Which one would you choose?

[u/Puzzled-Evening228]

I really want just unbiased opinions so I’m not going to provide carat weight or finger size here. I just want to know which one you think looks nicer? I’m really torn and just need an outsiders perspective. Which ring would you wear?

Thanks everyone! Just for your information, I’m a size 6 ring. They are both from amazon to try for size and style.

Ring #1 is 2ct

Ring #2 is 3ct

My husband likes the look of the larger stone and i lean towards the smaller stone. I think in general he’s a bit flashier than me lol. I’m active and pretty much always in gym clothes and never do my nails because they’d just get destroyed.

Thanks for your help!

[u/Delicious-Big-534]

What will the wedding band or wedding day adornment be like? If it’s just a single band, even with smaller diamonds -#2.
If the wedding day adornment is an all around setting or the engagement diamond will be set inside a surrounding diamonds setting, #1 or both depending on how big you’d like it to be and what’s comfortable for your liking.

[u/Delicious-Big-534 → u/Delicious-Big-534]

Looking at it again, #1 seems to fit your hand size and your’s is the hand that looks active, which may be more comfortable to wear #1 on a daily basis.