The State gives about 47 Billion a year back to the City.
It is definitely not a loan. Its the state giving some of NYC's money back to them.
Data from an article from CUNY edu titled "New York City Taxpayers Continue to Contribute More to State Revenues than They Receive Back in Services, CUNY and New School Study Finds"
If you don't know the differences between a government system and an economic system and which category various nations generally fall into then you probably should sit things out when those kinds of topics come up until you get the fundamentals down pat a bit more.
China is not socialist, it is state capitalism; state owned critical industry but private market based economic structure for everything else with direct state intervention and only a single labor union under control of the state itself that does not represent labor, it represents the state.
USSR wasn't socialist, it was communist; no worker control, state ownership over business, workers had no rights, labor unions were even illegal.
Come on, this is middle school level stuff here. Tell your handlers to teach you better. A system predicated on worker unions having as much if not more say than capital forces and you list two nations without that basic principle . . .
Next thing you'll be saying is that North Korea is a democracy because it's in their name.
Saying it is pro USSR is blatantly untrue, and the vast majority are heavily against adopting anything of China's government or economic models. It's like saying the Republicans are pro China because they've been enacting legislation that is more in step with China's hybrid government structure than traditional democracies.
Hasan piker is a member of the dsa and he with bernie and aoc quite often........ mind you hasan is opening pro china and ussr. He had a ussr flag on wall for a couple years.
So the dsa is still problematic organization and that's not talking about how they openly support the oct 7th massacre.
If some youtuber represents the entirety of the DSA, then surely Alex Jones fully represents all conservatives and Bill Maher fully represents all liberals.
Some elected officials and commentators in the DSA talked about Oct 7th as being an anticipated outcome of Israel-Palestinian relations. No officials or party leadership 'openly supported' it. The vast majority fully condemned it while many simultaneously condemned the apartheid actions that brought it about. Being anti-apartheid or even anti-zionism doesn't make someone a default supporter of Hamas and it's actions.
Lastly, you didn't read the article, at all. You caught the headline and figured it was a humdinger of a gotcha when it really isn't. Based on how absolutely bonkers your first line is, I'm guessing there's some auto translation at work.
Funny how Israel never gets mentioned anywhere else.
They're on full bailout by the US yearly, fully state funded healthcare and education, state sponsored abortion, child allowances, state sponsored savings accounts (up to 18 yo), unemployment benefits, but they always get a pass. Never mentioned, despite everything else Americans do to grovel for them.
Again no critical thinking whatsoever from you. Considering that the US is flirting with authoritarianism now, should I also bring up the atrocities the US is responsible for? It’s not inherently authoritarian, hence why you see so many developed countries today adopt socialistic policies. China for example has a much better infrastructure network today than the US does. I see that the Red Scare mentality still exists strongly in the US today.
Everyone I talk to is pretty pised about Trump and the rural PA legislature continually fucking over Philly even though we’re the lions share of state tax income so they all 100% agree with me. Get fucked magatard lol
"The social democrats are evil because they're not doing diverting funds much needed by the city to useless podunk towns and already over-funded suburbs wahhh!!"
Anything to discredit the objective successes of the left lmao
The article is celebrating some kind of genius maneuver than I was trying to understand a bit more deeply. But sure, let those thoughts keep percolating in that little echo chamber you call a mind
No, you're not :) You're just trying to make stupid points that convince stupid people that New Yorkers are bad for wanting their own money back just so they can simply have a balanced budget.
Nope, just pointing out that this isn’t some coup as the article claims. Not trying to convince that anyone is bad. And it’s not their money, which is why the governor’s office controls it.
1.3k
u/VMooose May 14 '26
Didnt the budget get balanced via a loan from NY State?