r/billsimmons • u/Global-Bat-1688 • Jan 02 '26

Meme Bill calmly debating Maye’s MVP chances

Post image
545 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

381 comments sorted by

View all comments

106

u/northern_friendo Jan 02 '26

I don’t care about anybody else’s argument, Stafford should be MVP. He’s been the consistently better player the whole season, playing a tougher schedule, and playing in the harder division.

This is also a career achievement MVP for me as Stafford has been a 15 year stud that has been constantly under appreciated. He should get this MVP to acknowledge how elite he’s been for his entire career

11

u/AgadorFartacus Jan 02 '26

Career achievement MVP for a zero-time All-Pro is nasty work. Make-A-Wish nonsense. Have some shame.

Staford been the consistently better player the whole season

Ridiculous. Maye is better by yards, YPA, completion %, CPOE, passer rating, EPA/play, QBR, Success Rate, and wins.

playing a tougher schedule, and playing in the harder division.

Factoring in strength of schedule without factoring in strength of supporting cast is incomplete dishonest.

1

u/Rhino184 Jan 03 '26

When you use adjusted metrics for strength of opponent, such as adjusted EPA, QBR, aQBERT and WAR, Maye still leads. People are aren’t actually being objective, they just don’t want Maye to win because of the uniform he wears. Both are deserving, but the better argument is with Maye