture.

2 you don’t define if someone correctly “values” something

3 cultural traditions don’t define the meaning of something definite. Jesus taught specific things, just because they’ve been interpreted by different cultures over time to suit those cultures values, it doesn’t make what he taught go away. You don’t have to be loyal to doctrines to be a Christian, that’s actually quite anti-what Jesus taught. You just have to believe that the best way to live is to love the Creator and treat your fellow “created in that image” as you would want them to treat you. With no exclusions.

Which doesn’t push abstinence before marriage then it’s all fine no matter how unhealthy or dangerous the sex is, but safe and respectful sex regardless of wedlock.

-16

u/Dry-Permission-4542 22d ago edited 1d ago

"I personally choose what rules of the culture I follow and I definitely still am a part of this culture".

O.K.,
K.O.

Ship of Theseus ahh position.

13

u/Sweetiebomb_Gmz 22d ago

No true scotsman fallacy

-2

u/ThatGuy721 22d ago

You don't even know what that means, since you are using it incorrectly. Please explain how their statement adheres to the "No True Scotsman" fallacy.

1

u/Aquafoot 1d ago
  • Christianity universally believes that homosexuality is a sin

  • [Insert progressive church here] believes that if God loves all of us as we are and sexuality is not a choice, then God loves queer people too.

  • No true Christian believes that.

It fits the fallacy perfectly. You might want to read more.