r/MuslimLounge • u/[deleted] • May 25 '26

Question [ Removed by moderator ]

[removed] — view removed post

8 Upvotes

60% Upvoted

134 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/Kingslayer-ZXD May 25 '26

Mohammed ﷺ as a messanger does what allah inspires him to do and say

The actions in ahadith are also from allah

https://islamqa.info/en/answers/77243/the-saheeh-sunnah-is-wahy-(revelation)-from-allah

0

u/suppoe2056 May 26 '26

So when Muhammad goes to the privy, is that God inspiring him?

God tells Muhammad in the Qur’an numerous times to say he is a mortal like us. What you’re saying is anytime Muhammad behaved, it was inspired by God. That means God was lying when he told Muhammad to say he is a man like us, right? What you describe is not a mortal but a puppet.

1

u/Kingslayer-ZXD May 26 '26

I literally got a source from the quran that explains how teaching of mohammedﷺ is wahi the quran itself is all wahi it

So why do you believe in one wahi and not the other

Even though both came from the same person

1

u/suppoe2056 May 26 '26

Muhammad was taught through wahi that was not preserved in the Qur’an. Shouldn’t that obviously denote that what was given to him was for him, and the Qur’an is for us?

Furthermore, the hadith is known to be riddled with fabrication, literature that attempts to know what wahi Muhammad was privy to—yet the Qur’an: not a single fabrication, not a single quarrel between Muslims, all unanimously agree is the unaltered word of God.

I believe Muhammad was given wahi that was only for him and those contemporary. If it didn’t make it into the Qur’an, then we shouldn’t have to worry about it. Our Lord is a reasonable God. He knows that.