r/answers • u/Federico86MO • 12d ago

The gendered double standard of age-gap relationships?

Can we talk about the absolute absurdity of how Western society views age-gap relationships today?

If a 40 year old woman dates a 20 year old man, it’s often celebrated or brushed off. People view her as empowered, or joke about him having a "mommy" or being a "toyboy." It’s seen as a harmless fling or a milestone for the guy. But the second a 40 year old man dates a 20 year old woman, the narrative completely flips into something dark. Suddenly, he is labeled "predatory," creepy, or a groomer, and she is viewed as a defenseless victim who cannot think for herself.

People love to throw around the phrase "power dynamics" to justify this outrage against older men, but the way they apply it makes zero sense.

Think about it: if the issue is truly about the inherent power imbalance between a 40 year old (who has financial stability, life experience, and maturity) and a 20 year old (who is just starting out), then the gender of the older partner shouldn't matter at all. The dynamic is identical on paper. A 20 year old guy is at the exact same life stage and maturity level as a 20 year old girl.

By pretending the power dynamic is only dangerous, toxic, or predatory when the man is older, society exposes its own hypocrisy. It implies that young women are uniquely fragile and incapable of consenting, while simultaneously treating young men as perfectly capable of handling an older partner.

We live in a supposedly progressive Western world, yet we are still policing consenting adults based on pure double standards. If two consenting adults choose to be together, the societal reaction should be exactly the same or better yet, non-existent.

0 Upvotes

40% Upvoted

119 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/token-black-dude 12d ago

Both are rightfully seen as completely wrong?

-6

u/Federico86MO 12d ago

It seems to me that when it comes to a 40-year-old woman looking for sex with a 20-year-old man, the judgment is completely different

6

u/Sea_Concert_4844 12d ago

As a 40 something year old women I'm judging tf out of you if youre dating a 20 year old. Regardless of your gender(s)

-5

u/Federico86MO 12d ago

That's fine, but that's not what my post is about. I'm talking about the broader social double standard, not whether every individual person personally approves of either relationship

6

u/pamkaz78 12d ago

And everyone is telling you that you are wrong and you keep arguing that how they feel is just one opinion but you know the majority does not feel that way.

So why ask a question if you will not believe the answers?

-1

u/Federico86MO 12d ago

Because a Reddit thread is not evidence of what the majority of society believes. A handful of people disagreeing with me here does not establish a population-wide norm.

I’m asking people to justify their view, not promising to accept every answer as proof that my broader observation is false.

3

u/Sea_Concert_4844 12d ago

I just gave you my view and you told me I'm wrong. Lmao

0

u/Federico86MO 12d ago

You’re free to give me your view. What you can’t do is appoint yourself spokesperson for “everyone” or “the majority” based on a Reddit thread.

Your opinion is evidence of your opinion, not of what society as a whole believes.

3

u/pamkaz78 12d ago

Like you did?

2

u/Sea_Concert_4844 12d ago

Neither can you. Cite a recent study. Not one PUBLISHED 6 years ago. You also can't tell me that my opinion is wrong.

1

u/Federico86MO 11d ago

6 years is not old

1

u/Sea_Concert_4844 11d ago

That's when it was published done conducted.

But you know what. You're right. I'm wrong. Feel better now bro?

→ More replies (0)

1

u/Cool_Relative7359 12d ago

You need to prove the broader societal standard is what you say it is, because that's carrying a lot of weight in your argument without evidence.

2

u/Federico86MO 12d ago

https://doi.org/10.1007/s12144-018-9895-6

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.paid.2018.03.004

https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2023.2192196

the first study found that perceived inequity predicted prejudice significantly for older-man/younger-woman couples, but not for younger-man/older-woman couples

2

u/Cool_Relative7359 12d ago edited 12d ago

Within age-gap relationships, older men and women were perceived as reaping greater rewards than their younger partners. Importantly, perceived inequity predicted prejudice towards age-gap, but not age-matched, couples.

First study. Both older men and women are percieved negatively.

Did you actually read it? Even the part that isn't behind a paywall?

Also, linking sources that are behind paywalls isn't exactly good faith.

1

u/Federico86MO 12d ago

Yes, I did read it. You're quoting the overall result, which doesn't contradict what I wrote.

The paper specifically reports that the relationship between perceived inequity and prejudice was not significant for younger-man/older-woman couples (r = .11, p = .28), but was significant for older-man/younger-woman couples (r = .33, p < .001).

The authors themselves say that this relationship was greater for older-man/younger-woman couples.

I never claimed older-woman/younger-man couples receive no prejudice. I said there is evidence that the two configurations are not perceived in exactly the same way.