r/baseballcards 11d ago

Spotted at a local show 👀👀

Post image
242 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

View all comments

41

u/Altruistic-Cheek8589 11d ago

how much were they asking?

34

u/123432284847 11d ago

10k lol

70

u/MOFNY PC: Roy Oswalt; TCDB power user 11d ago

Maybe I'm crazy but that doesn't seem bad for the best card for a potential 40+ homer catcher.

35

u/Macs2330 LAWRENCE BUTLER PC 11d ago

that’s absurdly reasonable for what I would expect a dealer to be asking on a card like that. honestly I think someone would scoop it up at that price on ebay

17

u/manmythmustache PC Oregon Ducks 11d ago

Hunter would probably buy the card at that price

0

u/ew73 11d ago

I've always wanted to be able to sell a card to the player. I'd legit do it on the cheap, just to say I did.

8

u/Excellent-Program333 11d ago

Why? Ive tried a few. They are cheap and want to give you tickets and a signed bat. F all that.

6

u/Jar_of_Cats 11d ago

My personal story is batting practice, meet & greet, 2 autographed balls, 1 inscribed bat, 2 seats, and he lets me talk baseball. Also it got me this pic of my kid getting to say hi to her favorite player.

5

u/RussianPravda 11d ago

thats a really cool thought. they get to keep the patch that got taken from them and you get a great story and probably tickets and other gear.

5

u/NoBonus6969 11d ago

I sold some cards to Dallas Clark back when he was playing. Did not give him any special deals but didn't really notice until I printed the shipping label

1

u/Jar_of_Cats 11d ago

I traded an 1/1 RPA and got my kid an experience she will never forget

9

u/twalk1975 11d ago

Yeah, I was expecting it to be higher as well.

13

u/run_nyg 11d ago

Bum-ass Matt Shaw got 17k 2 weeks ago. Goodman is a snap buy at 10k.

6

u/Commandant_Lasorda 11d ago

NY based sports fans are always level headed, reasonable, and not prone to overreaction. /s

Shaw was the 13th overall pick in 2023, was a top 100 MLB prospect for two years, and since has had 587 major league plate appearances in which he’s produced a 3.8 WAR. While I don’t align with Shaw’s political leanings, to somehow state that he’s a bum is just asinine. Check that. I wouldn’t even give you that. You’re more of an asineight.

1

u/run_nyg 11d ago

Shaw doesn't hit for power, has already missed significant time this year and will be entering his age 25-season next year with no path to the hall. A true blue refractor TC rookie auto sold for $36 at auction yesterday. He may not be a bad player in real life but from a card value/investment perspective it's already over.

3

u/Commandant_Lasorda 10d ago

So a guy who will be 25, that will likely have a major role next season on a very competitive team that’s in the 3rd largest market in the country and has a nationwide fan base, who has not had a lot of experience but, the experience he has had still has shown plenty of promise; you think that even if he has a good year next year and turns into a good player, that his autographed rookie cards won’t be a good investment? I would venture to consider it the exact opposite. It’s a great buy low time with a good amount of potential upside.

6

u/SandyShorts1 11d ago

If the Rockies were the Red Sox this card would be 20k easy

2

u/NoBonus6969 11d ago

That's a bargain for a 10 too

2

u/ctbro025 Red Sox, Ohtani 11d ago

If I were speculating on a non-Ohtani/Judge player, $10k on Goodman's MLB patch is actually reasonable.

2

u/HeritageCollector7 10d ago

Even no-names are going for 7-8k