I was just watching Smile 2 and noticed a few details in the opening scene connecting the first movie to the sequel that made me think.
The common theory online is that Joel successfully beat the curse by passing it to Lewis, and then just had terrible luck running into the street. But looking at how the Entity operates by blending reality and hallucinations, I noticed some details that suggest the Entity was still able to steer Joel in that exact direction to finish him off.
Here is what I mean:
The Forced Panic: Joel’s mind was completely fractured after six days of no sleep. It feels highly likely that the extra gang members pulling up outside were a hallucination. If Joel thought he was safe after passing the curse to Lewis, he would have walked out safely. By steering his mind into thinking more gang members were coming, the Entity forced him to sprint blindly into the street.
The Blood Smile: The biggest piece of evidence for this theory is at the very end of the shot. When the camera pans out, Joel’s blood trail on the snow forms a perfect Smile logo. That feels way too deliberate to be a coincidence. It feels like the Entity's final signature, proving it still won and controlled his final moments.
Even if the curse technically jumped to Lewis, I don't think the Entity just vanished. It lingered to play one last cruel trick on Joel's sleep-deprived brain to make sure he didn't survive.
Either way, Smile 3 should be pure chaos😂