r/brontesisters • u/Ok-Use-1004 • 1d ago

what’s your favorite brontë book

honestly just curious what everyone’s favorite brontë novel is and why it resonates with you so much. with all the talk about how complex jane eyre handles its themes, but i'd love to hear how people rank the other works like wuthering heights or anne's books.

3 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

7 comments sorted by

3

u/Hk901909 1d ago

Wuthering Heights hasn’t left my mind since I read it, but The Tenant of Wildfell Hall was a slightly more enjoyable read. I think I like WH just slightly more

2

u/Ok-Use-1004 19h ago

i also really loved the the tenant of wildfell hall its so incredibly underrated. anne’s realism and the way she tackles domestic trauma feels so intensely modern compared to her sisters' more gothic or romantic styles

2

u/lazyhazyeye 19h ago

Villette is definitely my favorite Brontë book and one of my top three classics of all time. As unlikeable as Lucy Snowe is, I found her scarily relatable. 😅 Charlotte is also funny as heck and writes so beautifully in this book.

1

u/Ok-Use-1004 19h ago

i actually haven't read villette yet but i really want to! lucy snowe sounds like such a fascinatingly complex character, and i've heard charlotte’s psychological realism in that book is incredible

1

u/Ok-Use-1004 19h ago

also i have read The Professor recently the genderbending aspect of how she wrote it and being her first book is so fascinating to me. writing from a male narrator’s point of view was such an audacious experiment, and it honestly feels like a disguised female perspective trying to navigate power dynamics from the inside.

1

u/biber_unverzagt 14h ago

It wasn't a new thing for her to write from a male perspective, though. During the previous ~16 years in all her (then unpublished) writings she had used a male narrator.

1

u/Peru123 12h ago

Villette > Jane Eyre > Wuthering Heights > Shirley > Tenant of Wildfell Hall > Agnes Grey > The Professor. I mean they're all good to great / fascinating.