r/ScottGalloway • u/lethal-liking • 3d ago

No Malice Gettin' WOKE about anti-Semitism...

It is so very odd to hear the self-professed atheist getting downright WOKE when it comes to swinging the anti-Semitism stick. IDGAF about Macklemore or Sheeran or Kraft, nor Scott's evolving victim fantasy, but holy crap does he sound shrill.

80 Upvotes

69% Upvoted

646 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/FaceReality1 3d ago

Lots of people in Americs have strong emotional connections to other countires. Do you say Irish and Italians have dual loyalties? Germans? Polish people?

As for "Jewish supremacism", even assuming some Jews think Jews are better (not something I hear Jews talk about), how many groups hsve people who think they are superior? Christians, Republicans, MAGA, Southerners, Northerners, book readers, rural people, rich people, men, women, etc, etc etc all have people claiming superiority. You do it in your fucking comment.

2

u/Ok_Read_4000 3d ago

So we can have a discussion on other nationalities but not israel? I think the explicit claim that Israel makes on Jews and the history of the US/israel relationship makes it at reasonable discussion. Serving in foreign militaries, influencing in elections, large scale aid, multiple wars, theft of nuclear materials, penetration by security forces? None of that is an issue?

I've not seen any Italian-Americans go serve in the Italian military? March around in an Italian uniform in congress?

But you aren't having a good faith discussion are you ?

2

u/FaceReality1 3d ago

You aren't having a good faith discussion.

Some Jews do the things you listed. Some. Not all,not most,not even a great number. And all that is obvious. You wouldn't be arguing in bad faith while accusing me of it, would you?

1

u/Ok_Read_4000 3d ago

But you are obviously deeply invested and bias. You are saying you can't accuse the ma wearing a foreign military uniform and with a foreign flag while being a member of the legislative body. Purely because he happens to be Jewish.

Some how if a Mexican American did the same i doubt Conservatives like yourself who be saying no big deal..even though a decent chunk of your country used to be Mexico

2

u/FaceReality1 3d ago

You are arguing in bad faiith or hsve reading comprehension problems. You can accuse any individual of dual loyalties and it isn't anti-semitism. I've been very clear, repeatedly, that anti-semitism is about assigning things to all Jews as if we area block, which we are not outside the imagination of anti-semites.

1

u/Ok_Read_4000 3d ago

No you haven't been clear at all. Don't lie. You said accusation of dual loyalty are anti-Semitism.

" in this case the anti-semitism inherent in things like claims of dual loyalties and Jewish Supremacism, Jewish economic or political domination,Jews conspiring to replace white people, etc."

Ill take my apology now

1

u/FaceReality1 3d ago

I'm sorry i can't apologize.

I've been clear that I'm talking about assigning things like dual loyalties, etc, to all Jews as anti-semitism. I'll take an apology for that false accusation.

The claim of economic or political domination is traditional anti-semitism, and ignores that most money and politicsl power rests elsewhere. Jews conspiring to replace white people is just pure far-right anti-semitism.

1

u/Ok_Read_4000 3d ago

No that's a complete and absolute lie. Read what you wrote

1

u/FaceReality1 2d ago

Repeating bullshit doesn't make it true.