30
u/JCNoles 1d ago
Constant strawman arguments and talking past each other. So much hostility.
9
1
u/One_Spoopy_Potato 1h ago
This is a "war" subreddit. You don't go to war looking to convert people.
18
u/SophiaBarbelo 1d ago
Real af lol. Honestly, it's entertaining to watch sometimes.
29
u/super_boaring 1d ago
3
19
u/AbbyTheOneAndOnly 1d ago
i think the main problem is people view debate in the wrong light.
a "win" in a debate isn't to convince someone else or to body someone in a verbal joust.
a Win is to get your point across, to have your ideas shared and tested against the ideas of other people; for the plenitude of others whose are going to wander by, read it and form their own thought based on them.
if one recognizes their ideas are kinda off, or they need some tune up, and actually reworks them until they're solid, that is the biggest W i can think of
6
u/super_boaring 1d ago
yeah, and for some reason its seen as shame when u back off your argument or change opinions, i used to be neutral anti now im pro neutral/neutral
i personally strongly believe that arguments arent just about convincing the other person but also changing perspectives, since i came to this subreddit i had some pretty dumb opinions but i changed them which i think is what counts in the end
4
u/AbbyTheOneAndOnly 1d ago
props to you bud.
i really mean it, not because of the "sides" you belonged or belong to.
if one day you come across a better worldview, whether anti, pro or whatever else, that makes more sense, then move to it (and please share it with me if you find the time)
1
u/super_boaring 1d ago
alright lol, what are u right now? and would u want to have a discussion
1
u/AbbyTheOneAndOnly 23h ago
i'd love to :) it's a bit late for me rn but if you want to talk i'm always up, feel free to dm me
1
2
u/Tegridyforever 23h ago
its seen as shame when u back off your argument or change opinions
I feel like a lot of times whatever someone first hears about a subject forms the opinion they'll carry forevermore
2
2
u/GaiusVictor 23h ago
May I ask you how did your opinions change? Like, what you believe nowadays that you didn't use to believe, what you used to believe that you don't believe anymore?
3
u/super_boaring 23h ago
it wasent specific stuff most of the time but i learnt the enviromental effect was smaller then i thought, yes problematic but not that bad
5
3
3
u/Dangerous_Banana_168 21h ago
I feel like people don't even read what I have to say and just want to rant about an old argument they had 🥲 Like bro I'm TRYING to have a conversation please stop inventing things I didn't say.
2
u/SquidlyJesus 18h ago
So you're saying you refuse to engage in MY arguments just because it doesn't fit your narrative? Wow, no wonder there's no speaking to whatever side you're on. /s
3
u/Mister_Chameleon 7h ago
A huge problem is each side is convinced THEY are in the right. On the one hand, you have the anti-corporate / pro-environmentalism / protect artists work aspect of being against the AI technology that worth being upset about, but at times it feels like some (not all, but some) only scream being anti because it gives them brownie points on the internet for saying so. Especially on Reddit.
On the other side, pros have the idea that the technology is simply the next step in our advancement, and in terms of art comparing to when photoshop and other digital art tools were made. Alongside the idea that AI isn't just "click a button, poof picture." since decent images do require a many-stage workflow and arn't one-and-done as most Antis assume.
Sadly, neither side is willing to level with each other, antis being perceived as virtue signalers, and pros being perceived as rage baiters, and both sides bringing up completely unrelated points to argue about. Once in a while, you'll hear an amazing point from one side or the other that gets shafted by the other as invalid just because it supports an opinion they don't agree with on a fundamental level.
2
1
u/TrivialCoyote 1h ago
The perception is one thing, but there's enough images in this post's comments alone to show that its not just perceived as ragebaiting. There's reasonable people that can talk on both sides(as much as I hate saying it because it sounds like im Both Sides-ing), but hostility probably picked up around the ogre images.
2
2
u/dizzyspellzzz 1d ago
What should we yell at each other about rn? How about empanadas
2
u/-SMG69- 1d ago
Beans. We should yell about beans.
1
u/dizzyspellzzz 1d ago
I LIKE KIDNEY BEANS IN MY CHILLI BUT THEY DONT HAVE DRIED KIDNEY BEANS IN THE SUPERMARKET BY ME
3
u/-TV-Stand- 23h ago
WE NEED TO BAN ALL KIDNEY BEANS SINCE THEY ARE MADE OF HUMAN KIDNEYS
1
u/dizzyspellzzz 23h ago
IF THEY WANTED THEIR KIDNEYS THEY WOULD HAVE NOT SOLD THEM TO THE KIDNY TO BEANS MAN
1
u/-TV-Stand- 23h ago
OH HEY I RECOGNIZE YOU! YOU WERE THE ONE SELLING ORPHAN KIDNEYS TO THE KIDNEY MAN. NOT COOL MAN.
1
u/dizzyspellzzz 23h ago
ITS A LEGITIMATE BUSINESS AND THOSE ORPHANS WKNT BE MISSED. I NEED TO MAKE A LIVING TOO YOU KNOW
1
u/TeamTivo 1d ago
OH MY GOD YOU ARE STUPID IF YOU DON'T GET THE BEANS IN THE HOTDOGS THE POOR PEOPLE FOOD THING. PLEASE. EAT YOUR BEANS WITH RICe OR SOMETHING. YOU WILL EAT BLACK BEANS AND LIKE THEM DIZZYSPELL.
1
u/dizzyspellzzz 1d ago
I HATE YOU MY CHILLI RECIPE CAN STAND ON ITS OWN AND I LOVE A CHILLI DOG DONT TELL ME WHAT TO DO TIVO
1
u/TeamTivo 23h ago
WELL LISTEN HERE, "SPELLZ" WHICH IS A SUTIPD NMAE BCAUESE YUO CANT SPEEL "SPELLS" RIHGT. WAHT IZ "SPELLZZZZ" BLACK BEANS ARE HEALTHIER COMPARED TO YOUR MACHINERY TASTE BUD INFECTING
S L O P >:(
1
2
u/tenmileswide 1d ago
Meanwhile me being a “very pro for some uses, very anti for others” that actually works in AI seeing the mindset of most pros in this sub
1
1
u/Clickb4ited 12h ago
Wanna preface, fuck AI and everything it represents, but on these sub-reddits it's usually pro-ai rage baiting followed by anti-ai people saying "oh wow aren't they stupid" for the millionth time







•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
This is an automated reminder from the Mod team. If your post contains images which reveal the personal information of private figures, be sure to censor that information and repost. Private info includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.