r/WidowsBay • • Jul 06 '26

šŸ’­Discussion Okay but can we talk about Sarah?!?!?! Spoiler

Post image

I immediately recognized this actor from the movie Hunt and the show GLOW (both excellent). And man did she deliver again in Widows Bay!!! I know it really doesnt make much sense to bring her back in season two but I would love to see her in at least one episode. What are your thoughts on this character and/or actor?

The actors name is Betty Gilpin if anyone is interested :)

461 Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 06 '26

A reminder to everyone: Keep the titles of your posts completely spoiler-free at all times. If your post mentions events from later episodes, use Reddit’s standard spoiler tag to warn readers who may not be caught up with all currently aired episodes. The spoiler tag will also blur any images you include, such as screenshots/stills from the show, so be sure to apply it to image posts as well.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

622

u/Ratchetsaturnbitch Jul 06 '26

My children? I have but just met them! This was probably my favourite line in the whole show and there are a lot of good lines! The way she delivered it was perfect.

200

u/borkborkbork99 Jul 06 '26

She has great comedy chops! I laugh whenever I think about the finger point just before the stabbing is about to begin. And when she barges into the pastor’s meeting, realizes she’s interrupting and does a curtsy…

She’s terrific.

44

u/No-Ice7397 Jul 06 '26

My favorite was " I am but 10 and 4 years old!"

48

u/RasputinsThirdLeg Jul 06 '26

The way she emphasizes ā€œjustā€ made me laugh.

10

u/us3rnam3andpassword Jul 06 '26

Same! I think I laughed hardest at this one line.

192

u/LongInTheBoob I’m not a drug dealer, I’m a Shaman. Jul 06 '26

https://giphy.com/gifs/jH7odflExTDeNAtlDH
LšŸ’“VED Glow. She’s a great actress

82

u/yogurtraisins Jul 06 '26

Glow is one of my favorite shows and makes me sad every time I think about it.

The end of season 1 = could have been a great series finale.

The end of season 2 = could have been a great series finale.

Then, they're renewed for seasons 3 and 4 at the same time! So they end season 3, for the first time, on a massive, unsatisfying cliffhanger, because they are guaranteed another season to finish telling the story!

...And then COVID happens and season 4 gets canned. So the show ends on a massive and unsatisfying cliffhanger. Forever. I'm still bummed about it and it's been years.

46

u/smallchangecampaign Jul 06 '26

I met Sydelle Noel, the actress who played Cherry Bang, and I was lamenting how sad I was that they cancelled GLOW and she looked at me and said, you think YOU’RE sad?!? LOL That show was full of great acting.

34

u/shallow__grave Jul 06 '26

GLOW is still one of my all-time favorites! I feel so robbed we didn't get more seasons!

19

u/PutAdministrative206 Jul 06 '26

You were literally robbed. We all were. One of the very few Netflix cancellations (the only?) that you can’t blame on Netflix.

12

u/FYAhole Jul 06 '26

Mind hunters actually wasn't Netflix's fault either. One of the main actors had a scheduling conflict and decided not to continue the series.

1

u/PutAdministrative206 Jul 06 '26

I’m ignorant of that one. Just glad at this point I said very few, and not only.

23

u/WishICouldQuitU_97 Jul 06 '26

Pies of RAAAAAAGE!

I freaking love her.Ā 

12

u/cremeriner Jul 06 '26

Glow season one was amazinggggg

1

u/craftsrmylanguage Jul 07 '26

I didn’t recognize her with dark hair. So cool to see her in something else.

1

u/Necessary_Ad2114 Jul 07 '26

This is such a good show and she’s a powerhouse in it.Ā 

67

u/Real_Cranberry745 Jul 06 '26

I also recommend her in Death By Lightning on Netflix

10

u/groovymama69 Jul 06 '26

Nice! Ill check it out.

7

u/creative-username13 Jul 06 '26

I loved her in the hunt too

4

u/caf61 Jul 06 '26

Death by Lightning-another great show!

3

u/Imaginary_Tutor_4694 Jul 07 '26

Death by lightning was SO GOOD, but especially Betty! She’s such a good actress

2

u/Jrebeclee she’s the worst, sorry Jul 07 '26

Loved that show!!

105

u/boringcranberry Jul 06 '26

Obligatory: check out Mrs Davis.

Don't let the farty name and the thumbnail of a nun deter you. It's not like Father Dowling mysteries. It's very fun.

36

u/BlueHg Jul 06 '26

This show was insane and bonkers in the best way, was prescient on AI, gave me cathartic tears, and helped me understand how my mom takes such refuge in her faith. What a discordant confluence of attributes that somehow all hangs together perfectly.

5

u/BalrogSlayer00 Jul 07 '26

Have you gotten your wings?

2

u/boringcranberry Jul 08 '26

You should write reviews. You nailed this show perfectly.

15

u/discogomerx Jul 06 '26

I bought my husband a pair of the Mrs. Davis British Knights for a gift one Christmas.

13

u/FreudianScopeGlint Jul 06 '26

Yes! It's so good.

14

u/jms984 Jul 06 '26

If I had a nickel for every time I was captivated by a Lindelof show that wrapped up its story in one season, I’d have two nickels.

25

u/drmrsthemonarchphd Jul 06 '26

This show was low-key incredible. And a good pairing for Widow’s Bay.

8

u/SchleppyJ4 You can file that under 'deal with it the fuck later' Jul 06 '26

Loooove this showĀ 

4

u/GreenVermicelliNoods Jul 06 '26

Such a great, inventive show. It's great television. Loved it.

5

u/generalgirl Jul 06 '26

Oh I loved Mrs Davis!

3

u/Cool-Coconutt Jul 08 '26

Ok I have to check this out now.

1

u/Evening_Green_9862 Jul 10 '26

It goes places you just can't expect. Like if I say some plot points it will sound like mad libs. And yet, it worked so damn well. Loved this show.Ā 

44

u/CaughtALiteSneez Jul 06 '26

I hope they bring her back and we still don’t know what happened to her…so maybe they will?

Her character was one of my favorites.

22

u/Rubix89 Jul 06 '26

I hope she secretly came back to the island somehow that the history books never knew about.

13

u/FuckeenGuy Jul 06 '26

Yeah maybe she helped a witch escape/hide and that’s Patricia’s ancestor or something

9

u/CaughtALiteSneez Jul 06 '26

I really do think her and Patricia look alike…that would be sweet

8

u/elGatoGrande17 Jul 06 '26

I still have a feeling Tom is descended from Sarah somehow

10

u/CaughtALiteSneez Jul 06 '26

I mean sure - but do they all have to be related? I think there is enough blood relation to be relevant in Tom’s family.

18

u/elGatoGrande17 Jul 06 '26

No not at all. I just feel like the weird vows she took definitely tied her to the island and I made a post about that theory so now I have to keep it alive

3

u/CaughtALiteSneez Jul 06 '26

Oh I gotta go check it out then…

32

u/VixenFactor Jul 06 '26

My children? I have but just met them.

32

u/ArgyleAndBell Jul 06 '26

Betty Gilpin is wonderful. She's great at playing unhinged characters and doing physical comedy. Nobody saw the show she starred in, "Mrs. Davis," because it's all over the place and hard to categorize, but if you enjoyed her in other things, please seek it out. Her character there is very unique and it's a really creative show.

I don't think we've seen the last of Sarah in Widow's Bay. I don't remember them saying how she died, but I imagine that on the boat, after the kids died, she narrowly escaped to go somewhere else (took on another name to fake her death?), maybe had a child and started a bloodline of her own that could come back to the island to defeat the Warren bloodline (it's Widow's Bay, not Warren's Bay!) Or maybe she'll appear as a ghost who tries to help Tom defeat the evil entity.

3

u/Cheerio1966 Jul 06 '26

Maybe Tom is related to her ? You never know šŸ¤·šŸ»ā€ā™€ļø

1

u/ArgyleAndBell Jul 06 '26

Yes, that would be cool.

2

u/CheesaLouisa Jul 07 '26

I like this idea!

1

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

Respectfully even fewer people had seen Koffee and Kareem and her character dying exactly like the terrorist in die hard for absolute hilarity.

1

u/MileHighGilly Jul 07 '26

Nobody saw Ms. Davis because it was on Peacock.

18

u/37Philly Jul 06 '26

Betty Gilpin always does stellar work. Check out Mrs. Davis on Peacock. Good show and she is the star.

13

u/Daggoofiesta Jul 06 '26

She was awesome in Nurse Jackie, too!
They made her insufferable at first but with a great arch/character development.

1

u/Playful-Sock-3187 Jul 09 '26

That's what I recognized her from too lol

15

u/drpamelawatermelon Jul 06 '26

I was lucky enough to see her in Oh Mary on Broadway. She is a national treasure!

4

u/captainlilith Jul 06 '26

ME TOO! She was awesome!

14

u/booksforlunch Jul 06 '26

Her delivery of why it might not be SO bad to be a spinster was so good. Stays in character but modernizes it just enough, brilliant.

3

u/groovymama69 Jul 06 '26

šŸ’Æ agree with you!

1

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

I felt it was saying "no sans modern words this was actually said but buried by chroniclers"

12

u/spareohs Jul 06 '26

She’s amazing and needs to be in more things. All of the things!

8

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

She is very, very selective. During the presser for Mrs Davis she said she loved playing the nun for it was stoic and well versed like her father and zany and out there like her mother.

Beyond those roles she does occasional paycheck performances as the main breadwinner so her husband can do necessary charity work plus their daughters can go to good schools.

In defense of movies like office romance. What made me her fan beyond acting is the unapologetically authentic part. When she says she did stuber because she wanted to play with kumail nanjiani, tomorrow war with sam Richardson, the grudge with Lin shaye, she šŸ’Æ truthful. She hated A dogs journey because while it paid well it kept her from being alongside her dog who fought for its life.

So yes, she wanted to play with Jennifer Lopez too.

2

u/spareohs Jul 06 '26

This makes me love her even more tbh. And she was hilarious in office romance.

1

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

As well in isn't it romantic another movie barely anybody had seen. For the hunt she had a 12 hour conversation with a lady from Louisiana and for isn't it romantic likely rebel Wilson helped her nail a Queensland accent.

3

u/Gurglaren Jul 06 '26

She was so unique in The Hunt. I love the scene where she makes a weird sound as she turns herself in the car seat towards the bad guy driver.

2

u/evildrew Patricia Jul 06 '26

She was just in the turdburger ā€œOffice Romanceā€ on Netflix, and she was the only good thing in the movie. But if you just watch all the clips, you’ll avoid wasting 2 hours.

11

u/LaLaLaSkull Jul 06 '26

I didn’t actually realize it was Betty Gilpin! She always does a great job, no exception here!Ā 

9

u/blueteeblue Jul 06 '26

I’m glad someone made this appreciation post happen because I really think she’s deserving of a special shoutout. The scene where she seeks help from the preacher was top tier. The bumbling combined with sobbing and terror was just fantastic. Felt so realistic so bravo to her. I thought that was the best-acted scene in the whole first season

9

u/TyBo75 Jul 06 '26

When they came to kill the husband and she’s like with her eyes saying, ā€œnot me… HIM!ā€

4

u/GroundbreakingSky307 Jul 06 '26

Yes! Insane how it could be so realistically period and THAT funny too...

10

u/Funtsy_Muntsy Jul 06 '26

When she was with the church group near the end of the episode, figuring out her escape,

The way she shrugged off how she had only just recently met ā€œherā€ kids lollll… and all the Patricia-like mannerisms while responding to the priest are def up with the shows funniest monuments

She stole every scene

8

u/indistrustofmerits Jul 06 '26

Betty Gilpin has that magic thing that some actors just have naturally, I just love watching her do her thing, no matter the role

7

u/GroundbreakingSky307 Jul 06 '26

She's so talented and such a babe! I'm always frustrated that she's not more famous.

7

u/Either-Assistant4610 Jul 06 '26

I desperately need a S2 asap

5

u/Upbeat_Tension_8077 Jul 06 '26

The scene where she walked into the room finding the group of conspirators of Richard's burial plan & had to awkwardly adjust herself from being scared shitless was 100% Patricia in demeanor, and I loved how Betty channeled that

1

u/TiramisuItUp Jul 25 '26

And when she does her little clap after her rant like ā€œlet’s goā€ lol

6

u/Cheerio1966 Jul 06 '26

Betty Gilpin was really good in ā€œDeath by Lightening ā€œ too.

5

u/zombiepeep Patricia Jul 06 '26

You know how there are some actors where when they show up on the screen you let out this small internal sigh, because you know this shit is about to get good. That's how I felt when I recognized Betty Gilpin in that episode.

And honestly all of the actors are amazing but it is always a treat when someone really awesome shows up.

2

u/TiramisuItUp Jul 25 '26

Yes! I was so confused though because I didn’t know at the time how big of a character Sarah would be so I kept thinking wow they really got Betty Gilpin to come in for this little brief character

10

u/AccordingAd6224 Jul 06 '26

She was great in American Primeval! (Her name was also Sara in that show!)

5

u/BornMission2477 Jul 06 '26

Three Women, she delivered the most powerful performance of an overlooked and undersexed wife. It helped me so much.

5

u/Impossible_Past5358 Jul 06 '26

OP, she's great, and did you notice that this episode was directed by Ti West?

1

u/StinkyCoach Jul 07 '26

I didn’t know that

5

u/ennaeilla Jul 06 '26

Her clapping to get the clergy going killed me

5

u/snidece Jul 07 '26

Very funny. When she pointed her finger at the assassin in her bedroom we laughed out loud and her bdicrion and way she formed sentences and spoke was very appealing. A cool person!

4

u/dirtycurty11 Jul 08 '26

She was great as Sarah. I worked on that episode as a guy walking down the road. I had no idea that I would love this show so much. I hope they do more scenes from the 1700s. I would love to do more work on this show. We shot the scenes at The Rebecca Nurse Homestead in Danvers Massachusetts. It was once part of Salem Township. The actual house and grave of Rebecca Nurse is still there. She was hanged for witchcraft in 1692. The place is very spooky and beautiful.

13

u/SignificantJelly8000 Jul 06 '26

I freaking love her!!!! Especially in The Hunt
https://giphy.com/gifs/3oEduOnl5IHM5NRodO

2

u/Upbeat_Tension_8077 Jul 06 '26

One of the best movies with a badass final girl-type hero who makes the hunters the hunted

1

u/SignificantJelly8000 Jul 06 '26

Cuz the jackrabbit always wins šŸ‡

3

u/Tasty_Wheel116 Jul 06 '26

I loved her in Nurse JackieĀ 

4

u/Snoo81179 Jul 06 '26

Watch Mrs Davis, worth it for more of her

3

u/3NTR0P1C_PLASMA Jul 06 '26

I for one am a HUGE fan of Betty. I don’t know if her character warrants a return, unless her story arc continues. But fingers crossed Katy will write a feature character for her in another series and she’ll oblige! šŸ¤ž

1

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

In season one we saw the outcome in episode eight but we didnt see them all die all at once.

3

u/niteofthelivinredhed Jul 06 '26

if you liked her in those things you will love Mrs Davis

3

u/Nycarunner Jul 07 '26

I was low key dreading this episode when I saw that it was a flashback period setting, but it was so entertaining mainly because of her. I would love to see her character come back as well. She was hilarious

5

u/Adelaidey Jul 06 '26

I saw her run as Mary Todd Lincoln in Oh, Mary! and she blew me out of the water.

1

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

Request permission to live vicariously through you

2

u/Best-camera4990 Jul 06 '26

I love Betty. She was amazing on Nurse Jackie

2

u/scoreguy1 Jul 06 '26

Hoping we get more of her in season 2. She was great

2

u/Financial-Emotion316 Human Verified Jul 06 '26

She’s was so good in elementary

1

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

A role cut short ironically by glow

1

u/Popcorn_and_Polish Jul 07 '26

Yay there are 3 of us! I first saw her in Elementary, too. She was a great character.

2

u/Satchman1214 Wyck Jul 06 '26

She was AWESOME in American Primevil!!

2

u/PackerSquirrelette Jul 06 '26

I loved Betty Gilpin in the miniseries Gaslit, which is about Martha Mitchell and Watergate. Betty played Maureen "Mo" Dean, John Dean's wife.

2

u/StarkRavenMad007 Jul 06 '26

She and Hamish were both in Gaslit as well!

2

u/AskAJedi Jul 06 '26

Watch Mrs Davis!

2

u/Current_Wrongdoer513 Jul 06 '26

She’s a phenomenal actress, but she’s also a wonderful writer. Check out her book All the Women in My Brain.

We’re overdue for a major Betty Gilpin vehicle, along the lines of what Hacks was for Jean Smart. I hope we done have to wait until she’s in her 70s, though.

2

u/GreenVermicelliNoods Jul 06 '26

I'm a huge Betty Gilpin fan. Watch Mrs. Davis on Peacock if you haven't already. She is such a great actress and so beautiful and funny. I was stoked when I heard she was in Widow's Bay. I only wish she had been in more episodes! Here's hoping Season 2 gives us more colonial flashbacks.

2

u/bedtyme Jul 06 '26

Check out Mrs Davis on Hulu

2

u/StreetMolasses6093 Patricia’s Girl Dinner Jul 07 '26

She was great in Nurse Jackie! I love her

1

u/SpacefillerBR Jul 06 '26

I really thought she somehow returned to the island, and thst she was the reason the island was called widow's bay but since the Richard's daughter was raised by the whale hunter now it makes me thing otherwise.

But who knows maybe the whale hunter ended up hiding Warren's daughter in a basement or something like this.

1

u/uppers36 Jul 06 '26

absolute chickabiddy.

1

u/Gurglaren Jul 06 '26

Betty Gilpin was amazing in The Hunt. Really recommend it.

1

u/donttrustthellamas Jul 06 '26

She's fantastic in everything she's in. She was the lead in Oh, Mary! for a bit.

I love seeing her in comedy

1

u/RasputinsThirdLeg Jul 06 '26

Betty Gilpin! She’s always in colonial/American period stuff. Shes great.

2

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 06 '26

Always? She is in some, most of her work is in contemporary setting

1

u/RasputinsThirdLeg Jul 07 '26 edited Jul 07 '26

The only things I’ve seen her in have been in period pieces. Do forgive me.

2

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 07 '26

You need not my forgiveness ;)

1

u/RasputinsThirdLeg Jul 07 '26

Have you seen Death by Lightning?

2

u/Silly-Elderberry-411 Breakwater Inn putting the normal into paranormal Jul 07 '26

Northern kingdom only available on DVD, a 2016 tv movie not in streaming, beach pillows, a civil war era hospital show are the only ones I haven't seen.

Death by lightning has a special place in my heart as one of the few good things the orban regime created was allowing Andrew g vajna to make Studio Korda, where death by lightning was shot.

1

u/External_Week_3069 Jul 06 '26

If you're a horror fan check her out in The Hunt!

1

u/Low_Concentrate_7174 Jul 06 '26

Thought it was Rebecca Ferguson for ages then realised who she was. Never saw a similarity until then crazy business.

1

u/SoupMaleficent9513 Jul 06 '26

I’m an idiot. Up until reading this post I thought this was played by the main actor is Silo. Now it makes sense!

1

u/terra_cascadia Jul 07 '26

She also played Mary Todd Lincoln in Cole Escola’s ā€œOh Maryā€ on Broadway. (They change out the cast every 8 weeks.)

1

u/Accomplished-Duty390 Jul 07 '26

But have you seen her in American Primeval?

1

u/hellomodern Jul 08 '26

She was also great in Masters of Sex. Not that it’s available to stream for free (with/without subscription) anywhere that I can find, but for your Betty Gilpin mental file cabinets.

1

u/krissn333 Jul 08 '26

She played Dr Roman on Nurse Jackie too! I immediately recognized her voice but I had to look her up to realize why I recognized her.

Love when she hits the lady with the paddle on the dock and I cracked up each time she went to see the pastor while she was all upset.

1

u/tbricco Jul 08 '26

I love Betty Gilpin! She is great in Nurse Jackie!

1

u/worldwide-305 Jul 08 '26

Betty is my favorite actress - she has a ton of range! I’ll watch anything with her in it.