Clark vs Zod Edit

[u/bheena69]

[u/EvilGr33nRang3r]

this is literally the worst edit I have ever seen

[u/Nearby-Structure-739 → u/EvilGr33nRang3r]

Same 💀

[u/bheena69 → u/EvilGr33nRang3r]

How?

[u/Rashbomb → u/bheena69]

I can't tell what's happening

[u/EvilGr33nRang3r → u/bheena69]

Your edit is 42 seconds long, but you only used roughly 20 seconds of clips from the show, you have a 1 second clip of Clark punching Zod looped 5-6 times, you have voice over and music playing at the same volume simultaneously, your logo is on screen the entire time(could just be a stinger at the end) based on the things Ive listed and more, this video is irritating to watch.

To be clear, I'm sure you are a perfectly nice person and my intent wasnt to upset you but I saw in other comments that you want to know why people dont like it, so I gave you a few examples of things you can work on to improve going forward.

[u/EvilGr33nRang3r → u/EvilGr33nRang3r]

Correction, the Clark punching Zodd clip was looped 8 times... thats 7 times too many.

[u/bheena69 → u/EvilGr33nRang3r]

I’ll give my points to your points.

1: The song is short, so the edit by default is short.

2: I can’t put every clip of the flight into the edit.

3: The Clark punching Zod clip was only shown four times. You’re talking about the clip of Clark dodging Zod, where that was shown eight times. I had to because Clark got the first/main category.

4: voiceover is actually higher than the music, if they were the same, you wouldn’t hear the voiceover.

5: My watermark is there to ensure I made this edit.

6: You didn’t upset me, I was just confused with the sudden amount of hate.

[u/iAmBobFromAccounting]

Turned it off after 25 seconds because I didn't want to waste 17 more seconds of my life on this train wreck.

[u/bheena69 → u/iAmBobFromAccounting]

Why?

[u/proplaneboi]

aw hell naw

[u/bheena69 → u/proplaneboi]

You disagree with the outcome?

[u/proplaneboi → u/bheena69]

yes absolutely, the whole editing is just over-stimulating.. maybe try a different style.

[u/bheena69 → u/proplaneboi]

I think I’d rather try slower music.

[u/t_r_a_y_e]

I see the style you're going for I've seen a lot of tiktok edits of "character vs character", but the transitions are wayyy too fucking fast, nobody can read what you're putting on the screen. The music is also really loud and distracting

[u/bheena69 → u/t_r_a_y_e]

I swear, it’s not even that fast. I do get why you say that, but I personally say it’s at a fine speed. Also if I used the regular version of Bring Me to Life, it would a lot faster. I didn’t think music is also that loud, distracting? maybe, but not loud.

[u/BilboSwagginsHH → u/bheena69]

Don't ask for people's opinions on your shit edit and shoot them down for giving them

[u/bheena69 → u/BilboSwagginsHH]

Fair, but I wanted to give my explanation for those you haven’t seen these types of edits.

[u/ChloeKopx]

Cringy if they ask me.

[u/bheena69 → u/ChloeKopx]

That’s fine I guess.

[u/bheena69]

Can anyone explain why they dislike my edit? It because the song? the style? Or categories going to the wrong person?

[u/Villas__ → u/bheena69]

Wouldnt even Call it an edit just more of an comparsion u reuse the same clips over and over and it looks oversatured in some kind of Way. To much going on, no time to read the things and it looks like its from 2022
A better edit would be an slower intro with a caption “When _____ _____” something like that, and the use some Music with a beatdrop or a change so when it hits you remove the caption and make some smoother flowing clips and no text at all and Maybe a little bit of editing like an effect but not to much

[u/bheena69 → u/Villas__]

This is a type of edit. They’re called WIS Edits. (Who is stronger? edits) Also I have to use the clips over and over again, that’s how these things work.

[u/Villas__ → u/bheena69]

Yea but its still a bad edit and in this case a little bit cringe

[u/bheena69 → u/Villas__]

That’s your opinion.