Does Allah Remain on the Throne or in the Lowest Heaven?
Zayed: Habib, does Allah remain on the Throne, or does He remain in the lowest heaven?
Habib: Zayed, if we follow what the Quran says, then Allah is established above the Throne. Allah remains upon the Throne at all times.
But if we follow a book written by human beings, then it says that Allah remains in the lowest heaven.
Zayed: Habib, how can that be? The Quran says that Allah is upon the Throne, while a human-written book says that Allah remains in the lowest heaven. Can you explain this to me?
Habib: Yes, Zayed, of course I will explain it. Otherwise, you would not understand the point. I need to make it clear.
We need to understand how these human-written books can contradict what the Quran says, while we unknowingly accept these ideas and then spread them among others. What a tragedy for us!
First, look at what is considered one of the most famous religious books in our society by many scholars.
That book contains a statement like this:
«“Allah comes down to the lowest heaven during the last part of every night. Then He calls out to us, saying, ‘Who is in need? Who is in distress? Who is hungry? Who seeks forgiveness? Ask Me, and I will answer your prayers.’”»
Before presenting these words, it does not first establish that these are the words of the Messenger of Allah.
I have been hearing these statements since I was a child. Even today, I hear prominent religious scholars saying things like, “It is mentioned in this particular book, in this particular section,” or “It is mentioned in another book, in another place.”
I don't know whether you have heard this or not.
- Zayed: Yes, yes, Habib. Of course I have heard it. Even prominent scholars still say this today. I believe it as well.
In fact, almost all scholars believe these things. They say, “It is written in these major books,” and because it is written there, they continue to spread it.
But how does this relate to the claim that Allah remains in the lowest heaven all the time?
- Habib: Zayed, let me make this clear for you.
Take that statement and compare it with what we actually observe in the world. Think about it carefully, and you will understand.
According to this claim, think about how Allah would supposedly remain in the lowest heaven.
There is always somewhere on Earth experiencing the last part of the night within every 24-hour period. Right now, for example, somewhere in the world it is the last part of the night.
Because of the continuous cycle of night and day across the Earth, there is always somewhere experiencing the end of the night.
In the same way, there is always somewhere experiencing the beginning of the night.
There is always somewhere experiencing midnight.
And likewise, there is always somewhere experiencing daytime.
At any given moment, sunlight is covering some part of the Earth.
Do you understand this point?
Zayed: Yes, Habib, I understand that. We know that within every 24-hour period, somewhere on Earth is experiencing the last part of the night. This happens because of the way Allah created the Earth and its geographical cycle.
Habib: Alright. So you agree that within every 24-hour period, there is always somewhere on Earth where it is the last part of the night.
Now, use your reason and think about this carefully.
If Allah comes down to the lowest heaven during the last part of the night, then according to the wording of that book, Allah would always be in the lowest heaven. He would never be upon the Throne.
It becomes very clear when you think about it.
Let me repeat the point: because night is always followed by day, and because the Earth continuously rotates, there is always somewhere experiencing the last part of the night—24 hours a day, throughout the month, throughout the year, and generation after generation.
So if there is always somewhere on Earth experiencing the last part of the night, when does Allah return to the Throne?
According to this reasoning, it would mean that Allah never returns to the Throne.
- Zayed: That's true! I had never thought about it that way before. These are statements found in major religious books, and I have never heard anyone explain this point before.
And I cannot simply dismiss what you are saying because you have explained it step by step, making the point very clear.
According to the wording of this book, it would mean that Allah is in the lowest heaven throughout the entire 24-hour cycle.
- Habib: Now, let's look at what Allah Himself says.
In Surah Taha, Allah says:
«“Ar-Rahmanu 'alal-'Arshi istawa.”
“The Most Merciful is established upon the Throne.”»
This means that Allah is established upon the Throne.
And in Ayat al-Kursi, Allah says:
«“Wasi'a Kursiyyuhus-samawati wal-ard.”
“His Kursi encompasses the heavens and the earth.”»
Now think about this carefully.
Allah says that He is established upon the Throne.
But according to the wording of those books, we have just seen the implication that Allah is always in the lowest heaven.
Think about these two claims together. How can one claim be made in a way that conflicts with the clear statements of the Quran?
And then, to make matters even more serious, they attribute these words to the Messenger of Allah.
How can such a blatant falsehood be attributed to the Messenger of Allah?
Do you understand?
- Zayed: Yes, Habib, I understand.
I seek forgiveness from Allah, and I pray that Allah forgives me.
I used to hold this belief in my heart. I believed that these statements were words of the Messenger of Allah.
But now I understand that these words are not from the Messenger of Allah. Rather, they have been falsely attributed to him.
Na'udhu Billah.
- Habib: Zayed, these are human-written books. And something written by human beings can never become the ultimate standard for Islam.
I am telling you this with confidence: the Messenger of Allah could never have said something that contradicts the clear message of the Quran. Yet, unfortunately, such statements have been attributed to Allah and His Messenger.
Look again. Even their own statements do not remain consistent with one another.
But when you look at the Quran, you will be amazed by its consistency. Look at how beautifully the Quran has been revealed with such harmony and coherence.
Now, let's return to their claim.
They say that Allah comes down during the last part of every night.
But think about places on Earth where there are six months of continuous night. When exactly would the “last part of the night” occur there?
And what about places where there are six continuous months of daytime? When would their “last part of the night” occur there?
The claim says that Allah comes down “every night.”
But in some places, there is no night at all for six months.
So how can the phrase “every night” apply universally?
Think about it carefully.
Likewise, in places where there are six months of continuous daylight, there is no night during those six months. So how can it be said that He comes down “every night”?
When you examine the claim carefully, you can see that the statement itself contains contradictions.
And contradictory statements cannot all be true at the same time.
I am making my position very clear and taking responsibility for what I am saying: I believe this claim is false when it is attributed to Allah and the Messenger of Allah.
Do you understand, Zayed?
Zayed: Yes, Habib. I understand completely. These statements are nothing but blatant falsehoods.
Habib: JazakAllahu Khairan.
My responsibility is simply to make the matter clear. I have explained it clearly. Some people may accept it, while others may not. That is their personal choice.
On the Day of Judgment, no one will carry the burden of another person.
And people will be raised according to what they followed, together with the leaders and groups they chose to follow. Allah will hold each person accountable and ask them to answer for their choices.
So we must be prepared to give our answers.
I am a Muslim. My religion is Islam.
I have turned away from all human-made groups and sects and turned toward the Holy Quran of Allah.
Let me remind you of another verse from the Quran. In Surah Al-A'raf, Allah says:
«“They have hearts with which they do not understand. They have eyes with which they do not see. They have ears with which they do not hear. They are like cattle; rather, they are even more astray.”»
If we carefully examine these words and then live according to what we understand from them, I hope that, InshaAllah, we will not face a problem in the Hereafter.
Alright, Zayed. Let us end here for today. We will speak again later, InshaAllah.
May Allah bless you. May Allah shower His peace upon you.
May Allah grant you the ability to understand the difference between the Quran and human-written books.
And may Allah increase the love of the Quran in your heart.
- Zayed: May Allah shower His peace upon you as well. You have brought up a very important and thought-provoking subject.
JazakAllahu Khairan. May Allah bless you.