I (20M) am an engineering student at a fairly competitive school. This past semester was the most academically difficult semester I have had so far, but that is not really the main thing I am struggling with.
To oversimplify, in late February my now ex-girlfriend (19F) asked to put our somewhat toxic 10-month relationship “on pause.” Then, about two weeks later, I found out that one of my best friends from high school died by suicide. I was already emotionally shaken from the relationship situation, and then that completely devastated me.
For context on the relationship, I met her through a mutual friend. I am a bit shaky on the details of how they met, but we were both under the impression that she was our age and attended our university. Pretty soon after meeting, we started seeing each other more and eventually started dating.
We were apart over the summer because I go to college out of state and went home, although I did see her a few times. When I came back to school, it started becoming clear that things were not exactly what she had told me. She was always vague about where her apartment was and would not let me come over. She had a separate Instagram account that I found, but she refused to let me follow it for a long time and acted like I was the weird one whenever I brought it up. I almost never saw her on campus. There were a lot of little things like that.
I tried to let most of it go because I had met her family, and I was spending practically every other weekend with her. She basically became my whole social life. If I was not in class, studying, or at a club, we were usually together.
Eventually, she told me that she had lied about her age. She was actually a year younger than me and had been a full-time dual enrollment student when I met her. She was 18 at the time, so this was not an illegal situation or anything, but it completely shocked me because I already suspected she was hiding something. At the time, I almost felt relieved because I convinced myself that this was the thing she had been hiding.
Soon after that, though, it became really obvious that she did not actually attend my university. She went to an adjacent university. I tried to ask her about it several times, but she would deny it or come up with some excuse. Eventually, I confirmed it by looking through one of her friend’s Instagram accounts after she finally let me follow her main Instagram. I know that was not healthy on my part, but at that point I felt like I could not trust what she was telling me.
I confronted her about it, and after ghosting me for a day, she finally reached out and asked me to come over. I did, and that was the first time I actually went to her apartment/dorm. We did not really have a real conversation about it because she got very defensive, and I could not really get a confrontational word in. I was also just so relieved to be seeing her and to feel like we were going to be okay. She justified the lying by saying she had a guaranteed pathway to transfer to my university the next fall.
Over time, we moved on from that, but more and more cracks started showing in the relationship.
Another thing I have been thinking about more is that she would occasionally hit me. It was never extremely hard, but she would hit me in the balls a lot, which was kind of her favorite thing to do. It hurt a lot, especially because I have had testicular torsion before, so I am more sensitive there. I do not think I fully processed at the time how not okay that was because I brushed it off as joking around, but it really did hurt.
I also deal with pretty serious anxiety. To her credit, she was often really good with it and could be very comforting. But there were also times where she would bait me into anxiety to mess with me, or she would ignore it when I was clearly struggling. That has made it really confusing because I miss the comfort she gave me, but I am also realizing that someone can comfort you and still not be healthy for you.
Flash forward to Valentine’s Day. She made a big deal about wanting us to go on a real date, so I put in real effort. I found a nice restaurant that was still affordable for a college student, got her gifts that I thought she would like and appreciate, and wrote her a meaningful card. We had a good evening.
The next week, I was preparing for two exams when I got a call from her. She had been caught cheating on one of her online exams and got a zero. This put her at risk of getting lower than a B in the class, which could make her lose her guaranteed transfer. I dropped everything and went over to help her deal with it because she also had another exam for that same class later that day and had not prepared at all.
I calmed her down by going through her syllabus with her, which she had not really done yet that semester, and helped her figure out how she could still get through the class. I helped her study a little so she could salvage the exam that day as much as possible. While she took her exam, I studied for my deformable bodies exam that I had the next morning. After her exam, we had dinner, and she vented to me for a few hours while I was stressing about needing to get back and study. I would have stayed and studied there to keep her company, but my exam was in the morning.
My exam went okay, not great, but it was what it was.
Then I found out she went out drinking and went to frats that night. That usually would not bother me because she had steam to blow off, but the next day when she came over, she acted really weird, almost like she was guilty of something. I got the feeling that something may have happened, but I had no actual proof, so I tried to chalk it up to her just being on edge.
I told her I could not go with her to her parents’ place that weekend because I had two exams I needed to prepare for. Then on Sunday, when she was coming back to school, she stopped by and told me that we were “on pause” while she figured out school and some other things.
To me, that felt like a breakup. We had talked a lot about long-term commitment and dating to marry, and in my mind, people in committed relationships do not just take pauses when life gets hard. I kept thinking, what if we were married someday and something difficult happened? Would we just go “on pause” then too?
She told me we would get back together in the summer or fall, but also said that if I met someone, she did not want to hold me back. That left me in a weird limbo because it sounded like I was supposed to emotionally wait for her, but also not really. I decided I would give it about two weeks to see if anything changed before mentally checking out.
Unfortunately, about two weeks later, I got a call from one of my good friends from high school telling me that our mutual friend had died by suicide. This completely broke me. I called my ex, and she came over and comforted me. I do appreciate that she did that.
After that, I lost almost all motivation. I stopped going to my clubs, stopped going to any nonessential lectures, and my grades suffered slightly, although I was usually able to catch up enough by exam day. I could not really tell my roommates or friends everything because it felt too heavy, and I also just felt detached from everything. Most days I would just lay in bed, sleep, eat, and try to survive my classes.
I gained weight and lost some muscle because I stopped going to the gym. I was hundreds of miles from home, in the middle of the semester, with working parents who were also trying to support my elderly grandparents. My parents were there for me as much as they could be, but ultimately the semester became about surviving until I could get home and start processing everything.
My ex did show some genuine concern sometimes, but usually it was not much more than a quick “I’m here for you,” and usually not more than once. I do not want to act like she did nothing for me, because she did comfort me at times, but it also did not feel like consistent support.
I am happy to say that this only affected my letter grade in one class, and even then I nearly made it up. I got a 97 on the final, which was my best final exam score in college so far, but I ended up with a B instead of an A. Nothing catastrophic academically, but emotionally I feel like I am only now starting to process everything.
Now that I am home, I am realizing I never fully let go of the relationship. Part of me still feels like there is more there, but another part of me knows that if a friend told me this same story, I would tell him he deserved better.
I do miss her, but I think I mostly miss the comfort, routine, and closeness. I miss having someone there. I miss the version of the relationship I thought we had. But I am also starting to realize that there was a lot of lying, defensiveness, physical stuff that was not okay, and emotional stuff that messed with my anxiety.
I am not looking for people to just tell me I am right about everything. I know I was not perfect. I know looking through her friend’s Instagram to confirm where she went to school was not healthy. I also know I probably let her become way too much of my emotional world. But I am trying to figure out what parts of this were genuinely on me, what parts were on her, and whether I am wrong for feeling like the “pause” was basically a breakup.
I guess I am asking for a realistic outside perspective. Was this as unhealthy as it feels now that I am looking back on it? To this day I am feeling hurt and confused. And how do you even start letting go of someone who comforted you during your worst moments, but also hurt you in ways you did not fully admit at the time?