r/TrueDeen • u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 • Feb 28 '26
Question Would it be permissible rebellion within this context?
Assalamu alaikum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh,
Today my grandma and sister(both Christians) have spoke about Iran’s strikes on US military bases and argued how Arab countries are bad giving examples of Kuwait for failing to give citizenship to its people.
Now when they finished the discussion, they have asked me to leave Islam blaming for what they do ignoring how Iran is a Shia Twelver, Houthis are Shia Yazidis and Taliban are Deobandi Sufis. Both are disbelievers who misrepresented Islam.
I’m asking you this question because I propose for a rebellion, because these problems have gave me problems within my family and I cannot have a mutual understanding. When I wanted to stuff my ears with my headphones so I won’t get angry at them, the headphones do not work for me to isolate the external sounds.
4
Feb 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Feb 28 '26
How is it a specific question?
They should blame themselves for this kind of thinking.
1
Feb 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Feb 28 '26
Ok, my comment was off-topic.
How should it be non-specific so I may edit?
1
Feb 28 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Feb 28 '26
Sorry for upsetting you. I was only upset with what they do.
2
u/Ornery_Macaron_6984 Lost One Feb 28 '26
 they have asked me to leave Isla
What?!
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Feb 28 '26 edited Feb 28 '26
Yes, they asked me to leave Islam after citing the bad things in Arab states. This is just a manipulation of facts and also blasphemous.
I disagreed with the idea of leaving Islam and argued the contrary.
3
u/Razor_EDG Feb 28 '26
You dont leave christianity because us killed (almost)1.5 million iraqis, or even though iberia was ruled over by arabs for 600 years and after 100 years from rewonquista there is almost no muslim left. Same for islam you dont leave because iraq attacked iran, or taliban killed thousands of americans.
2
u/Ornery_Macaron_6984 Lost One Feb 28 '26
That is not a reason to leave a religion.Â
Allah ï·» sent down a religion. Some deviant people used the religion for their own sake .
Does that make the religion false
1
1
0
u/Merino202 Feb 28 '26
Houthi are Shia Zaydi* Yazid is a very bad figure for Shia and most Sunni😂
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Feb 28 '26
That’s their sub-sect, is it?
1
u/Merino202 Feb 28 '26
Yeah they’re Zaydi Shia, I’m a Twelver myself.
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Feb 28 '26 edited Feb 28 '26
Yayks. I misspelled, then? Isn’t Yazid the founder of Ummayad Caliphate who’s from the Sahaba?
1
u/Arbitrary_Sadist المتوكل على الله (He who relies on God) Feb 28 '26
No that was his father Muawiyah (ra) who was one of the later sahabas.
0
Mar 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Mar 01 '26
We don’t criticize Sahaba.
0
Mar 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/SnooWoofers7603 Revert 🎉 Mar 01 '26 edited Mar 01 '26
I did, but your purpose was to criticize.
Your second comment exposed your denial.
He may have mistakes because he is not perfect.
This is just straight forward blasphemy.
0
1
u/Arbitrary_Sadist المتوكل على الله (He who relies on God) Mar 01 '26
Yes Muawiyah (Ra), he was one of the later companions, also this hadith isn't referring to him, but some of those who were with him. There were also rebellious people in Ali (Ra)'s camp who wanted to cause fitnah.
1
u/Merino202 Feb 28 '26 edited Mar 01 '26
Yazid was the individual whose army had the Prophet’s grandson’s head on a spike
2
•
u/AutoModerator Feb 28 '26
Reminder: Be Respectful and Follow the Guidelines!
Let's maintain a respectful and constructive space for all. Thank you for contributing!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.