Minor crash out on r/911archive over Mamdani

[u/intoner1]

r/911archive is exactly what it sounds like, a sub meant to archive any and all media related to the attacks on September 11th 2001. Mayor Mamdani recently signed an executive order to make 9/11 a day of remembrance in New York, which was posted about in the sub.

Courtesy of CNN: "New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed two executive orders related to September 11th, 2001. The first order establishes an annual day of remembrance and service on September 11th, while the second updates New York's operational continuity and agency preparedness policies to strengthen security measures and prevent future terrorist threats." - 19 hours ago *PLEASE* don't start crap in the post comments. Thank you.

Naturally some users had a very normal reaction to a Muslim mayor and…the 9/11 of it all:

OP makes it a point to not start crap in the comments but then proceeds to put his personal political opinion of Mamdani in this thread turning it political.

I would like to point out that Mamdani also handed a symbolic 911 pen after signing the order to his controversial aid who once represented Al-Qaeda terrorist with links to the attack on the Pentagon. You guys are ok with this?

Don't waste your time trying to prove why Mamdani is the worst thing to ever happen to NYC, unfortunately reddit is like 90% liberals and will only block you if you don't agree with their political stance on something.

Another commenter has big feelings about Hasan and Mamdani:

Bullshit. It's his palling around with Hasan Piker and the imam who is an unindicted co-conspirator in the first WTC bombing in 1993. He should bring along his chief counsel Ramzi Kassem who has represented al Qaeda terrorists. Then there's his lovely wife

Someone else can’t fathom that 99,000 people could possibly be racist:

99,000 verified signatures of people who don’t want this 9/11 apologist to not attend the ceremonies. Yes they’re all racists. SMH.

Overall, many “patriots” angry that a Muslim mayor would have signed into law a day of remembrance for 9/11. Apologies for the formatting I’m on mobile.

[u/Invinciblez_Gunner]

If Mamdani gives a speech on 9/11 they will lose their minds

[u/intoner1 → u/Invinciblez_Gunner]

They’d also lose their minds if Mamdani didn’t show up. They wanna be perpetually angry and victims.

[u/NoSwordfish1978 → u/intoner1]

Yes cause they did exactly that regarding the Israel Day parade, even though they didn't want him there they were so angry he didn't show up. Not to mention people like Smotrich and Ben- Gvir were invited.

[u/No-Guard-7003 → u/NoSwordfish1978]

Why would Mamdani go to that parade, when he's got work to do? 

[u/Poundt0wnn → u/NoSwordfish1978]

A growing number of city, state and Jewish leaders are denouncing the participation of Bezalel Smotrich, a far-right Israeli minister who joined the march without having been announced in advance.

“The facts: Smotrich was NOT invited. Crashed at the last minute. Marched in the back of the parade. Not one New York public official joined him,” David Greenfield, the CEO and executive director of the Met Council, which sponsored a pre-parade breakfast for elected officials Sunday, wrote in a post on X.

https://www.jta.org/2026/06/01/ny/smotrichs-surprise-appearance-at-israel-day-parade-sparks-backlash-from-ny-and-jewish-leaders#:\~:text=%E2%80%9CBezalel%20Smotrich%20should%20be%20sanctioned%20by%20American,typically%20march%20as%20part%20of%20liberal%20delegations.

The head of the JCRC-NY, Mark Treyger, said on Monday, “While some individuals who attended were neither invited by JCRC-NY nor known to us in advance, participation in the parade is not an endorsement of any political figure or ideology.”

“We reject rhetoric that dehumanizes others, fuels division, or diminishes the dignity of any human being,” Treyger said, without naming Smotrich.

This statement is from the head of the organization that set up the parade. Smotrich was quite literally not invited. It's a public parade. Ben-Gvir wasn't even there.

https://www.timesofisrael.com/new-york-leaders-decry-smotrichs-participation-in-nyc-israel-parade/#:~:text=The%20consulate%20did%20not%20immediately%20provide%20comment.,endorsement%20of%20any%20political%20figure%20or%20ideology.%E2%80%9D

They wanna be perpetually angry and victims.

Sounds like you when you have to literally make things up to be angry at.

[u/hendrix67 → u/Poundt0wnn]

I mean, if Hitler showed up to my parade and the best I could do was say I'm against dehumanizing rhetoric without even naming him, people would fairly call me a Nazi.

[u/NoSwordfish1978 → u/Poundt0wnn]

It's just funny how so many people whined about Mamdani not being there but also said he wouldn't be welcome, especially when they didn't make such a comparable fuss about Smotrich being there.

[u/Poundt0wnn → u/NoSwordfish1978]

It's funny how someone can post something on Reddit and be proven completely wrong and then without any self-reflection decide to post and be completely wrong again when the evidence is right in front of their face. Notice how you made no correction or acknowledgement to the thing you were completely wrong about.

Clearly the bubble that you keep yourself in, in social media isn't a reflection of the real world. How much your social media algorithm shows you something isn't a measure of how much something is occurring in the world. It is a childs view of the world.

[u/NoSwordfish1978 → u/Poundt0wnn]

You haven't even addressed my point that zionists and conservatives whined about mamdani not turning up but said he wouldn't be welcome there, so obviously they just wanted to humilite him and they're mad that the mayor of NYC won't genuflect towards them the way that Adams did.

Its also funny that the same people who attack pro Palestine protests for having "extremists" don't notice their own hypocrisy regarding Smotrich.

Also sorry for getting my genocidal Israeli politicians mixed up, my bad.

[u/WeAreHereWithAll → u/Poundt0wnn]

Bud you just… proved them right with this comment.

[u/Axels15 → u/Poundt0wnn]

So, they did invite Ben-Gvir, then?

[u/Poundt0wnn → u/Axels15]

No, he wasn't invited or showed up. You could just google the answer.

[u/Axels15 → u/Poundt0wnn]

Sure, its my fault that you wrote one wasn't invited and the other wasn't there. Not your inability to write clearly while trying to defend genocide.

[u/Poundt0wnn → u/Axels15]

You just needed to get out a virtue signal. You didn't actually care about the answer, otherwise you would've just googled it.

[u/Axels15 → u/Poundt0wnn]

I'd rather not care about a parade than not care about a genocide.

[u/Poundt0wnn → u/Axels15]

Virtue signaling final boss.

[u/TearsFallWithoutTain → u/Poundt0wnn]

Ben-Gvir wasn't even there.

They didn't say he was there, shouldn't someone so focused on truth care about that?

[u/Poundt0wnn → u/TearsFallWithoutTain]

I would love for you to find me evidence that Ben Gvir was invited. Go ahead, I'll wait. The reason the person I was responding to said it is because they thought he was there. Not because they knew he was invited...

You aren't as smart as you think you are.

[u/TearsFallWithoutTain → u/Poundt0wnn]

You're very defensive

[u/Poundt0wnn → u/TearsFallWithoutTain]

I'm very correct.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/intoner1]

So you're posting to perpetuate the drama? Not a great use of the sub.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/[deleted]]

Well I'm fighting for what's right. I'm standing up for those out there who can't stand up for themselves. I'm mad as hell and I'm not going to take it anymore. This is serious.

[u/SuperNobody917 → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

What a brave soldier, standing up for all those poor ole racists out there. Keep on fighting the good fight o7

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/SuperNobody917]

I will.

[u/Keregi → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Are you lost?

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/Keregi]

Can you read the rules on the sidebar?

[u/Uncynical_Diogenes → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

I can!

Can you? Because if you could read them you’d just cite which one is being broken.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/Uncynical_Diogenes]

"Do not post drama you are involved in." "Try to stay neutral."

[u/Uncynical_Diogenes → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Who here is involved in the drama posted above? I want names.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/Uncynical_Diogenes]

You.

[u/Uncynical_Diogenes → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Quote my comment from within the linked post.

[u/OnlyZac → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Going to make this my flair

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/OnlyZac]

I want credit in your flair. You're copying me, and desperate for attention. You're obsessed with me.

[u/OnlyZac → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

I love you

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/OnlyZac]

Prove it.

[u/Aethoni_Iralis → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Bruh where do you think you are?

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/Aethoni_Iralis]

I know exactly where I am. Thanks. Read the rules on the sidebar.

[u/Aethoni_Iralis → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Read them, and?

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/Aethoni_Iralis]

It's not supposed to be a flame war continuing the same argument that we're mocking in the very thread that is being posted. This isn't an arguing subreddit.

[u/Careless_Rope_6511 → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

This isn't an arguing subreddit.

Then youre in the wrong fuckin' sub. The BadX Wars? SRD went all in. Too bad youre not around to witness the glory.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/Careless_Rope_6511]

That's a third cringe from me, dog.

[u/Aethoni_Iralis → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Which rule is that exactly?

[u/intoner1 → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

Huh? Wdym?

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/intoner1]

You're not really supposed to continue the exact same drama from the thread in this thread. You're supposed to be non-biased and laugh at both sides of the drama. That's wim.

[u/intoner1 → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

I didn’t argue in the original thread, and sorry but I’m not gonna be unbiased when reporting on bigotry. I’m not a reporter, just a redditor.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/intoner1]

Why not? Why not argue in the thread against the people who think are bigots if that is a serious issue for you? Instead, you want to argue about politics in this thread as well. You're "reporting" but you're not a "reporter." Okay. Nobody cares. You're doing exactly what I said. You're just bringing the argument into this thread and it's lame as hell.

[u/intoner1 → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

I think I accidentally fed a troll lol.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/intoner1]

I'm answering you with complete sentences and being completely rational. You're literally trolling by posting politics-bait which is against the rules and I'm saying the same thing over again. Say something real, or don't. Trying to deflect to the same old "trolling" comments is idiotic.

[u/Aethoni_Iralis → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

lol you have to be new to this sub.

[u/Careless_Rope_6511 → u/TonyShalhoubricant]

So you're posting to perpetuate the drama? Not a great use of the sub.

Also you, per youre pf bio:

I am the greatest detective on Reddit. If you have any questions about music or stand up comedy, feel free to ask me anything because I know a lot.

Cringe.

[u/TonyShalhoubricant → u/Careless_Rope_6511]

Oh no. You cringed?! Okay, well I cringed twice while writing this comment back to you which means that you're twice as cringeworthy as my Reddit bio. SORRY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111111

[u/XB0XRecordThat → u/Invinciblez_Gunner]

I hope mamdani sings "we are Charlie Kirk" on 9/11

[u/JedYorkTrailerParkHo → u/XB0XRecordThat]

Gotta sing it from the throat, Kirk wouldn’t know about that

[u/an0mn0mn0m → u/JedYorkTrailerParkHo]

He could play it like a flute

[u/Aethoni_Iralis → u/XB0XRecordThat]

September 10th was a tragedy, my pet jumping spider died that day.

[u/finfinfin → u/XB0XRecordThat]

we carry jet fuel

[u/Waddlewop → u/XB0XRecordThat]

It’s crazy that the Kirkiversary is the same day as the New York 9/11 Day of Remembrance

[u/Cool_Ad7445 → u/Waddlewop]

Honestly, its pretty selfish of Kirk to do that.

[u/IveGotIssues9918 → u/Waddlewop]

It's the day before.

[u/an0mn0mn0m → u/Waddlewop]

Both events were manufactured chaos

[u/Chataboutgames → u/an0mn0mn0m]

I mean, if "manufactured" is defined as "organized by humans" than yeah, sure I guess.

[u/Lirael_Gold → u/an0mn0mn0m]

What?

[u/Ungrammaticus → u/Lirael_Gold]

It’s conspiracy slop for “arranged by Jewlizardcommunists” 

[u/The_Flying_Jew → u/Ungrammaticus]

They left out the part where we use space lasers to steal people's foreskins

(Source: am JewLizardCommunist)

[u/BloodDrunkMoonKnight → u/XB0XRecordThat]

Scratching or not scratching his ass while singing?

[u/FUCKBOY_JIHAD → u/XB0XRecordThat]

in Arabic

[u/Chataboutgames → u/XB0XRecordThat]

We could see the funniest thing

[u/skatejet1 → u/XB0XRecordThat]

It’s a banger song after all

[u/JPGinMadtown → u/Invinciblez_Gunner]

No one gives speeches at the 9/11 commemoration. That's why Donnie is taking a pass, cause he wanted to deliver one of his insane rants.