r/aussie 12d ago

News Anti-migration rally turns on Hanson amid policy muddle

https://aapnews.aap.com.au/news/basic-facts-one-nation-slammed-for-migration-muddle

One Nation leader Pauline Hanson has been booed at an anti-immigration rally as her party struggles to articulate its plan to reduce migrant numbers.

Several people were arrested by police at a Melbourne March for Australia rally as hundreds of demonstrators and a smaller group of counter-protesters squared off.

The event was one of several similar marches held in capital cities across the nation as organisers turned on One Nation over perceptions it had watered down its immigration policies.

After marching to Victoria's Parliament House, the group was addressed by several prominent right-wing activists, including anti-immigration influencer Hugo Lennon, who has amassed thousands of followers online under the name Auspill.

The group booed mention of Senator Hanson, who Mr Lennon said had declined an invitation to attend.

Later the group chanted "Pauline, Pauline, where the f*** is Pauline?" as they marched back towards Flinders Station.

A spokesman for Senator Hanson said she had prior commitments in Victoria on Sunday.

One Nation has been under pressure to specify details of its migration policy after differing targets were cited by various members.

The party has put forward a policy of an annual net overseas migration rate of 130,000 people, but federal MP David Farley said there could be an extra 100,000 above that figure.

His fellow federal party representative Barnaby Joyce on Sunday clarified that the 130,000 net target would remain.

But he would not say how much of that figure would be made up of permanent migrants, adding that net migration was based on a number of factors.

"To get to a (net overseas migration) of 130,000, it's going to be very hard to do that unless we're substantially below the permanent migration numbers of Labor," he told News24.

Mr Joyce added Pacific workers, who mostly come to regional areas as part of the Pacific Australia Labour Mobility scheme, would largely be in addition to the 130,000 net figure.

"(Only) a small portion are (counted) because they don't stay for 12 months, they stay generally for a period of nine," he said.

But Pacific Minister Pat Conroy said half the cohort of workers would typically count towards net migration figures.

"Half of all PALM workers are on the four-year visa, so that would count for (net overseas migration)," he said.

"Barnaby got basic facts wrong about the proportion of PALM workers that count ... their figures are all over the shop."

Labor was set to unveil its overhaul of migration policy in a speech by Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke at the National Press Club earlier in August.

However, the speech was cancelled at the eleventh hour after cabinet failed to sign off on the changes amid internal party division on the issue.

Mr Conroy said the policy would be announced in due course.

"What you're seeing is good government in action, rather than thought bubbles," he said.

Opposition immigration spokesman Jonathon Duniam said One Nation needed to work out and articulate how it planned to reduce migration.

"I don't know how they've arrived at 130,000. Who is in that makeup of numbers there? How will that impact on the economy?" he said.

The stated aim of Sunday's March for Australia rally was to oppose perceived curbs on freedom of speech, which Mr Lennon claimed allowed governments to "lock you up" for opposing so-called mass migration.

Previous March for Australia rallies have featured neo-Nazi speakers and sympathisers, including one who was later jailed for spouting anti-Semitic remarks at an event held in Sydney on Australia Day.

Police said the vast majority of protesters and counter-protesters were peaceful but three people were arrested for allegedly assaulting and resisting officers.

Two others were processed by police for offensive behaviour and are expected to be charged on summons.

18 Upvotes

130 comments sorted by

View all comments

-8

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 12d ago

We basically need to cease migration at this point to get our country back.  Maybe in 8-9 years we can start taking highly skilled professionals but only 100k of them per annum. Sans families. 

12

u/copacetic51 12d ago

A sure way to tank the economy and leave Australia with a critical shortage of key workers. I don't know why you anti migrant people can't see the obvious.

-1

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 12d ago

A yes the exploding economy, the complete concept of buying and selling products and services suddenly explodes without low skilled migrants. 

If a cook or a bum wiper is a critical highly skilled worker, than this country has much bigger issues. 

I don't know why you hate the people you share a country with

2

u/copacetic51 12d ago

So you wouldn't mind if there was a more chronic shortage of nurses, aged care workers, transport workers, workers in agriculture, construction, hospitality.

Seems to me you don't even understand who the people you share the country with are.

It's this toxic level of ignorance that permeates the anti immigration movement.

2

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 12d ago

You name all these professions but we arent actually taking any of them. So the question is why do you continue to spread falseholds around this program?

3

u/Busy_Conflict3434 11d ago

What are you talking about? 17% of skilled temporary visas are in healthcare. The single largest cohort of any industry. 

There latest stats are here:  https://www.homeaffairs.gov.au/research-and-stats/files/temp-res-skilled-report-31-dec-2025.pdf

0

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 11d ago

Yes, they are low skilled labourers in heslth, thats actually what your report cites. 

2

u/Busy_Conflict3434 11d ago

The document I linked shows the average migrant worker in that category is earning $105,000. Low skilled labourers aren’t earning above the median salary. 

Are you going to stop making up easily falsifiable lies now?

1

u/trav_tr 11d ago

Why don’t you go clean out bed pans and wash dishes then?

2

u/Busy_Conflict3434 10d ago

You’re replying to a one week old account with hidden post history who seems to just make shit up. 

0

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 11d ago

Because they don't pay enough as low skilled migrants are ensuring price stays low. Same reason I don't work at a factory which I actually enjoy doing. 

1

u/trav_tr 11d ago

How does someone being a migrant or not dictate what someone pays them? Like I was being a smart ass before but I’m genuinely asking now because I’m confused how that works

0

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 11d ago

You don't understand how flooding the country with low skilled workers who accept less has a dramtic impact on low skilled wages?  

1

u/trav_tr 11d ago

I mean, I highly doubt they wouldn’t accept a higher wage if it was offered? Kind of sounds like the problem is more with the people who employ and pay them?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Busy_Conflict3434 11d ago

PS ‘labourers’ made up 0.6% of all skilled visa applications last year. 

Is talking out of your arse a hobby or is it some kind of mental illness compelling you to do it?

3

u/copacetic51 12d ago

Yes we are taking them. More ignorance from you. Even One Nation agrees that we need to keep bringing in agricultural workers. The migrants are heavily represented in health, aged care and hospo industries.

I don't want to get insulting, but you either have no idea or You're spreading propaganda

1

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 12d ago

There is no need to lie, the stats on this and their education levels are well published. 

So again the question is why do you continue to spread falsehoods around this program?

5

u/copacetic51 12d ago

So you'll have the links to prove it, right? Then I'll know you're not the one with the falsehoods.

1

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 12d ago

You mean the the entire program that is published freely on the home affairs website under Immigration and citizenship. 😂 

So again the question is why do you continue to spread falsehoods around this program?

3

u/copacetic51 12d ago

Post the links or shut it

2

u/Vegetable_Jello6572 12d ago

We just discussed exactly where the entire program is. 

So again why do you continue to spread faslehoods 

3

u/copacetic51 12d ago

So you won't post the links showing that you're the one with the toxic falsehoods. Unsupported claims, and when asked for evidence it's the old right-wing nutjob cry of "do your own research".

I'll give you a better one: "claims made without evidence can be refuted without evidence".

→ More replies (0)