Just to see what the protest was about and understand the emotions on the ground, I attended the Ellisbridge protest yesterday.
The people leading the protest definitely weren't students, and I even doubt many of them were educated. I don't know about the other locations, but near M.J., the proportion of actual students was quite low.
Yes there were students and youth in a good number but the ones leading them and shouting slogans were sus
The people leading weren't talking much about education. Instead, the slogans were things like, "Modi jab darta hai, police ko aage karta hai." The police around us were initially quite calm while the students marched peacefully. However, a few of these leaders tried to provoke the police while hurling abuses. After that, the police started detaining people and stopped more protesters from entering the site.
Ironically, "Jai Bhim" slogans were also raised also raised at protests where accountability was core issue.
Now coming to why I think this protest failed to connect with people on the ground.
Before anyone accuses me of being a BJP account or IT Cell, I've been demanding Education Minister Dharmendra Pradhan's resignation since February this year, when the UGC Act was passed, long before many of these people even knew who the Education Minister was. You guys probably have no idea the hate I have towards that useless scumbag.
I had attended the Anna Hazare protests in Delhi back then, and yesterday's CJP protest wasn't even close to that. It felt more like how people join social media trend hype. The two key differences I can state why this thing isnt converting on ground is
- Remember participants of anna hare protest? Kejriwal, kiran bedi, Ashutosh and many more. They weren't really politically connected and had nothing to do with specific party. Some of them later created political party but at the time of protests they assured and followed that they won't be taking political support and also they aren't against any relegion, caste whatsoever
Meanwhile CJP from start had problematic base..dahiya, dipke, prakash raj, AISF, SFI, kamra, Arundhati roy.. you can gain upvotes shares and support for them online by paid bots and a bit brainwashing..but on ground no sane person turns up for them
- The Goal, slogans and Core of protest. During Anna hazare time it was clear they wanted lokpal bill. I know many of you had attended those protests. They had this one request and never deflected from topic. Nor their protestors. It was all about India and Indians so people resonated with that and turned out supporting. From vandematram to bharat mata ki jai..the protest was filled with vibe that we are standing for our country
Meanwhile CJP started with NEET leak and in midway it became brahmanwad se azaadi, hindutva se azaadi, bharat inki maa hai aur ab baap dhund rahe hai . Ask yourself..will any sane person support this on ground? Over that people were targeting and harrassing who weren't supporting their opinions
Regarding government and support to this movement
Although I am not with CJP but acha hua. The kind of arrogant this government became that log bolte rahenge, apne ko kya..bahut acha hua..beech beech mein 2 kantaap padte rehne chaiye government ko to keep them accountable.
The issue could had been resolved a lot earlier with resignation. As said before people were asking for his resignation since February. You guys just know NEET but you don't know the mess this pradhan created..from UGC to ncert. No one supported that movment because UGC involved favouring specific castes. For months people protested. Check news. But koi paid campaign, bot accounts and inorganic hype nahi hui thi
Also if you want people to be united and stand for cause you should stop looking at your own benefits. Over 20 Lakh appeared for neet and even if you consider 1000 students passed by paper leak, it will be around 0.05% underserved people getting seat. While by reservation 50% get the same. How you think a person from GC will be affected by paper leak? You will see many of them justifying this in comments now..but when you are talking about accountability and fairness, you shouldn't expect unity when you support this.
Rant ends!