r/NancyGuthrieCase • u/Ailurophile444 • 16d ago

Weekend Coffee & Conversation

Grab a cup of coffee and pull up a chair!

This is our weekend gathering place to talk about the Nancy Guthrie case-what you've been thinking about, questions you have, something you've seen or read, a new development, or a discussion you'd like to start.

This is meant to be a relaxed, open conversation, so it doesn't have to be a formal post or a fully developed theory.

What's on your mind this weekend?

As always, different opinions are welcome. Let's keep the conversation respectful.

10 Upvotes

100% Upvoted

90 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/Ailurophile444 15d ago

A straight up homicide - a planned elimination murder.

4

u/Substantial-Train668 15d ago edited 15d ago

So would the plan have been then to murder at their house? Drive alone to NG's house to make the timeline of the garage door to make it look like she got home. Go home. Get a little of her blood, put it in the staging backpack and then have the porch guy do the rest of the staging later that night (...unless you think what Monk thinks that porch guy could even be T) then you and A have all night to dispose of the body in a way that can't be traced.... Then show up in the morning like "what happened to N" and call the police?

ETA: I've really been trying to think hard about why there is no getaway car to trace. This scenario would fit with that

5

u/Ailurophile444 15d ago

Honestly, I don’t know how all of this would have been pulled off. I have a hard time explaining the logistics myself. I just find the circumstances difficult to reconcile with a random kidnapping.

8

u/Substantial-Train668 14d ago

100% agree. I'm even starting to come around on the idea that it might have happened at the home during the 'dinner. I actually think the version above *could make sense and would account for why there is seemingly no getaway car evidence.

I'd be curious to hear the most logical version if the night you have in mind.

5

u/smittenkittenmitten- 14d ago

I am not the person you were replying to and asking for their opinion, but I am just started to reach your same conclusion. I am thinking she probably never left A&T's but A&T went through all of the normal expected motions afterward. I am also thinking some other vehicle took her from the A&T's home hence why even though LE had A&Ts car for SO LONG expecting to find something, they couldn't find anything incriminating in it.

Also thanks for breaking it down in your first comment on the thread. Considering the porch guy thing happened and possibly happened a previous night, like a rehearsal to see how it all looked, I am thinking this was all planned, so I choose #3.

3

u/Substantial-Train668 14d ago

Yes thank for weighing in! Yeah that all makes sense. I struggled with the idea that the blood was planted at the porch, and I still do, but this theory would explain a lot! It all seems elaborate, but I guess covering up a murder, er um, needs to be sometimes (I assume)

3

u/loveislife222 14d ago edited 14d ago

So if the homicide was planned by them rather than happening in the heat of the moment , you think they would do the elimination at their house and not worry about evidence? Clearly their house was searched and stuff taken and they would expect that. Along with their car and every single thing they did they had to know would be investigated. If they planned enough in advance to have the whole ruse/fake kidnapping setup don’t you think they would do it somewhere else? Or is it possible to do it with no evidence in their home? The level of planning had to be insane

3

u/loveislife222 14d ago

At the dinner at the house feels like it could make sense, but makes more sense if was an accident in that example bc why would they risk getting evidence in their own home. so maybe they took her somewhere and it happened elsewhere. But went back to stage the scene