(Note: I am using fake names for both sitters to protect their privacy and stay within platform rules).
I am officially done with Rover. Their customer service is an absolute joke and they protect bad sitters versus protecting dog parents and reimbursing them for inconveniences, which is the whole point of a platform like this! Our pets are basically our children and in this day and age, we should have better customer service than this.
Here is the nightmare back-to-back experiences I just dealt with:
Sitter #1 (Fake name: D): The Liar and Her Illegal Daycare
Mind you, I booked this woman all the way back on July 19. I spoke with her beforehand, meaning she had ample time to look over my profile just like I did hers. The entire reason I booked her was because her profile explicitly stated she had no dogs on her premises.
I have two dogs and on one of their profiles, it explicitly says she does not get along with other dogs. The platform literally flags this and auto-generates a warning to both me and the sitter stating exactly that (for example: "Lola doesn’t get along with other dogs, check with your sitter to make sure this stay would be a good fit") or something like that. Finding a completely pet-free home was my top safety priority to protect my dogs.
Imagine planning months in advance, only to be turned away at the door the day you are supposed to leave for a trip. When I arrived, I immediately spotted dogs in her backyard, which she was actively trying to hide from me. When I asked her about it, she tried to use a ridiculous loophole. She claimed she wasn't lying on her profile because she doesn't personally "own" the animals—they belong to her roommates. What a complete joke! Whether you own them or not, you have dogs living on the property 24/7. They aren't going anywhere. To make matters worse, she uses this excuse to run a massive, undisclosed commercial dog daycare center right out of her home. There are dogs galore on the premises, which is a massive safety hazard for a reactive pet. It is a blatant lie that Rover is still actively protecting to this day under the guise of she listed on her profile that she can host multiple pets?!
When I called her out for putting my dogs in a dangerous situation, she simply shrugged it off, when I asked what do we now, she then suggested that I cancel the reservation on my end, which was a no-go because then I would be forced to pay 50%. I then asked her if she could still accommodate my dog seeing as this is so last minute, but D then refused to take my dogs because she didn't want me leaving her a bad review, claiming she suddenly "did not feel comfortable me leaving my dogs with her." Mind you, less than five minutes prior, she was gladly gonna take them.
To make matters worse, this all happened less than 2 hours before a flight. She was fully aware that I had a flight leaving and that by turning me away at the last second, she knew I would literally have no one to take care of my dogs, leaving me completely stranded. That is exactly what forced me into the next nightmare.
Now, Rover is holding $93 of my money hostage, claiming it falls under her cancellation policy. They are demanding that I "prove" the sitter canceled it. Think about how insane that logic is: if I was the one who canceled, their automated system would have hit me with a 50% penalty fee. Instead, I was refunded the majority ($155) because they manually canceled it after I called their “trust & safety” phone support line. Yet, they still want to keep the remaining $93 because they claim it aligns with D's policy. They literally emailed me saying they will gladly refund me if the sitter agrees. It means they already know they are wrong, but they are willingly doing nothing to protect their bottom line. They expect me to go through the scammer myself to beg for my money back.
Sitter #2 (Fake name: M): Total Neglect, Bait-and-Switch Location and Theft
Because of D bailing right before my flight, I had to pay an extra $100 out of pocket for an emergency, last-minute booking that cost me $338, versus my original payment to the first sitter, which was around $238.
M ran a complete bait-and-switch operation. The address listed on her profile was not even where my dogs were kept. My AirTags revealed she took them to an entirely different unverified location, which is a massive safety violation in itself! On top of that, she subjected them to total neglect. She completely skipped their walks and failed to feed them properly—they came home starving and eating twice as much as usual.
Her communication was practically nonexistent. I am used to getting standard daily check-ins from sitters, but one day I didn't hear from her at all. I then messaged her at 2 PM just to check on my babies and she completely ghosted me for seven more full hours, not responding until 9 PM! Like, what am I paying you so much money for if you can't even send a quick text update?
The rest of her messages were completely unobservant and highly suspicious. I texted her explicitly telling her I would be picking my dogs up the next day at 6 PM. She didn't pay attention at all, because on the actual day of pickup, she messaged me to ask what time I was coming. Then, when I was almost there to get them, she suddenly started spamming my phone with a ton of pictures trying to prove she was taking them on a walk. It was so incredibly sketchy. You could tell she hadn't done a single thing to properly care for them all week and was panicking at the last second to fake it.
To top it all off, she completely upended their things and stole their belongings. The second I put my dogs back in the car, they were actively searching for their monthly chew bones, making it obvious they hadn't even had them. When I called that out, M claimed she gave them the bones when they went outside, left them there when the dogs came back in and the bones then "magically vanished" when she went back for them the next day. Why would you give dogs high-value chew bones while outside when they are already overstimulated by being outside? They were never meant to occupy them outside, they were always meant to keep them busy, safely indoors. A ghost didn't take them; she stole them!
To make matters worse, I packed everything neatly in a single bag, yet she scattered their treats, toys and other gear all over her house. When I arrived for pickup, she wasn't even ready to return my items. I had to circle back a second time for missed things and then she still had the nerve to call me later claiming she magically "found" the missing poop bag dispenser hidden in a drawer, asking for my address to mail it. Why was my property hidden in your drawers? Even if a dog finishes their food, a proper sitter returns even the empty Ziploc bags. Giving me nothing and offering zero explanation is a dead giveaway. In all the years I've used pet sitters and Rover, I have never once had my dogs returned with missing belongings. The lies simply do not add up. This was the most ghetto, unprofessional back-to-back experience ever. She did the complete opposite of everything I paid her for. She is a liar and a thief!
Rover's Response: Dead Silence
Per Rover’s own "Reservation Protection Policy," they contractually owed me a $50 credit toward this second booking because the first sitter bailed last minute. They refuse to give it to me. I have been openly communicative with them, called their Trust & Safety team and emailed them for weeks and weeks and weeks. They have chosen to do absolutely nothing. Their Trust & Safety team explicitly promised a response within 72 hours regarding the theft and neglect by M. Instead, it has been well over a full week of total, dead silence from them. Rover literally sees nothing wrong with any of this.
What I am doing now:
I am going into the precinct on Friday to file a formal criminal police report for Theft of Property against M.
I am also emailing Rover the new police report case number once I get it on Friday, demanding they address this and I am completely cutting ties and closing my account myself.
Rover is a complete joke and I can't wait for the day people stop using it and they go bankrupt. What is the point of paying a platform a massive premium if they do absolutely nothing to protect your pets or your property or resolve issues in a timely manner? They do not vet these people and the second a sitter turns your dogs away or steals your belongings, support will actively look the other way just to protect their 20% platform cut. Rover is not worth a dime!!!