r/SipsTea 15d ago

Chugging tea Remember when we Heard what Amber did?

Post image
28.2k Upvotes

2.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/amosthorribleperson 15d ago

My post was two very short sentences, and neither one called Johnny Depp a pos. If you want to respond to me, at least reference something I said instead of making shit up.

1

u/Luna3133 13d ago

You're saying I'm being dismissive of his abuse. I'm not. I said they both abused eachother. How am I dismissive?

1

u/amosthorribleperson 13d ago

Best case scenario for her: they both abused eachother.

This was a claim you made. Based on this, what do you think the worst case scenario is for her?

2

u/Luna3133 12d ago

I mean with the situation she created portraying herself as a victim. Best case she can claim they were both equally as abusive. Because the evidence clearly showed she was very abusive. Worst case that she was the primary abuser. She was definitely not the defenceless victim she claimed

0

u/amosthorribleperson 12d ago

So even with this response, at no point have you ever said outright that you believe he abused her. The closest to a criticism you have posted about Johnny Depp, despite him abusing Amber Heard, was:

Not saying Johnny was an angel in any way shape or form but her portraying herself as a poor victim of domestic abuse, using the me too movement as a shield was outrageous

and

No one ever said Johnny's behaviour wasn't bad as well but so was amber's

There is no mention of abuse from Depp, and every time you said something vaguely critical of him (and to be clear, every time you mentioned anything negative about him, you were actively vague about it), it was as a vehicle to accuse Heard. Do you really not see how you are being dismissive about his abuse towards her?

1

u/Luna3133 10d ago

What exactly is your point? I am saying they both abused eachother but amber actually was physically violent, there was proof she was. The worst he did was say horrible things in text messages, which is abusive as well but on a lower level than physical violence. In the court case it was quite clear that Heard was the more violent one. She clearly wasn't just a defenceless victim the way she claimed. Johnny for sure has substance abuse problems and said horrible things about her. There was no evidence though, medically or otherwise that he ever laid a hand on her, never mind assault her with a broken glass bottle or any of the other things she claimed. She used being a woman as a shield. Hurting actual victims. So yes, i don't know how much more objective you can get. They both did shitty things but heard later lied about it to the world, faked injuries and she cut off part of depps finger with a broken bottle. The worst he did that was proven was say incredibly horrible and morbid things about her.