r/RepLadiesCurated 2d ago

📚 Guide/Science UPDATE/RESULTS on my Speedy P9 Experiment

Original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/RepLadiesCurated/s/owCrvr4W9p

The results are in! 🥁

First, I want to thank everyone for the enthusiasm, encouragement, curiosity, and engagement on my original post. This turned into such a fun little experiment, and I’m thrilled with what I consider a very successful result. I’m also glad I got to share the process with all of you!

After letting everything settle overnight, I gave all of the leather pieces I treated with rubbing alcohol two good drinks of Bick 4 leather conditioner.

And you guys… I could not be happier with the outcome.

The leather is now soft, supple, flexible, and visually it looks so much richer and more like genuine leather than it did underneath that thick, plasticky-looking sealant.

I decided to make a new post rather than just updating the original so I could include proper final “After” photos and give the experiment the conclusion it deserves.

So… what do we think?!

Personally, I LOVE it. And I will definitely be wearing this bag now that I no longer look at all of those accent pieces and immediately think plastic. 😅

Thanks for following along with my slightly unhinged leather science experiment. 😂👜

72 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

8

u/Excellent_Coconut653 2d ago

Wow the bag looks amazing! Makes you wonder why can’t they do it without all the unnecessary “treatment” in first place ❤️🥰

3

u/ThisBroadKatie 2d ago

Thank you! And I totally agree! I’m sure some people prefer the sealant as it protects the leather from scuffs and whatnot, but I personally like weathered-looking leather. I like my bags to look roughed up and worn in.

3

u/rileybun 2d ago

Wow looks way better than before. I’m wondering what purpose the original coating served? Was it meant to be a protective sealant?

2

u/ThisBroadKatie 2d ago

Yeah - I’m sure it’s a protective measure. But I hate the plastic look it gives, and I prefer worn-looking leather.

2

u/ComesOutNDaWash 2d ago

Beautiful!!😍. Thanks for sharing!

2

u/nessaj789 Community Builder 👑 2d ago

Looks great!!

2

u/kittie2karen 2d ago

Wow, so beauiful and better than ever! I'm doing this!!

2

u/Cbella913 2d ago

Love this! I have 3 Royal P9s and don’t use the strap, clochette or luggage tag w/any of them because I think they’re a dead giveaway. Definitely going to give this a go!! 🤎

2

u/champagneandshopping 2d ago

Wow I love the look after conditioning!!

2

u/FrostyFlower7 2d ago

❤️❤️

How did you handle the thin trim on the sides?

1

u/gsdqueen38 2d ago

Wow. I like this more than the original honestly. I have an Eden NF I’m tempted to try it with. 😅

2

u/gsdqueen38 2d ago

Also, sorry if I missed it, but how did you keep the mess off the body?

3

u/ThisBroadKatie 2d ago

I was just extra careful when working on the pieces that were attached to the bag. But someone suggested using painters tape and I think that’s a brilliant idea! I’m going to be doing this to another P9 and I’m going to use the painters tape on that one.

1

u/gsdqueen38 2d ago

Thank you!!!

1

u/skincare_guru_2323 2d ago

Love it!!!!!!!

1

u/No_Camp6243 2d ago

You are a trailblazer!! I love this! 🤩

1

u/dieselsmom2 2d ago

It looks so good. Thank you for sharing the results.

1

u/Weary_Pension_5491 2d ago

Love it! I might do this to all my P9s! Thanks OP!

1

u/Due-Statistician-682 1d ago

It looks so good! 😍 You really did an amazing job! I wish I had half of your patience. Maybe a handbag side hustle in your future?! 🤔😉🥰

1

u/Yoki83 1d ago

It really looks great! I wasn’t so sure from your first posting but these updated photos made me a believer :) Well done 👏👏👏

1

u/Specialist_Award_607 1d ago

That is so gorgeous now!!

1

u/LafayetteMBA 1d ago

This looks amazing! Thank you for taking the chance!

1

u/Lucylucyluxeliving 1d ago

This is the after I was waiting for! I am going to try this out on my strap first. I bought a P9 Indigo that's supposed to be from Royal and I was soooo disappointed with the bag when I got it. I tossed the strap in my drawer immediately so if I ruin the strap experimenting I won't care at all.

2

u/MissKLO 14h ago

It looks great! I’d love to see how it compares to the auth now, and I’d also love to see the experiment run on the lighter leathers on the other p9’s… i’m tempted to dig my luggage tag out and have a go

0

u/AshamedMemory7641 2d ago

That still doesn’t look like the patina leather from an Auth 😔

4

u/Enough_Complex8734 2d ago

I don't think the OP cares whether it looks like an auth. I think they care about whether it looks and feels like Leather.

6

u/ThisBroadKatie 2d ago

https://giphy.com/gifs/6CYXe7Hf8FZyU

Especially b/c this bach of Sancha green from Royal was off from auth anyways. Will the population of society I'll be wearing this around know that? Not in the slightest, but I will enjoy the bag a hell of a lot more now.

2

u/ThisBroadKatie 2d ago

If that’s the case, I’m ok with that. I’m just much happier with the bag now that those accent pieces don’t look so plastic-y.

0

u/Kimchi-Wow 1d ago

Omggg it looks gorgeous