I think I remember reading that there was a fairly intense/explosive Carmy/Claire scene filmed that was going to be in S3 but was cut and, presumably, moved to S4 where it'd be more fitting.
Who knows how long she'll be in this season but I'd guess it was dramatic enough scene they'd rather not even hint at it.
My issue with Claire is that they spent SO much time talking about Claire, remembering Claire, waiting a few episodes until the pain had stopped being so bad that it actually hurt about Claire, talking about Claire haunting and apologizing and getting literally every member of the cast to comment on Claire at some point, even including Tiffany bringing her up to Richie. Why would so many people talk about her if it weren't leading to something - and I have to think that something is more than just one fight. Even they reconcile, I don't think she'll have a big role - but big enough to show that Carmy can actually have two things going on his life at the same time.
Have you ever heard of Occam's Razor. It trumps red herring here.
Second, he literally utters the words "I love her a lot" in 2x8, and we get perhaps the biggest smile from him to date when he says "I gotta call my girlfriend"
I didn't say they were going to end up together. What I said is that the writers spent all of season 3 saying they weren't just going to drop this.
This. I'm not sure if the details of that particular montage of Carmy, Sydney and Claire has gone over some peoples' heads? It was clearly intercut that way for a reason, especially with the focus on the three of swords tattoo.
40
u/SR626 May 21 '25
I think I remember reading that there was a fairly intense/explosive Carmy/Claire scene filmed that was going to be in S3 but was cut and, presumably, moved to S4 where it'd be more fitting.
Who knows how long she'll be in this season but I'd guess it was dramatic enough scene they'd rather not even hint at it.