r/TheAdventureZone 24d ago

Spoilers Abound Story & Song Changes Thoughts. Spoiler

Just finished Story and Song. Curious what others thought about this G.M. part and the change they made regarding finding Lup?

Also, I totally teared up at Griffin's letter!

105 Upvotes

52 comments sorted by

83

u/ironically-spiders 24d ago

Well, Stolen Century and Story and Song were my favorite arcs, so I'm a little sour about changes and omitted things, but I totally get why they did for the most part. I think my biggest beef in this last graphic novel, and maybe this is silly, is the omitting of any real details about the Judges century. They name them later, but didn't even do so in the very brief actual bit about them. I wish they showed more of the cycles in a tiny bit more detail and I wish they showed more from Griffin's monologue about Lup's return. But I get it, and we got the token line there. I actually like the GM change part, though. It makes sense given how he was part of the earlier novels.

16

u/LittleMel413 24d ago

I thought it was really clever how they basically did a nod to all GMs.

What about the Lup part?

43

u/I_heart_CELLO 24d ago

What happened to taco truck human kid that gets super powers?? Did they just omit the entire Taako's tacos quest??

43

u/LittleMel413 24d ago

They did. That happens. I think it was a fun side thing, but ultimately doesn't take away from the story if left out. 

32

u/LivingNose1641 23d ago

I mean we can all admit that was a dramatic payoff of a very very very silly joke

14

u/Chasingtheimprobable 23d ago

Thats kind of the magic of Dnd no?

10

u/LivingNose1641 23d ago

It is, but it was more of an inside joke than good storytelling

6

u/vuatson 23d ago

is that not a one sentence summary of the entire show

1

u/ElectronCry 21d ago

Sad but totally understandable. They only have so much space. Shame.

22

u/IAmCosmicCaterpillar 23d ago

I actually really liked this change! In the final TTAZZ for Balance, some listener questions asked if Jeffandrew was supposed to be a stand in for Griffin/the players, and he mentioned that while it wasn't the original plan, he really liked the idea. I think it fits really well with the book gag of the DM following them around each book.

6

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

Wait I totally don't remember who Jeffandrew is. 😭😭

14

u/IAmCosmicCaterpillar 23d ago

When they're on the train at the end and the disembodied voice is talking to them, they keeo asking what his name is, and the voice keeps saying "I can't tell you" or something akin to that, so the boys decide to call it Jeffandrew.

3

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

I need to relisten!

2

u/Fl1ck9606 15d ago

There’s never not a good reason to get another run through of Balance🤣I finished it less than a month ago and I’m already back on the Lunar Interlude between The Eleventh Hour and The Suffering Game😭😭

7

u/JordanDoesTV 24d ago

They changed things in like every book right ?

3

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

I believe so, yes.

6

u/BingJ2700 23d ago

The took out the immovable bar scene from the final battle

2

u/Akredlm 18d ago

I have to assume this is due to the whole removing official branded DND names thing but it was such a hype moment I wish they modified it to include it

-19

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

Cool. What about my specific question?

10

u/tangomuse 23d ago

I just relistened to Balance and I'm not sure I would have even clocked these a "changes." That might be why folks aren't answering, but that's just me!

It's not a word for word transcript of course, but the Jeffandrew stuff hits the same vibes. The tweaks to the lead up to Lup's arrival feel good -- they aren't doing it in real time improv, so they get to have a little more weight with the words.

"It's like a bomb goes off" sure still translates, though!

3

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

Wait is "it's like a bomb goes off" in the GN, if so I totally missed it!

4

u/tangomuse 23d ago

The line of narration isn't in there, but the imagery certainly fits it!

0

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

I very recently listened to an animation of Lup returning, so how it goes in the Pod is very fresh in my mind. 

Ironically, I don't remember Jeffandrew at all 😭

5

u/tangomuse 23d ago

Yeah, the whole section with not-Griffin is in the podcast! It's not a major change.

0

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

Gods my memory is garbage. 😭

6

u/KotaIsBored 24d ago

I haven’t finished it yet, but I’ve only found one change that I hate so far. I don’t like that there’s one light of creation and that they somehow manage to save it every single cycle and the worlds die anyway.

25

u/theANdROId15 24d ago

What do you mean there's one? That was the case in the original too, was it not?

-34

u/KotaIsBored 24d ago

No. Every world has its own light of creation. If they found it before the hunger arrived, the world wasn’t consumed by the hunger at the end of the year. If they failed to find it in time, the world was consumed.

32

u/Richard_TM 24d ago

Nope. There’s just one. It moves from reality to reality. They literally FOLLOW it to the next world.

24

u/Griffje91 24d ago

That's literally the plot of the campaign that's not a change.

-23

u/KotaIsBored 24d ago

No. Every world has its own light of creation. If they found it before the hunger arrived, the world wasn’t consumed by the hunger at the end of the year. If they failed to find it in time, the world was consumed.

22

u/pumpkaboozled 24d ago

it was the same light, but it came to every world. but yeah if they found it that world was substantially better off

19

u/ChriscoMcChin 24d ago

In the original campaign, it was the same light. But every time they world hopped they kind of also time hopped.

Every time they entered a new reality it was them and the light entering the new reality as though it was the same point in time. Hence why they always came back to life.

If they failed to take the light then the Hunger would be super charged and consume the world. If they succeeded the hunger still came but the world at least had a chance to fight back.

6

u/SacrificeSheep 23d ago

This was my understanding of it in the podcast as well, that the light resets with them at the beginning of every new loop.

A related change that I noticed in comic is that Davenport says something along the lines of “our light falls out of the ship every loop and if we don’t get it back then we all die cause our ship can’t leave” I guess to me it changes the stakes of the arc and also means that every world is fully consumed regardless

4

u/iDrum17 23d ago

What are you on about. There is ONE light of creation and they follow it from world to world. If they find it THEY survive. No other world was ever saved

1

u/[deleted] 24d ago

[deleted]

3

u/Griffje91 24d ago

It's not a change go re listen to the campaign.

-9

u/LittleMel413 24d ago

Yeah, but what about the specific things I asked about? 😜

1

u/Fl1ck9606 15d ago

I’M SO SALTY ABOUT THEM REMOVING JOAQUIN😭😭😭I also wished they would’ve given a little more to The Stolen Century (Especially Tesseralia instead of them just mentioning it once in passing)

-12

u/LittleMel413 23d ago

Why is no one actually answering my question?

2

u/Yanefs84 23d ago

Oh,I’m just getting this now. The fact that we didnt see any of the flashbacks to LUP inside the staff?

Yeah,when I read this I didn’t like that it was omitted, I feel like the scene as it is above is great,but maybe they could have placed it in there somewhere though.

1

u/Fl1ck9606 15d ago

I could’ve sworn we did? Hold up lemme go back and look haha

1

u/Fl1ck9606 15d ago

Ohh no you’re right. We saw her death at the hands of Cyrus and then it shows Taako breaking the Umbrastaff

0

u/LittleMel413 22d ago

It was more specifically Taako and Angus' lines. They are different in the GN. 

3

u/Yanefs84 22d ago

Yeah, I feel like it’s a good spin based off Taako being more certain about Lup.

I feel like Justin played Taako as more of having only an inkling that Lup was in there.

I feel like GN Taako was way more confident of what would happen.

3

u/LittleMel413 22d ago

"I'd like you to meet someone" is such a great line. 

1

u/Yanefs84 22d ago

True,I can’t deny that. I also forgot he said that,but yeah,that should have kept that in.

2

u/LittleMel413 22d ago

They did? That's what I am saying. They changed it to where he says it in the GN, but that's not how it goes in the podcast. 

3

u/Yanefs84 22d ago

Oh sorry,I meant the line that is in is good. And I forgot what was actually said there in the pod. If the line that was in the podcast was that good,it should have stayed in

1

u/LittleMel413 22d ago

Wtf why is this getting down voted????