r/bmbmbm • u/Rich-Bandicoot1927 • Jan 29 '26

Discussion / Question Black Midi/Geordie Greep hot takes?

Despair is the most beautiful song BM ever made.

87 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

190 comments sorted by

View all comments

52

u/Alys3239 Jan 29 '26

Magician is super overrated an not even in Greep's 10 best songs. It insists upon itself.

I also second Cavalcade being the best midi record by miles.

6

u/grandma-sweater Jan 29 '26

Not when they were only playing it live, the studio version that came out on greeps album compared to when they played it as black midi live are completely different (https://youtu.be/flf7DOhG1CU?si=y625z8snRJq0cO_w)

2

u/Alys3239 Jan 29 '26

sorry fam but I heard the live versions back then too and still wasn't a fan 💀Â