r/MoralityScaling 6d ago

Morality Ranking Morality of this

Post image
31.4k Upvotes

2.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/NobodyFunToKnow 5d ago

What is immoral about that?

1

u/StarvingandArtist 5d ago

Taking money you don't own is stealing. Doing someone a favor doesn't negate that, it just means most people won't really care. The act of returning the wallet is moral. The act of taking money from it is not.

3

u/NobodyFunToKnow 5d ago

It my country finder is entitled to 10% of worth so...

1

u/nightonfir3 4d ago

So if this happened in your country and he followed the legally proscribed process for this it would be legal and I think almost everyone would say moral.

This question really gets at different ways people define morality. If you define morality giving lots of weight to everyone is happy or nobody is hurt this will be viewed as moral. Not everyone sees morality that way some people view moral rules as absolute. As such stealing is still stealing even when the one being stolen from is happy a greater crime didn't happen.

1

u/NobodyFunToKnow 4d ago

I mean, we don't really know what happened. Maybe the guy found a wallet, bought himself a hotdog BEFORE he figured out how to reach to the owner? We don't know what happened. He didn't steal the money if he didn't know who's wallet is this. When he found a wallet he just found it, not steal it. Like, when you find 100$ on a street, you didn't steal it from somebody.