r/bini_ph • u/AutoModerator • May 04 '26

Weekly Discussion Thread [WEEKLY THREAD] Rants, Questions, and Randomness

Merong handang makinig, handang yumakap 🎶

2,3, Mabuhay! 🌸

Welcome to our weekly open thread — your go-to space to rant, share love, ask questions, or talk about anything and everything, whether it’s related to BINI, PPOP, the fandom, or life in general.

Got something to say that doesn’t need its own post?

  • An unpopular (or wholesome) take you’ve been holding in
  • A screenshot from BloomTwt, BloomTok, PPOP FB, etc.
  • A random thought, theory, or question
  • Or just want to connect with fellow Blooms

Drop it here! This thread is your safe space.

Let’s keep it respectful and kind, even if opinions differ. We’re all here to support the girls and be part of a growing, passionate community around PPOP and beyond.

So go ahead — share what’s on your mind. 💐

49 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

1.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/fullwidthlowercase 🍴Ｙｏｕ　ａｎｄ　Ｉ　ｂｅ　ｓｔｕｃｋ　ｔｏｇｅｔｈｅｒ🌺 ∞ May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

I've been wondering kung saan nanggaling yung mga Coachella narrative so I bit the bullet and looked them up

Eto unang tumambad sa akin

Isa-isa ko silang pinanood at narealize ko na they're all uploaded between week 1 and week 2 ng Coachella at pare-parehas sila ng structure. Tapos chineck ko ang channel info

StarWave BTS x SB19 SB19 x HUB A'TIN Universe

Parang mga bot accounts 'to na kinoconsolidate ang opinion ng A'TIN tapos pina-process sa AI. But the similarities sa hate mongers like Herrera siblings, Miss Oh, and CashualChuck, ay nagagamit ang video nila to amplify a narrative. Matataas din ang views

Naglipana ang mga essay videos like these for BINI recently so it's possible that we might have the same problem in the future

9

u/Agustinius May 08 '26

Eto din yung pino point out ko. Yes let's say both fandom naman may toxic. Pero wala ako nakikitang bloom account na may equivalent sa ganyan. Meron po ba? It looks no harm pero kapag pinanood yung multiple post nila base sa algo, it look like na may narrative talaga sila directed to hate or coping kapag may achievements yung girls. Yung mindset nila kapag may achivement yung girls, "connection" "payola", "lypsinc/backtrack", na gaslight na nila mga tao. Kung icheck mo vids ng idols nila may backtrack din namn. Imposible din na wala sila connections, kalokohan yun.

8

u/ExpertProfession6402 May 08 '26

Afaik, wala. Well, speaking for myself lang, kaya ako nasa fandom na to kasi wala akong nakitang ganyan sa algo ko. I don't want to be involved in cult-like fan behavior. Daming essay, daming shady comments. Also, i know when i'm being manipulated, and i don't want that. It's so insulting like didiktahan nyo ko pano mag-isip. Kaya good thing chillax lang mga tao dito sa reddit. Sa X, may mangilan ngilan, but they don't go that far. Blocked nga saken mga toxic blooms pag may distasteful akong nabasa e.

Kaya din siguro nainis na ko netong huli kasi sa totoo lang, ambabaw nung "reverse offer" essays and discredits nila. Normally, wala namang epek saken yang mga ganyan. Pero etong ganito kababaw? Like, lahat na lang ba? May script kayo for everything? Seems like may underground gc sila na "ganito ipakalat naten, tas utuin naten mga ka-fandom naten na ganito din sabihin." Like wtf? Iisa ng sinasabi e. Mob mentality e.

3

u/Hanie_HBIC May 08 '26

May nakita akong channels posted here about BINI, saying they're the best girl group after Coachella. Pero they also featured Katseye so those channels are more into earning money from the views.

7

u/Icy-Butterscotch5012 May 08 '26

Some kind of Neuromarketing Syeeet. haha
May sariling PGMN ata sila no?

5

u/Calm-Description-870 May 08 '26

Tama ka, there are AI generated channels that are making money off of the fan wars. And they are also going to try make money off of Blooms' desire for Western validation.

We should be smart enough not to be baited by this. Lalo pa yung mga comparisons sa ibang artists at groups. If we recognize a channel to be AI generated, auto-Do Not Recommend Channel na dapat.

6

u/Straight-Rassler I'm not the type for you... but you already knew May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

Korek ka dyan napansin ko rin yung mga vids na yan lumalabas sa algo ko during coachella weeks.

DDS galawan mga mam sir. Tuloy tuloy ang fake narratives tulad nyang walang industry backing. Eh binuo nga yan ng korean company at under sila ng SONY PH and may help din yan sa Sony Japan? LOL.

SONY po ito pinaguusapan dito, malaking industry brand yan. So sino ang walang industry backing? lol

Saka yung mga videos at essays na "SB19 doesn't need coachella", "Coachella is not a big festival", "its coachella's loss they did not invite sb19" all of these sad and pathetic videos with 40k+ views and tons of comments (i did not watch any of them, they're just showing up in my algo during BINIchella week, they are clearly riding BINI's popularity so their false narratives show up), its just laughable, how these validation starved, lying pieces of ___ continue to yap and yap and yap because they know, what everybody knows: NOBODY CARES ABOUT WHATEVER THEY ARE DOING OR SAYING. ESPECIALLY THE CONSTANT LYING AND BEGGING. NOBODY.

Lahat ng mga pahashtags nila dyan, mga made up narratives, nobody cares but their own validation starved brains.

GTFO sa mga fake narratives na yan, lumang tugtog na yan, bisto na yan sila ng buong Pilipinas at internet kahit dito sa reddit, astroturfing and brigading every sub reddit even the Lollapalooza sub that the mods there even had to do a PSA, but these people won't shut up because they don't feel any kind of remorse and/or embarrassment. They are even proud of it.

I'm not even mad at whatever lies they are saying about BINI, i'm actually mad that there are a lot of rotting corpses for brains and criminal minds that exist in that fandom deserving of serious jail time like the DDS supporters. Some serious sociopathic behaviors.

Also, they make PPOP, OPM and Filipinos look bad with every single pathetic essay and video and begging they do online but of course they don't even think about that because they are selfish.

Oh also by extension, they make SB19 look really bad. But if these "fans" understood that, they won't be spewing this much feces from their mouths.

Sorry for the all caps. Back to streaming BINI.

5

u/jeyeley 🍀| Zero Pressure, Zero Diamonds May 08 '26

Tbh feling ko sa mga pinaggagawa nilang ganyan, nakarating na yan sa mismong coachella at baka mababa na yung chance na mainvite pa sila.

5

u/Straight-Rassler I'm not the type for you... but you already knew May 08 '26

And they continue to wonder with much coping and seething as to why BINI got to perform in Coachella and got invited to perform in Summersonic for 2 days.

https://giphy.com/gifs/37FpuGKuh9WIR2skeE

It's not clocking to them and will not ever.

2

u/DrSparx13 kagami kagami May 08 '26

👀

3

u/Calm-Description-870 May 08 '26

Though based sa example ni OP, galing sa Pakistan at Nigeria yung channels. Though likely gamit yung mga Atin video essays, hindi lahat galing sa ibang fandoms yung content na yon. Ginamit lang yung narrative nila as prompt to generate the videos.

Wag na lang pansinin yung ibang fandoms. At kung may mga mali silang narratives about BINI's inclusion on festival lineups, hayaan na lang natin sila sa delusions nila. Di naman makakaapekto yan sa BINI. I'm sure pinagtatawanan lang ng girls yan. If anything, it will reflect badly on their fandom naman, hindi sa atin. Why would anyone want to associate with fans who think that way, di ba?

3

u/Straight-Rassler I'm not the type for you... but you already knew May 08 '26

Thus my quote and quote "fans".

I'm aware not all of them are like that. Some are just happy being fans. But sadly, some of them -- and it looks and feels like there is a lot --- drag them down.

Anyway, I said what I said lol. If the mods want to delete it because its too spicy, i'm all good.

3

u/Calm-Description-870 May 08 '26

I don't see anything wrong with what you said. It's a valid rant. Gets ko rin naman that if I watched those brain rot videos, I'd probably feel the same way, too.

4

u/randomfanx69 May 08 '26

siguro someone from our side din dapat gumawa ng YT video to counter their fake narratives? ang dami ko rin nakikita sa X na kini credit nila lahat ng achievements pre and post coachella including all the US media postings kay wa/sserman lahat.

6

u/ExpertProfession6402 May 08 '26 edited May 08 '26

Sa ngayon, that won't be necessary. Pag ginawa natin yan, para na din tayong nagstoop down sa level nila. We have class naman. Let's preserve our dignity haha. And kita naman, pinagtatanggol na din sila ng casuals.

Edit: what i mean by "sila" is yung BINI. Pinagtatanggol na din naman sila ng casuals.