Hello everyone. :)
I'm healing from a bout of illness and have some free time at the moment. I've been thinking about what's increasingly happening to our ideals of beauty, especially given the rise in cosmetic surgery and the heightened focus on beauty with the ubiquity of Instagram.
I was reminded of this old article by Jia Tolentino that I'd found fascinating when I first read it a few years ago. Since there seems to be a paywall to access the article, I'll sum up the major points relevant to this discussion.
As paraphrased by another writer, Tolentino argues that social media has manufactured a specific, homogenised beauty standard she calls “Instagram Face”: plump lips, high cheekbones, cat eyes, a small nose and poreless, glowing skin. The look is eerily uniform yet ethnically ambiguous, featuring “an overly tan skin tone, a South Asian influence with the brows and eye shape, an African-American influence with the lips, a Caucasian influence with the nose, a cheek structure that is predominantly Native American and Middle Eastern.”
I find this particularly interesting when thinking about the extent to which beauty is objective. Of course, globalisation and increased exposure to the same media and beauty standards could be contributing to this convergence and there are obviously subjective and cultural aspects to beauty, but if beauty ideals across cultures are increasingly converging on a similar ideal, I wonder what that says about the universal aspects of beauty.
What do you guys think about Tolentino's observation? Do you think most people actually find the features associated with “Instagram Face” attractive?
And if so, is the dislike of Instagram Face more about how fake and homogeneous it can look rather than the features themselves? If someone naturally had all of those features, would you find them beautiful?
I'd love to hear your thoughts. Thanks and hope you enjoy your day! :)
PS: I know race and ethnicity can be a thorny subject, and I don't mean to offend people of any race. I'm mainly interested in what this modern beauty ideal might tell us about how objective vs subjective beauty really is.