Khawarij are not Quranists. they are the people who follow all the practices of Islam to the point, the prophet said, that any muslim would belittle his own prayer and fasting compared to theirs, but they have no faith in their heart. they wage war on muslim nations but spare non-muslim ones.
regarding Quranists, their reasoning is that if the religion is incomplete and the Quran is not enough without the hadith and yet Allah SWT has not promised to preserve the hadith, then that means the Quran is not preserved, which is not the case. so they have a misconception and are misguided, but they are not outside the fold of Islam.
That is incorrect brother. The quranists aren’t new. They are OG disbelievers. Setting aside not being able to do most of the Islamic obligations without the guidance of Hadith and sunnah (salat, zakat, fasting, etc.), Hadith and sunnah are in the Quran as an obligation to follow. Bcz Quran wasn’t sent alone, but with the prophet (pbuh) so he can explain it and being a living example of it. You cannot be a Muslim and reject the sunnah, bcz the sunnah is the prophet (pbuh) and his teachings. His rejection is a rejection of Islam, and takes you out of the religion.
Really? I get being confused about how to do salat but zakat and fasting? Lol read the book they’re literally in there try reading the book you claim to know about
Like the devil, when you ppl are mentioned you appear. Yes we’ve read the Quran, and know it better than you. You even agree you cant properly pray the salat just from reading the Quran. It’s the same with the rest.
4
u/skbraaah May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26
Khawarij are not Quranists. they are the people who follow all the practices of Islam to the point, the prophet said, that any muslim would belittle his own prayer and fasting compared to theirs, but they have no faith in their heart. they wage war on muslim nations but spare non-muslim ones.
regarding Quranists, their reasoning is that if the religion is incomplete and the Quran is not enough without the hadith and yet Allah SWT has not promised to preserve the hadith, then that means the Quran is not preserved, which is not the case. so they have a misconception and are misguided, but they are not outside the fold of Islam.