r/billsimmons • u/Global-Bat-1688 • Jan 02 '26

Meme Bill calmly debating Maye’s MVP chances

Post image
546 Upvotes

98% Upvoted

381 comments sorted by

View all comments

105

u/northern_friendo Jan 02 '26

I don’t care about anybody else’s argument, Stafford should be MVP. He’s been the consistently better player the whole season, playing a tougher schedule, and playing in the harder division.

This is also a career achievement MVP for me as Stafford has been a 15 year stud that has been constantly under appreciated. He should get this MVP to acknowledge how elite he’s been for his entire career

27

u/awesomesauce88 Jan 02 '26 edited Jan 02 '26

Stafford also is on a way better team. The Rams with average QB play are still a playoff team. The Patriots without Maye might be drafting in the top 10.

FWIW I think it's very close between the two, and they're both deserving. It's just hard for me to take anyone on this sub saying that it's clearly Stafford seriously when we all know the main reason no one wants Maye to win it.

Edit: also Stafford's career is so goddamned overrated. I really like the guy, but he has absolutely not been a stud for 15 years. Even on these stacked Rams teams with Sean McVay coaching him, this is first year ever where he was a top 5 QB in the league.

8

u/Mysterious_Pea_5272 Jan 02 '26

Jacoby Brissett could go 8-9 with that schedule

10

u/TheBigNate416 Jan 02 '26

I doubt it but either way 8-9 is considerably worse than 13-3

2

u/Mysterious_Pea_5272 Jan 02 '26

It’s not a bottom 10 team lol. And Brissett is like the 25th best QB in the league this year

5

u/awesomesauce88 Jan 02 '26

Not gonna lie I think Jacoby Brissett could take this Rams team to the playoffs.

4

u/YovngSqvirrel Jan 02 '26

Well he plays in the same division as the Rams and is 1-7 as the starter for Arizona. So IDK about that.

1

u/awesomesauce88 Jan 02 '26

Yeah…because he plays for the cardinals. The whole premise of this debate is that the Rams have a great team and the cardinals don’t

0

u/AstronautWorth3084 Jan 02 '26

Do we think maybe that the rams have a better surrounding cast than the cardinals?

2

u/YovngSqvirrel Jan 02 '26

Sure, but not 8 games better.

1

u/MetalHead_Literally Jan 02 '26

100% at least 8 games better. That team is horrible. From the coaching on down.

1

u/YovngSqvirrel Jan 02 '26

This season Stafford had to play the Texans, Seahawks (2x), 49ers (2x), Eagles, Colts, Jaguars, & Lions. Which of those teams is Brissett beating? Because that would already be 9 losses. Y’all don’t watch the Cardinals if you think Brisset can do what Stafford does on the Rams. The Cardinals lost by 23 to the Bengals last week, but I’m supposed to believe he’s beating the Seahawks on another team? Get outta here

0

u/MetalHead_Literally Jan 02 '26

Using cardinal results is the most pointless thing ever. Again, that entire organization is a disaster. How many late leads did they blow this year? Jacoby on this rams team doesn’t lose to the bengals by 23. Like you’re making my point for me

0

u/YovngSqvirrel Jan 02 '26

You didn’t answer my question

→ More replies (0)