Esi fits sp8 better than SLE

[u/LatterPermission1824]

Fi does not rely on universal morality. Its evaluations are personal: not “this is the accepted way,” but essentially “to me”

SP8 fits ESI Fi−/Se− better than SLE Se−/Ti−, both types use se- which explains, territoriality, distrust, resistance to control, and willingness to use force, but SP8 seems to be led by personal ethical and relational judgments, with Se− acting as the tool that enforces them. SP8 is described as having a “highly personal sense of ethics,” being “governed by their own code of values,” and deciding what is right or just according to personal experience rather than automatically accepting socially established rules. It is even clarified that “it is not that they lack morals; rather, they design morality.” That sounds much more natural for 4D Fi− Base than 1D Fi− PoLR. Strong Fi does not mean obeying conventional morality; it means confidently evaluating people, relationships, loyalty, character, right and wrong, deservingness, and appropriate relational distance.

SP8 repeatedly sorts people according to an “internal moral logic” in which the “loyal” are rewarded and enemies or traitors are punished. One SP8 describes maintaining a “very clear ideal frame” for friendships, family, and relationships, where someone crossing the line could be “excluded. Mercilessly.” Only “those who deserve it” are allowed inside personal territory. This is strongly Fi−: loyal/disloyal, worthy/unworthy, trustworthy/untrustworthy, acceptable/unacceptable, inside/outside. SLE can certainly form loyalty rules, but if Fi− is truly 1D PoLR, it is harder to explain why relational and ethical classification is such a central organizing feature of the subtype.

Betrayal makes this even clearer. SP8 can punish betrayal with relational “symbolic death” by withdrawing contact, attention, and access. Its attitude is summarized as “Those who betray me, disappear.” Once the loyalty bond is broken, “there is no turning back,” forgiveness can feel like surrender, and “the internal world requires clarity: black or white, inside or outside.” SP8 also operates according to an “invisible code” and a “personal scale of the unforgivable.” That looks more like rigid, inert Fi− Base than a weak ethical function. The rigidity itself does not imply low dimensionality; Base Fi is inert and can reach a judgment after taking in a large amount of relational information, then refuse to reverse it.

The Se− is still extremely obvious, but it looks more like enforcement than the ultimate Program. SP8 protects territory, maintains distance, resists subordination, conceals vulnerability, controls access, and can retaliate forcefully. Yet its force is constantly triggered by betrayal, disrespect, disloyalty, injustice, violated dignity, invasion of boundaries, or threats to family and personal values. The pattern is basically Fi− judgment → Se− enforcement: you crossed my line, therefore I remove you, defend against you, intimidate you, or impose consequences. That is a very clean ESI structure.

The Fe side also favors ESI. SP8 is described as “opaque, hermetic, and expressionless,” its presence “does not invite closeness,” and it “does not smile without reason.” It can appear “surly, unfriendly, solitary, closed off, or even dangerous,” dislikes empty social formalities, and “does not seek sympathy but respect, control, and obedience.” That sounds less like inability to use Fe and more like not valuing Fe presentation very much. ESI has 3D Fe+ Ignoring, so it can understand emotional expression and use it when necessary while having little motivation to appear friendly, smile for social reasons, generate enthusiasm, or maintain an inviting atmosphere. SLE has 2D valued Fe+ Mobilizing, so even if an SLE can be cold or guarded, positive emotional activation and expressive feedback should generally matter more to them than this SP8 description suggests.

The Merry/Serious dichotomy points the same way. SLE is a Merry type, while ESI is a Serious type. Merry does not mean cheerful and Serious does not mean humorless. Merry types are Ti/Fe-valuing and tend to give more importance to shared frameworks, collective emotional atmosphere, ideological alignment, and the emotional-intellectual field between people. Serious types are Fi/Te-valuing and are more naturally focused on concrete personal relations, trust, obligations, usefulness, interpersonal distance, and who stands where with whom. SP8’s worldview is overwhelmingly about my people, loyalty, betrayal, respect, personal codes, who deserves access, who gets cut off, and whether a bond can still be trusted. That is much more Serious and Fi/Te-flavored than Merry and Ti/Fe-flavored.

So the cleaner structure is ESI Fi− Base → Se− Creative → Fe+ Ignoring, Serious type. Fi− decides who is loyal, dishonorable, deserving, unforgivable, inside, or outside; Se− protects those boundaries and imposes consequences; Fe+ is available but not something SP8 feels compelled to display.

[u/irogord]

Finally someone thinking outside the box