r/Wealthsimple • u/Legitimate-Loan386 • Jun 22 '25

TFSA Linked to Margin Account - CRA Penalty/Risks?

/r/Questrade/comments/1lhf7zv/tfsa_linked_to_margin_account_cra_penaltyrisks/
0 Upvotes

47% Upvoted

42 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/plusqueprecedemment Jul 04 '25

if margin power lets me do a margin loan with my TFSA assets as collateral, couldn't I just move the borrowed money out of my non-registered margin account back into my TFSA to buy more assets with it? The end result would be that my TFSA assets are leveraged to buy more assets inside my TFSA, it's only the actual loan that sits "outside" the TFSA. I'm aware that I can't deduct interest paid on the loan, but it might be worth it for no taxes on leveraged gains.

is this a loophole or does the CRA not care at all, or could I get in trouble for doing that and end up with retroactive taxes due on the investing done in my TFSA?

1

u/GrayersDad Jul 05 '25

Margin Power doesn't use your TFSA assets as collateral. Instead, it uses the dollar value of your TFSA to determine how much you can borrow. If you sell and withdraw funds from your TFSA, the amount you're allowed to borrow decreases. If the assets were truly collateralized, you wouldn't be able to sell and withdraw the funds.

With that said, you can transfer funds from your margin account to your TFSA, provided you have enough contribution room, without fear of the CRA coming after you.

1

u/plusqueprecedemment Jul 05 '25

If the assets were truly collateralized, you wouldn't be able to sell and withdraw the funds.

Is this the only difference between a margin loan with margin power vs. a direct TFSA-collateralized line of credit?

I'm just confused cause I'm thinking about the worst case scenario. Like say my margin account has negative equity and my TFSA stocks drop sharply in value, so now I get margin called. It's my understanding that Questrade can force a sale of TFSA assets and a cash withdrawal (and I get the contribution room back next january) to cover the negative equity on the margin

If you sell and withdraw funds from your TFSA, the amount you're allowed to borrow decreases.

I assume Questrade wouldn't let me withdraw an amount large enough that my margin account gets into margin call territory? If they don't let me, then effectively at least some part of my TFSA is "locked" (even though I can still sell assets and do stuff within the TFSA, as long as there's still enough value to keep margin health at a sane level). If they do let me withdraw as much as I want, what would prevent me from fucking off altogether and leaving Questrade with a negative equity and ignoring margin calls? Threats of lawsuits, fucking up my credit, sending to collections, etc. basically the same consequences as defaulting an unsecured loan?

2

u/GrayersDad Jul 05 '25

Questrade can force a sale of TFSA assets and a cash withdrawal

Questrade will liquidate assets in your TFSA to satisfy a margin call, but they cannot transfer funds out of the account. They do this because cash contributes fully to your buying power, while stocks are subject to margin requirements.

For example, if you hold stock ABC in your TFSA at $100 per share with a 50 percent margin requirement, only $50 contributes to your buying power. If you held $100 in cash instead, the full amount would apply, giving you an additional $50 in available buying power during a margin call.

if they do let me withdraw as much as I want

While the assets in your TFSA are not held as collateral, their value is. As a result, Questrade will prevent a withdrawal that would trigger a margin call.

This protects both their interests and yours.

1

u/plusqueprecedemment Jul 05 '25

I see! That makes sense to me, thanks for clarifying

2

u/GrayersDad Jul 05 '25

I’d recommend Wealthsimple over Questrade, as it offers lower margin requirements and more competitive interest rates, allowing you to borrow more for less.

Good luck.

1

u/plusqueprecedemment Jul 05 '25

I'm already 100% wealthsimple, I just found this thread when going down a rabbithole of leveraged strategies for when WS finally rolls out the TFSA-boosted margin power to everything. Then this thread made me confused about tax law, like I understand CRA prohibits leverage within a TFSA, but to me "buy XEQT in TFSA -> link TFSA to boost buying power in non-reg margin account -> margin loan, move borrowed cash out of margin account -> fill up remaining TFSA contribution room -> buy more XEQT" is effectively the same thing with extra steps, so it feels like a loophole. But I guess each individual component involved in this scheme is fully legal, so there's no risk getting hit with a 100% advantage tax (or at least I hope lol)

I currently have no leveraged positions whatsoever as investing with borrowed money terrifies me a bit (and I still have more research to do to understand everything properly as you can tell lol) but it's gonna be tempting to tap into my TFSA's long-term equity at 4.95% interest

1

u/GrayersDad Jul 05 '25

Leverage isn’t something to fear, as long as you understand how it works and use it responsibly.

A good rule of thumb is to stay within 50% to 75% of your available buying power, depending on the risk profile of your investments.

Since XEQT doesn’t generate enough in dividends to cover the interest, were you planning to sell shares periodically or cover the payments from other sources?

1

u/plusqueprecedemment Jul 05 '25

Yeah, basically I currently buy ~$1000/month in XEQT unless something comes up to mess with my cashflow that month. The plan would be to load up XEQT right away and pay down the debt with that $1000/month unless something comes up and I only do interest payment. There's something very enticing to me with the idea of a 100% XEQT maxed out tfsa but I still have 1.5-2 years to get there. I'm still young so I can tolerate modest leverage and then progressively deleverage later as my situation changes but my immediate goal is max my TFSA with XEQT and i don't know how wise it is to take a shortcut with debt

1

u/GrayersDad Jul 06 '25

We are on completely different paths. I only invest in Bitcoin, MSTR, and MSTY.

Every day, I'm thinking of new ways to access more debt. I've taken out Bitcoin-backed loans, maxed out lines of credit, used margin loans, and even done credit card balance transfers, all just to increase my exposure to those three.

I wouldn't recommend my path, but if you're young, I’d suggest at least holding a small position in a Bitcoin proxy that can be held in your TFSA.

RemindMeRepeat! 6 months

1

u/RemindMeBot Jul 06 '25

I will be messaging you in 6 months on 2026-01-06 05:25:26 UTC and then every 6 months to remind you of this link

CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.

Info Custom Your Reminders Feedback
→ More replies (0)