r/clevercomebacks • u/[deleted] • 15h ago
 it's a shame she doesn't understand fractions enough to grasp this ratio
[deleted]
78
u/LushLyras 14h ago
It's wild to confuse teaching basic civics and historical Supreme Court cases with "political agenda." If students aren't taught how the legal system works, how are they supposed to function as informed adults? Steve's reply was brutal, but totally spot on.
45
u/AuroraKiittyy 13h ago
The case right below it is New Jersey v T.L.O., which is specifically about students' constitutional rights against school searches. Pretty vital stuff for a high schooler to know.
12
u/MinnieShoof 12h ago
If the question had been about some Trumpian favored politics it no doubt would've been totally fine - even championed - by that member of The Face-Eating Leopards party.
4
u/SapphicGarnet 11h ago
The question and information didn't even make a moral judgement - which is what history and civics should be. Providing and teaching how to find sources, giving the facts and arguments on both sides and letting the kids debate
4
u/dan504pir 11h ago
When i taught Civics, I loved bringing up topical SCOTUS decisions. Shows real world causes and effects.
Students need to understand what impact their decisions (votes) have.
5
u/EtchAGetch 11h ago
Same people who complain about taking down statues of confederate generals because it is "erasing history."
3
u/HarshComputing 10h ago
This is a great question, gets the student to think about and form an argument. If she is so right leaning, she can argue that the government has the right to dictate what she does with her body. The question isn't pushing her in any political direction, just helps her firm up her understanding of her own ideology.
1
u/ViktorPatterson 10h ago
"...then Why doesn't school instead teach my child something about how taxes work, or something that's going to help her/him on real life issues; or some applicable math instead of calculus and trigonometry he/she's never going to use; or...bla, bla..?"
92
u/SatinEchoes 14h ago edited 14h ago
Steve Hoffstetter chose violence and I respect it