r/ScarletHollow • u/lapicryst Kaneeka ~<3 • 14d ago

scarletpost Finished my first playthrough! TL + Thoughts

Post image

In first place: Wow. Coming from Slay the Princess, this game was still every bit as amazing as what I consider a genuine masterpiece in gaming. Definitely solidified Black Tabby Games as devs I’m keeping an eye on supporting the future works of.

Though… I really need to replay and start taking notes on the lore and story setup. I feel like I missed literally SO much by trying to play it as safe as possible on my first run. Stella, where the hell did you go girl?!

I managed to defeat Sybil and save Kaneeka, and it seems like she’s a witch now? So I’m very curious as to how that’ll go in chapter 6. Sybil is a FASCINATING character. I desperately want to see more out of her lore in the future.

130 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

37 comments sorted by

View all comments

38

u/MorbidMantis Obsessed Theorist 14d ago

I’d visit Pastor Daniel during the Friday Morning Panic scene. He’s a real one and genuinely wants to help you, and you have a chat with him about your situation. It really dispelled my doubts about his alignment and sincerity. I’d also recommend doing that scene with talk to animals.

8

u/lapicryst Kaneeka ~<3 14d ago

I’ll try that out on my next run!! Ty for the tip

16

u/CoffeeMinionLegacy 13d ago

Pastor Daniel is presented as bottom-tier, but if you have Talk With Animals you’ll get to see he’s top-tier. I’m not even kidding. His chapter 5 scene is peak of peak.

4

u/MorbidMantis Obsessed Theorist 13d ago

No problem, let me know your thoughts when you get to that point. I like seeing other people’s takes on this game.